Brother’s Pizza

The pizza was delicious! And the service was fast and attentive. Love the restaurant atmosphere and it has lots of seating choices, perfect for a small or large group.

I’ve always loved all the brothers locations. Until this one. I’ve eaten at all the brothers many times. The wings were as close as you can get to bar wings while eating out with kids. Not anymore. They changed their wings. The new ones have an odd taste. And now the last two times I’ve eaten there have been bad a experience. One the waitress was rude by almost running into people while rushing through the restaurant and we were here second table. And this latest time I again order wings. I was hoping the change was only temporary. But no. Same nasty wings and now under cooked. I show them to my server and she asks if I want her to take them back. I said no I’ll just eat my stuffed mushrooms (that she forgot with the original order) and I didn’t eat 5 of 12 wings after I saw the raw one and eaten the beginning which were not crunchy at all. So she gives me 10% off. Really. 10% for serving me raw chicken? Will not go back. They have lost a long time customer. The only reason I gave them 2 starts and not 1. Is they do still have good pizza.

Pizza was so/​so but wings and salad were excellent! Pizza was thin, not a lot of sauce, toppings slid right off and almost $ 2 per additional topping!

We love the pizza and the subs. The delivery is prompt for the most part. Sometimes on really busy nights it’s takes longer than usual but is you call in and your nice they will do anything to help out. We love this place‼‼

I love the Brothers Pizza in Greencastle, PA. This one in Waynesboro is horrible. I will drive to Greencastle from now on. I ordered a chef salad and it was nothing but lettuce and a few onions. No thanks. I won’t return.

The waitress Cindy is a complete… b – ch. I have never felt so rushed, and an inconvenience as I did with her. Not to mention, she charged us for things that we originally asked for but didn’t get. So when I brought it to her attention she simply cut me off, and said I’ll fix it. Came back and rapidly showed me the small difference in price, and handed the receipt off to me. Sorry I refuse to pay for something I never got. The way she speaks to the other employees is horrible as well. Also I understand the cooks are in the back, but they should clean up their appearance a little bit. The one woman cook looks like she is from the backwoods, unprofessional at its best. I remember the young girls Amy, Holly, and Tammy that worked there, and were so friendly and efficient. Obviously those girls moved onto better things, but where can you find good help anymore?

I get it, it took some time to accept but where I come from pizza shop owners /​employees may speak English as a 2^nd language to Italian. Plane and specialty pizzas rock BBQ chix. and loaded Sicilian are favorites !

We went in for Breakfast on Saturday morning. Let me say NEVER again, on a weekend. And if I visit during the week; if the skinny blonde is the waitress I will change sections, or leave. It has been years, and I do mean years; since I have left a restaurant without leaving a tip. To Miss Blonde who waited on us: The older waitress brought silverware and napkins and said she would be right back. You jumped on us like a fly on crap, if you were so busy why didn’t you let her wait on us? Trying to wait on too many people will not get you more tips. It will get you lower tips or no tips. I understand busy, I understand waitressing is hard work. But I do not understand being rude, or just not bothering with a customer. There is much more to waitressing than throwing food on the table. You really need to come back and check on the customer. I am sure you knew when you tossed our food on the table that it was wrong. You looked at us several times, and when I smiled and waved you over you went the other way. One word comes to mind. You never brought more coffee, you never refilled our water. We ate the breakfast, because it was almost right, and we were in a hurry. We had to ask another waitress for our check. Than to add insult to injury you gave us a check for over $ 14.00 for what should have been about $ 10.00. We straighten that out at the register. I wanted to say something then, but my husband eats there with his retired buddies during the week, so I held my tongue. Hope you were not surprised when you cleared the table. I really hope you don’t split your tips because I would not want to cheat the nice women who could bother to bring us more coffee. Oh the food breakfast is good, if you can get them to actually cook the fried potatoes. Pizza and subs are decent.

Pizza very good, pony up for the works on the Sicilian pizza it will feed the whole family for days. It is hard to take pizza seriously when its on the same menu with a burrito, bbq’d chicken, taco pizza had them all very good. Worth the drive cross town, usually able to get in and out quickly.

Subs are fantastic. The waiters are very friendly. The make their sub rolls fresh from scratch every day and it adds a lot to the sub. I like the chicken cheese steak the best. Pizza is good and the salads are huge.

Hit or miss. Let’s look at the facts. It’s an American restaurant in which Mexicans make Italian food. Mind blowing, I know. But usually its pretty darn good. The place inside is strangely out of place. Not just for a pizza place, but for the location. A hole in the wall between a roller skate rink and a bowling alley should probably look like a demiliterized zone and smell like wet dog. It doesn’t though. It’s very nice inside, a few tables, mostly booths, a very nice counter and stools, a few tvs to watch whatever they think you should, and, oh yeah, usually decent food. Like I said, hit or miss. The first few times I went, the pizza was fantastic. Few times in my life have I ever said that the crust was better than the pizza itself. But they had that magic. Had. Lately, the wizard is either off, or dead. The pizza is still ok, and the wings are alright, but I no longer strive to go there over Dominos. If you catch them on a bad day, its going to seem like a waste. If you get them on a good one, you may just be getting a fluke.