The Pizza Shop

We were visiting Lake George for a weekend getaway and we’re looking for a pizza spot and happened to find this gem! The décor was simple and minimal but it was very clean and open. We was a party of 10 and they attended us quickly and were super friendly. When we finally got our food it was nothing short than amazing! Pizza were excellent thin, crispy crust slices, the calzone was freshly baked with cheesy goodness, and the garlic knots were absolutely wonderful! Definitely coming back when we visit again!

Got the Stromboli and was very impressed! All ingredients were fresh and sauce was delicious! Brought back memories from when we visited Italy!

A Pizza Shop in the heart of Warrensburg, sitting slightly off the street with ample parking. I stopped in and treated myself to «a slice». Wow was it good!
I engaged in a conversation with a great young couple about the differences between New York Pizza and what they serve, using the same name in California. Seriously, California Pizza makers should either be arrested for fraud or sent here for cooking lessons.
Seriously, this place is clean, we’ll run, lots of personality and they make an awesome product. If you live within 5 miles, they’ll deliver for free. Unfortunately my campground is just outside that radius… however it’s worth the trip into Warrensburg for what just may be the best Pizza I have ever eaten.

Best Pizza in the Lake George Area! Don’t waste your time anywhere else. Real Italian pizza at great prices! Doesn’t get any better than this!

Ordered a supreme small pizza to go. It was delicious. The crust was great and the toppings fresh. I would order from them again.

We had a cheese pizza, which we have ordered in many other pizza restaurants. This one was very unremarkable even though the chef was from Italy. They didn’t even have ice or lemons for the water.

Best pizza in the North Country as far as I’m concerned. Calzone’s, Stromboli’s, wraps
Everything prepared fresh including the dough. They even offer a gluten free dough.
This one’s a winner.
Update 9÷1÷15 — Had a yen for some wings the other night. I tried their hot variety — oh so meaty & large! Done to perfection. I’m just glad I don’t get the itch for wings very often, or I’d be back to packing on the weight instead of taking it off. I whole heartedly endorse the Pizza Shop in Warrensburg, NY.

Opened within the last 10 days or so and the pizza is very good. Classic, thin crust pizza. I had a couple slices on my first visit. $ 5– gets you 2 generously sized slices and a drink. The menu includes the usual… subs; hot and cold, calzones, strombolis, salads, «platters» which are dinners with bread and a nice selection of creative pizza types for those who don’t want to build their own. Notably, they say they bake their own bread and rolls daily. I’ll definitely go back soon. No apparent website yet. This is the best of the pizza places in Warrensburg… I’ve tried them all. I’d give them 5 stars if they ground their crushed pepper finer. Picky yes. Try Italian food in Utica and you will be served what they call «Utica grind» crushed red pepper. Grinding the pepper finer releases a lot more flavor. 10 – 15 seconds (not powder– just finer) in a good processor changes the generic crushed red from big flakes that don’t shake out well to something more enjoyable.