Extreme Pizza – Wantage

Worst wings ever! So tiny I thought they were a joke. Pizza was hardly edible. Think they caused stomach issues too! Can’t even get a cup of ice here. No idea why space farms would let this chain in their shop. Anyone who thinks they make good pizza here has never had real pizza. Also what kind of pizza place has all their pies listed without sauce and all have cheddar in their cheese?! You have to request sauce!

We didn’t know about this place until we drove by the entrance to Space Farms. Wow was I surprised. Different than your run of the mill NJ pie. We ordered the Yard Sale specialty pizza. Crust cooked to perfection and the toppings kept on coming. Sausage, olives, red onions, mushrooms, tomatoes, pepperoni, salami, green peppers and more. Lost track. They had me at red onion! Was taken aback by the price. A bit higher than I am used to but, totally worth it. Highly recommend. They clearly earn what they charge. I see more yard sales in my future!

Had seen brochures, but really didn’t know where this place was until I happened to drive by Space Farms in Beemerville, and there it is! Right at the zoo. Actually a great location, as there is nothing near the area – you have to go to Branchville, Sussex or Newton (or farther) to get anything to eat. AND THEY DELIVER!
Stopped with a friend and we tried PANDORA’S BOX: Spinach, artichoke hearts, sun-​dried tomatoes, feta, garlic, fresh basil, oregano and mozzarella. – and it was very good, and NOT GREASY. Stopped for lunch a few days later, and the spicy Thai chicken salad is yummy, and actually spicy!
I’m delighted to have a place near by that serves fresh, interesting pizzas with a selection of crusts (whole wheat, regular, gluten-​free) and lots of different toppings, especially so many vegetables!
And you can BYOB if you want. Hope this place makes it – it’s a nice change from the local pizza places.

Not your typical NJ Pizza joint. I was so surprised! This is a California pizza chain, but don’t let that keep you from trying it! The pizza is a thin crust. With 8 Veggin’ Out pizzas, 12 Carnivore pizzas in 5 sizes. Homade sauces include Tomato, Pesto, black beans and salsa, hummus, spicy hoisin, sweet bbq, tangy ranch and buffalo wing. 7 Cheeses including Soy, 11 meats including smoked bacon, 22 veggies fruits and nuts and delicious fresh spices. There is a combination for everyone, Or make your OWN combination. Each pie is made fresh to order. AND GLUTEN FREE IS AN OPTION.
They also have a unique selection of Monster Subs, and Fresh salads. Looking forward to trying those next time.
We had one Classic cheese pie (the sauce is a delicious ripe plum tomato sauce) a Pandora’s Box (spinach, artichoke hearts, sundried tomatoes, feta, garlic, fresh basil, oregano and mozzarella) and an order of chicken wings. The wings were tender, juicy and not greasy. Yum!
The person who took our order was perky, patient and our order was correct. We had an awful connection from our phone. Plus she included an extra order of the Pow Pows! dessert stix with our order. Nice touch. The delivery arrived hot and on time. The delivery person was pleasant and efficient. Nice to have the cheese cake dessert kept cold and sparate from the pizza.
Give it a try, I’d like them to stick around :)