Manhattan Pizza

I am embarrassed to say how often I order from Manhattan! This is the best pizza place around. I have tried almost every menu item and have yet to be disappointed! My favorite menu item is their wings. Highly recommend Manhattan Pizza.

Their pizza crust has absolutely no taste, which makes their pizza taste nasty, however the vibe and style of this restaurant is cool, and their French fries are amazing. I don’t go there for pizza, I go there for their sandwiches and fries.

First of all: The women’s bathroom needed attention. That has to be said. The décor was nice. My Shish Taouk platter was not large. A small-​ish serving of french fries and not much lettuce, and they forgot the onions. My kids enjoyed their pizza and my husband said his sandwich was good, but I don’t think we’ll be back. A $ 30 lunch deserves more.

We ordered delivery tonight from this new pizza place. We were presently surprised.
We had a few things to give it a try.
The Manhattan burger: It was rather large. Although slightly undercooked had good flavor and lots of condiments.
Small pizza –Ba da Bing: very good pizza. There could be a little more sauce but overall very tasty dough and fresh toppings.
Wings: pretty average although the option for extra crispy was nice.

I got pizza once to go for dinner at home and once for lunch dining in. It’s a good lunch deal, but I’m not crazy about the pizza. They get a good crowd it seems like, I’m just not the biggest fan. The restaurant is clean and there is an outdoor patio as well. I’ll likely give it another try, but it wouldn’t be my first choice.

I love the chicken pita dinner, it is excellent. The fries are really good! The pizza is ok, the sauce is sweeter than I like. The service is great!

This was my first time here and the pizza was amaaazzziingggg!
Friendly staff and it’s in a great location! Ughhh I’m getting hungry just thinking about it. I recommend the pepperoni and sausage pizza if you want to start out with something basic. Definitely coming back soon!

After a day spent leaf-​peeping on Shenandoah’s Skyline Drive, we were feeling reaaaaally hungry, and I in particular was craving something cheesy, greasy, and satisfying. The solution, of course — pizza! Manhattan Pizza seemed to be the best bet for us to hit up on our way back to DC, so we made a little detour for some hot and fresh ‘za.
The place is new — and feels very new. Staff was polite and our pie was ready pretty quickly. The pizza itself is decent; it hit the spot for sure, but it wasn’t anything out of the ordinary. If anything, it was a bit too chewy for me, and slightly too heavy on the cheese. But overall, it was pretty good, and a fine price too ($ 12.99 for a large). One complaint is that the ice tea was totally warm, ewww.
There was only one other table of patrons when we came in (early evening on a Sunday), but there were plenty of people coming in and out to pick up pies.

Well first time I tried the place I was very underwhelmed with the steak and cheese (I miss jerrys). But also chalked it up to being a new place. Gave it another shot today delivery and while the pizza was good the gyro was horrible. I had asked for no tomatoes or onions. But they didn’t put any feta on it either. The meat was big chunks (should be thin slices) and burnt. Since the pizza was ok I gave them three stars. But it’s nothing special.

Not sure what to make of this place yet. Let’s start at the beginning.
Took a long time to order, the line was out the door. I can understand you are busy but customer service is key. You had quite a few people standing behind the counter, and what appeared to be a manager standing to the side of the counter but not really helping, just barking orders. The employees taking the orders were slow, unfriendly and just shouted NEXT, instead of smiling, apologizing for the wait and politely taking our order.
The dining room was clean, table cleared and cleaned. Though there is only one place for garbage, so with a line out the door, it was hard for folks to navigate from one side of the dining room to the other to throw out their trash. Easy fix!
We ordered a Caesar salad and calzone. Salad came out quickly, was a healthy portion and lettuce was crisp. I enjoyed the fact that the dressing came on the side but it was not «ceasar» was not… creamy, and it was not good. The calzone dough was previously frozen… this was disappointing. We thought it was overly salty and the ham inside was just cut up deli slices. On point though… the marinara!
Overall, we will be back to try the pizza. Hope second time is the charm!

I have had a couple sandwiches from here for lunch. Also had the pizza. So far it’s been good. Taking home late night dinner and trying the pasta.

Yes, I’m a fan. I miss Jerry’s so much but if you have to replace them, then Manhattan Pizza may as well be it. We had a large pepporoni and sausage pizza. Regular salad with Ranch and an order of regular wings/​crunchy. All three were great. No wilty lettuce… Just enough grease on the pizza to lick your fingertips and still be o. k with it. Everyone loved the regular crunch wings. It was like minature fried chicken! lol. We ordered delivery and they were here in no time! We were surprised at how fast they were. We are glad they are in town.

This is the best pizza I have had in Warrenton. The sauce was delicious and the crust was perfect. I can’t wait to eat here again.

Came here with my husband. We split the pizza deal which is 2 large slices of pizza and a soda. The pizza is great! Texture and flavor on point. Not overloaded with sauce or cheese so the ratios are great so nothing overpowers the other. By far one of the best pizza joints around and one of the best I’ve had in all my travels.
We also split the gyro which tastes fresh, full of flavor, and you can tell the meat was carved off a skewer. Not that frozen and fried crap you tend to get. The pita itself is fluffy and has great texture. The tzaziki sauce is light and fresh tasting. All ingredients are great quality.
We will be returning to this establishment regularly.

Tried the pizza yesterday, it sucks. The pizza doesn’t have any taste, dough looks and taste like it is frozen. How this pizza was voted #1 anywhere is beyond me, I can get a better pizza at Costco. Do yourself a favor and stick with Joe &Vinnies.