Christiano’s Pizza

I live in Chicago and Chicago style is great and all, but it’s refreshing to have a thin slice, brick oven style pizza! It’s one of those pizzas I find myself folding in half and eating it because I can’t eat it fast enough! Their calzones are great, but I think the pizza is the way to go.

Amazing pizza; great service; very clean; yummy salads; a must stop if you are anywhere close to wautoma!!!

Excruciating. That is the word to sum up my experience. I ordered carry out and they actually forgot about my pizza. Not the friendliest bunch of employees as I walked in I got a stare down by the kids behind the counter and I witnessed one messing with his head after taking his helmet off and not wash his hands. I had to look away because I didn’t even want to know if he actually touched anything.
In any event to sum it up the pizza took 15 minutes longer than I was quoted, they use canned mushrooms as they were waxy, pizza was burned on one side and soggy on the middle. Totally not impressed.

I’ll start off by saying im from chicago. So I definitely have had some pizza in my lifetime. Huge fan of thin crust. Every time we go to the wife’s parents house in wautoma this is a must. Love the fresh ingredients. Everything taste like its fresh from the garden. The staff is great and the environment is very relaxing and clean. The service was quick as can be. I drive a truck for a living so I always am down for a nice meal and a beer. Christiano’s is by far the best pizza money can buy period!

Inconsistent pizza … sometimes good and sometimes terrible. Very expensive. The dining room is LOUD especially on weekends.

We stopped in for a quick lunch and I as surprised to see they now have wine on the menu.
My sister suggested splitting a pannini. We chose the chicken and artichoke. The sandwich arrived and it was huge! Do glad we decided to split it. We also each tried a cup of the daily soup, the roasted red pepper. The sandwich and the soup were both delicious and well made.
Service was prompt and friendly. Do glad Wautoma has this as a go to.

Not many restaurants in Wautoma, Wi. We have family that lives in the area and we were visiting from California. My husbands sister said this place was good. The hostess seated all 6 of us at the round table in the back room, along the window. It was a perfect place for us. We ordered the Cheese bread, which was delicious. We ordered the Danza pizza which was very tasty, it had a nice crisp crust that wasn’t burnt and the toppings didn’t fall off. YEAH.
The only downfall for me, was that I had to LOOK AT THE 10 Commandments through the entire meal, as they were posted on the wall behind our table. I do not believe in organized religion or god for that matter. Then again I am rural America.
Overall the food and service were very good.

Let’s start out positive: Their garlic cheese bread was to die for kind of wished I would have just had that for dinner! They had an outdoor seating area that was very clean a nice place to sit so you don’t have to sit in the busy and loud dining area. But the main course the pizza was not anything to rave about. The outsides of the crust were burnt so I did not eat that part. The crust was not that great and either was the sauce. The toppings (cheese, sausage, veggies) were all great. I also like the fact that they serve beer and wine now!

While on vacation last night we ordered 3 different take out pizzas for our family. Within 15 – 20 minutes we had our pizzas and were on our way back to the cottage. We were delighted with the pizzas. Each one had different toppings. They were excellent in flavor and a nice oven backed crust.
Good service and great food. You can’t go wrong eating here or getting take out.

Being from chi town I know pizza and Christiania does an excellent job. Delivery is fast and consistent. Delicious!

Cod special was well cooked and tasty
Spicy chicken rigatoni special was very good with loads of chicken in a creamy sauce
Salads were ok with good housemade dressings
Garlic bread — should have ordered more!
Pasta was a nice change from their great pizzas

I was in Oshkosh for a race, and after 12 miles, my friends and I did not feel like going out. My friends and I had a gluten free pizza delivered to our hotel, and it did not disappoint! The gluten free crust was fantastic. Most GF crusts are thin and crispy, and it was a nice change to have a thicker crust. We had the Danza and all of the toppings were excellent. We also had a few cups of gelato delivered with the pizza. The gelato was delicious!

I feel like Christianos used to be much better. Their portions were much bigger I felt which made it ok to pay their prices but now that you don’t get a whole ton of food it just doesn’t seem worth it to me. Its the best for this area. It is pretty awesome that they deliver to anywhere. I’ve ordered food from there that has been to die for but I’ve also had food that I’ve been extremely disappointed with. Guess it just depends on who is cooking it…

Christiano’s is a solid option when you’re at the lake and you don’t want to cook. We went here to beat the heat a few weeks ago during a crazy heat wave, and while the ovens were blazing in there and it wasn’t as cool as we’d like — we really enjoyed the pizza and the service never fails to be Wisconsin-​friendly. Bonus that they deliver given that everything is so spread out around there. We had the Hawaiian and the Dad’s special — both were devoured. My grandma wanted spaghetti and meatballs and they were happy to have her order a kid’s portion since she didn’t want so much food. I’m still not sure what kid could eat that much pasta, but it was nice they gave her the option. Glad to see this place thriving in Wautoma and we will defintely be back!

Christiano’s is great. Whenever I am in the area I need to visit! The pizza is great, the service is very friendly, and the atmosphere is relaxing.

A-​MAZING pizza! I would have to agree and say that it may be the best in the state. They deliver a good distance as well and the staff is super friendly. I would recommend Christiano’s anytime… family time, out with friends or date night!
*I do wish they had a liquor license so that I could enjoy a beer with such delectable pizza!

Still incredibly good brick oven pizza. Also great calzones. Salads aren’t bad either, you get very generous portions. The owner has now opened stores in Green Lake and Oshkosh as well.

We stopped in for lunch today since we were in Wautoma. I had never been in the restaurant and upon entry, you are met by the hostess. I noticed that even though the building is old, the interior was newer (it had that small town feel to it) and it was clean.
We ordered a Italian sausage and a meatball sandwich to go. I was told the wait would be 15 minutes and it was just that. The reason for the 15 minute wait was because of other «to go» orders ahead of us.
My wife had the meatball sandwich which she said was excellent and on a fantastic 3″ x 6″ very fresh Italian bread roll. It was a bit messy but in a very good way. I had the Italian sausage which was a 3″ x 6″ patty which fit nicely on the roll. There was a fair amount of Italian sauce, but it had no onions or cheese, which was disappointing as that would have really made the sandwich even more memorable. Even without those items, it was fantastic. I wish the clerk would have asked I wanted the extras as I would have said yes… definitely.
We sat outside and could not happen but notice that Cristiano’s had a lot of people coming and going. They also had 5 delivery vehicles in the parking lot, so they must really have a huge fan club.
We will stop in again when in town for dinner. Thanks again for a great lunch.

The service was awesome from the time we walked in the door, until we walked out (full and satisfied).
They will do half and half with their specialty pizzas and the size and price are great.
The only downside is that they do NOT have a changing table in the bathroom.

Best Pizza in Wisconsin!
If you like thin crust pizza you’ll like Christiano’s a lot. Bill’s in Stevens Point is okay, Faye’s in Sheboygan is good, Edwardo’s in La Crosse is better and about the same as Balisteris in Wauwatosa; Christiano’s based on at least six different samples is the best. As an aside, since I’m reviewing pizza in Wisconsin, Slice of Chicago in Sparta is about like Faye’s. All of these places are locally owned for those of you who prefer locally owned establishments.
Although we’ve not yet tried it, I have it on pretty good authority that Il Ritrovo pizzeria in Sheboygan is excellent. Plan to give it a try next time we visit Sheboygan.