Anthony’s Coal Fired Pizza

I must ask I this the same ownership as the Fair Lawn location? Total s %xt show… the food is always good when you get it… the he pizzas, salads drinks are all fairly priced… but the big but is if your staff can’t execute then it’s just another eatery… I was there and we sat at the bar last Sunday about 5ish… our drink order did take some time when the bar had 6 people sitting at it… the restaurant half full… so our drinks come all is good I am hoping that the here is better customer service… the here hen we order a salad… theherehenhey are pretty good along with two meatballs… our salads came all is going ok… I look around and 5 of the 6 people sitting at the bar drinks have evaporated… finally we get a refill… but my meatballs are still not served… so I say to the young lady cancel my meatballs and we will order a pie… she comes back and says the meatballs are on the house… we eat the pie and get the remaining slices wrapped… so she asked if we ever got the meatballs… I said no… then the words flow off her lips… well you didn’t want them anyway… wow…poor service starts from the top… the menu is very small which is ok with me… but they can’t deliver on it… they should be ashamed of themselves… poor service is poor service and I experienced it twice at this location and the Fair Lawn lications… should I try the Ramsey location… they definitely hire from a duck pond…

Had a party of 18 people at home and used the catering menu. First, the catering Mgr. Liz could not have been more helpful, pleasant and professional. Their catering pricing is a bargain. We had more food than we needed (which is always a good thing) and a great assortment of foods. They let you choose which pizzas you want. I added the ribs add’l which was the only miss. They were too spicy for most guests. But everything else was perfect. Most of my guests have not been to the restaurant, but will now! I and I know some are planning on catering a party using Anthony’s in Wayne

Great pizza! Crust is to die for and cheese is very fresh along with the toppings. Wings and ribs are really good too. My daughter loves their meatballs which you can but by the pot. Highly recommend it.

Their food I really good I enjoyed it. There’s a lot of pizzas to chose from and the prices are not to bad

Great ambiance and clean. Went on a Friday night, just want I needed to unwind. Nice bar and great pizza. I mean fantastic. Wait staff was polite and friendly.

Just what I needed, yet another ACFP this one being overly convenient to my new office. It’s really not enough that I eat at their Livingston location once, usually twice a week and hit up Fair Lawn ever so slightly less. In typical Anthony’s fashion, the pizza and wings are spectacular. As always, the Paul & Young Ron tops the list but beware of hot peppers as they can overpower the flavor. Sweet are a much better choice. I also opted for a Side Chick, 5 wings smothered in sauteed onions with foccacia bread on the side.
Whomever does the hiring for this chain is clearly on top of their game. Service is always really friendly and attentive without being too much in your face. Food arrives promptly, steaming hot and is wonderfully consistant. Beer is cold, usually local and fresh. Hit them up on Wednesday nights for Martini’s & Meatballs where you can sample from a roving, hand served buffet while sipping cheap-​o martinis.
As has been written in numerous online reviews and newspapers, Anthony’s really is the best pizza chain in the country. They’re the ones to beat or to emulate. No matter the location, everything is just about perfect. Love ACFP!

I’m always leery of a place that doesn’t post prices on their web page.

This place nails it in so many ways, great food, atmosphere and people! The menu is simple, a few things done very well. It’s rare (in my experience) to get consistently good service in this area unless you pay a boatload. Enjoy the Philly cheesesteak pizza, it’s amazing!

Tried to go for dinner at 6:30 tonight… Half hour wait… Sorry food isn’t that good!!!

Their pizza is pretty decent, not out of this world though. My friend and I ordered the cauliflower and eggplant pizzas and they were good, but not worth what they’re priced. The waitstaff is very friendly and constantly checking in, and I will definitely come back for their $ 3 Yuenglings

Stopped in for lunch with a friend. Beautiful day out so side wall to bar was open. Had salad and meatball sandwich with long hot Italian peppers. Nice place with a nice atmosphere and servers were excellent. Will definitely be returning here.

I have been to coal fired pizza places before and for a chain it’s pretty good. I wouldn’t rank it the best ever, but they do a good job at a fair price. The service was extremely friendly the entire time. The waiter new we were new to going to their chain and brought us sample chicken wings. The wings aren’t deep fried. They are marinated over night, cooked in their coal fired oven and served under a mind of cooked onions. If you love spicy, don’t expect it from these. They are however still pretty good. I like spicy, so I wouldn’t bother getting them in the future. They also had a good selection of beers on tap, I had a seasonal pumpkin beer which was really good. Overall, you will enjoy this place, it’s not a ten but it’s still really good pizza.

Great pizza and wings. I love buffalo sauce so for me to like wings like theirs which are done a lot differently was pretty unexpected. We have only had takeout so far but the hostess was very polite and they were speedy. The bottle of coke we ordered was randomly only ¾ full which was strange but probably just a fluke.

Gonna make this one short bc there is not much too say. Have had good experiences here and not so good. Craving pizza the other night we stopped in here. Got the wings and a house salad as an app. Wings were extremely over cooked. Salad… ehh something was different maybe they changed the lettuce? Pizza came out and we still had half our apps to eat which is my biggest PET PEEVE! By the time we got to the pizza it was cold and not enjoyable. Hoping it was an off night for them #disappointed

Cooking things on coal is not only a cool marketing idea, but it makes food taste good! This is my second time eating at this location, and the food does not disappoint. I tried the chicken wings for the first time. They are served with carmelized onions and pita bread, which is definitely unique. I couldve used some hot sauce on them, and I learned that AFC is a hot sauce free zone. They didnt even have a bottle of Tabasco!
The pizza is awesome, but you jave to like your crust well
, limp, wimpy dough here… its thin and baked in the fires of coal oven hell! I Everything on the menu is made fresh to order.
They have a pretty awesome selection of craft beer, which pairs nicely with the pizza and wings
Definitely a fan, just wish there was one closer to my house!

I come for the tomato basil pizza, meat balls, and draft beer. They always have an awesome selection on tap and the staff is great.

Came here today for the first time & loved it, the ingredients are fresh the sauce & mushrooms tasted great
The crust is well done so if u don’t like that u might not like it. They give u a lot of whatever topping u order which I loved. & the drinks are reasonably priced
Next time I come back I’ll sit on the outside bar which looks pretty cool

Came here for lunch. Pulled into the lot, saw the pizza place and thought «let’s have some pizza for lunch.»
Well when I walked in I was quite surprised, certainly not the «typical pizza joint.»
Nice atmosphere, full bar, out door seating.
Food was great. Service was great.
4 stars just due to it being a little pricey for a pizza and such.
Will return.

Great pizza place. Upscale sports bar/​restaurant.
If you like thin crust and crispy pizza, you’ll enjoy Anthony’s. If you don’t, you wont. It’s that simple. Their motto is «Pizza well done» in both senses of the phrase.
For lunch I usually order the personal pizza with mushrooms and I couldn’t ask for better. I ordered the cauliflower pizza today and it was fantastic. Loaded with cauliflower that’s moist and sprinkled with breadcrumbs. It’s a good sized pizza, a little expense at $ 9 but you’re paying for the food and the atmosphere. Go to a small, non-​fancy local pizzeria if you don’t want to pay $ 9 for a personal pie.
The wings are great too! I gotta try the meatballs next time!

Good for what it is, a casual pizza spot with a good selection of tasty pizzas and a bar. The remainder of the menu is pretty limited.
How places still manage to get a liquor license in Wayne is beyond me but I was thankful for their $ 2 Peroni «game day» drafts on the Sunday we went. They also have ½ price craft beers on Mondays & Tuesdays.
Outdoor seating in Wayne is a bonus, even if it’s right on the parking lot. We sat outside on a cool, clear early September night and we enjoyed it. We watched the sun set over Party City across the other side of Route 23… Romantic.
We had a ½ broccoli & sausage and ½ white pie. Both were tasty and satisfying.
We tried a small order of their famous meatballs — they were good, but not as good as my homemade balls ;)
The inside dining room seems really loud, based on the acoustics of the room
Give it a try, especially on a night they have drink specials. The wings looked good, will try them next time.
Still wondering … Do the actually make the dough in store or are they pre-​made??? Anyone know?