Pie Guys Pizza

Absolutely love pie GuyZ ! Always consistently great ! I usually order a buffalo chicken salad or a cheesesteak wrap. Fresh ingredients and great flavors all around. I am always greeted by the staff with a warm welcome ! Pie GuyZ is a great addition to the Wayne community. If you haven’t tried them, I recommend you do !

Honestly I don’t know how this place has more than two stars. My thought is that most reviews are from people who have never had good pizza. If you’re in the area my suggestion is to just get Positano’s, it’s better. The pizza is mediocre at best and the service leaves something to be desired. Granted I’ve only gotten take out but I think that should speak volumes. If your only job/​encounter with me is to hand me my pizza where I’ve already given you at the very least a 20% tip (as a former waitress and pizza delivery person I can’t tip less even of you suck) couldn’t you suck it up and be polite. The first time I ordered from pie guys I was told by the delivery person that «I was lucky he even came out“because it was close to closing time and the second time the driver rang the bell 15 seconds later, I literally did not even put shoes on, the driver laid on the buzzer non-​stop until I got ti the door. He literally waited less than 1 ½ minutes from the time he rang the bell till the time I had the pizza back in my apartment and he had to be obnoxious. The pizza was not the worst but far from the best I’ve had. I give the pizza a 2 ½ with the shitty service it gets a 2.

Let me start off by saying that the owners of this place are the nicest guys ever and that I wish them the most success in their future because not only are they awesome but their food is great. I love that this place popped up in wayne because it blows other pizza places around here out of the water, great work guys!

They also know me as Kenny. I’ve been a Wayne native now for 27 years and have tried every pizzeria numerous times throughout my life. These guys are by far the most respectful owners I’ve ever met and their pizza is astonishing and it’s the cleanest pizzeria I’ve ever seen. They have the best chicken fingers and wings I’ve ever had! Their pan pizzas are phenomenal and their overall pizza selection is ridiculous! Compared to Vinnies, Neil’s, Brother Bruno’s stand Pizza One this is by far the best pizzeria in Wayne HANDS DOWN! Best part of all is their delivery is insanely fast and always fresh and hott! I truly hope that these guys continue to have amazing success in their business venture and open many more locations in the near future because people need to have the opportunity to taste food this good at least one in their lives lol KEEP UP THE GREAT WORK PIZZA ONE!

I’m in shock. How does this place not have 5 stars?! Amazing pizza and super creative recipes. The owners are so nice and they always remember what we like. They’re extremely passionate about their craft and it shows. Hands down the best pizza in Wayne. I’d go so far as saying in NJ’s top ten. If you’re in the area and you’re looking for a delicious slice, look no further. They use extremely fresh ingredients. The best zeppoles and garlic knots too. I always leave extremely full and extremely satisfied. I’d love to see them grow and add more locations! Keep it up, Pie Guys!

ORDINARY pie. Fairly tasteless and sparse on the toppings. Ordered the $ 25 deal comes with zeppoles I was asked if I wanted Nutella. I said does it come with and was told «it can» only to find out they charged me $ 1.00 extra. A low practice. The boneless chicken wings are a drippy soggy mess of nastiness. I had to drain the container. They are a shapeless mass of gnarly. The garlic knots and zeppoles are frozen chewy not crispy that turn to rocks when they cool.
The delivery was prompt but I’ll take a pass and order from Vinnys Pizzarama next time.

Tried it tonight. I’m giving it four stars bc I am comparing it to the pizza in the neighborhood. If I were in nyc it would get 2 stars. This is one of the better pizza places in Wayne. They have the round garlic knots. my daughter loved them, I thought they were ok. The deep dish pizza was good for Wayne; not good compared to nonna’s in e. village, rays, or any good spots in nyc.

Just tried Pie Guys for the first time. I’m kind of a grandma’s pizza expert. I have high standards and a love my grandmas! I’m happy to report that Pie Guys does it right! Thin, crisp, tasty, fresh… It hits all the right buttons. Give it a try and I think you’ll agree.

This place is on point. Great pizza, great wings, AMAZING garlic knots and fast delivery! Plus they have a sweet deal including all of the above plus zepoles for $ 25. Oh and you can order online, which is clutch for all us introverted phone haters.

This was my first time at Pie Guys. I ordered the Grandma Sicilian pie at noon on Grubhub for carryout. Friendly service at the counter warranted a deposit into the tip jar. I noticed the box was not very warm when I took possession of it. Reheating was necessary at home. The taste was alright for this thin Sicilian style pizza. I found the dough a little spongy as I really had to bite into it in order to rip off a piece.

This place is great, tried it for the first time tonight! Very nice people. Got the Meatball and Ricotta Pan Pizza, Caesar Salad, Hot Wings, and Garlic Knots. The Pan pizza is delicious, tastes great and not as greasy and heavy as Pizza Hut. The Caesar salad is very good, and the fresh ground pepper adds a nice flavor. The wings are good, just a little dry for my taste. The garlic knots are very yummy and chewy. The food definitely tastes fresh. All of the menu items look very appealing, I would definitely come here again!

I recently moved to Wayne and have tried out all the «popular» pizza places and my vote is for Pie Guys. I love the pizza’s I ordered, delivery to your home is quick and friendly. I’m ordering the pizza with the vodka sauce tonight — the crust I have had is thin and I like it this way. Yum!

These guys continue to please, great service and even better food. Honestly surprised this place isn’t Jam packed with people on a daily basis.

Great staff clean place great selection of pizza delivery is also punctual and polite. Way to go guys

Delivery fast and pie was hot, that’s the good part! Taste was good and crust was perfect. However the pie was lacking toppings for being their signature pie. I counted 12 slices of pepperoni and 15 pieces of assuage on a large, and a couple of slices didn’t have any meats. Maybe an off night for them but I will not be returning.

Really delicious pizza and great customer service! We have tried two other pizza places in the area and they were so awful, so happy to finally find a place we can frequent for our family’s pizza nights! Keep up the good work, it is appreciated on our end :).

Fast delivery… Granted it was a Wednesday night, but it got here nice and hot! Had the Grandma Sicilian and Margarita Pies. Very tasty, and not too greasy.
Definitely will be ordering from them again!

Pizza is really good but I have to say the garlic parm fries were soooo delicious!!! I ordered delivery and driver came in a timely manner. Person on phone taking my order was nice and courteous. I’m defiantly ordering again

Pie Guys are making some of the best pizza in the area. It’s thin, and very tasty. My office will be ordering from Pie Guys from here on out.
As a guy who grew up in the New Jersey/​New York area, I have a taste for good pizza. Pie Guys are the real deal.

Tried them for the first time today. Looks a lot like the old Ciao Bella which closed. Order in the back and they will bring out your order.
I had one pepperoni slice and one plain slice. Good thin crust pizza and served very hot. Extensive menu. I will post some pix.
Second visit — a very good cheesesteak sandwich for $ 7.00.