Timeless Destination

This place is a total RIP OFF and the food really isn’t that great. I’m not sure what the hype is all about!

My sister attends a university nearby and suggested we go here. Service was great. The french fries are out of this world. My sister ordered the chicken parm panini. It was ok, but got soggy on the bottom. I ordered the turkey, avocado panini. It was a little bland and the cheese was not melted.
I liked the atmosphere, the dark wood, the bar area was welcoming.
I would certain give it another shot. The french fries are amazing, don’t pass them up.

Good service and good food with a nice atmosphere. I have been here a few times and they have shown consistently good quality of food

This was the first time we stopped here and it was worth it. It was a late lunch and we had the Chicken cheesesteak and the chicken firecracker wrap. Both were very good. The meals came out pretty quick but like I said it was a late lunch about 2:30pm and no one else was there eating but two others at the bar and they just had drinks.
I would stop there again if I’m in the area for sure. We ate at the bar and the atmosphere was a very nice place.

Very nice laid back atmosphere!
Great food amazing salads and entrées!
They were a lil late with an appetizer and took it off the bill right away.
The buffalo chips are awesome!
Very nice beer selection, our server Donna was on top of everything and was very friendly.

Um, do not let the newish contemporary look fool you… the service is old fashioned (EXCELLENT) and the food is fresh. Definitely trying dinner here some time. We don’t get to Wellsboro often but would come back here on our next visit.

Pizza was delicious, salad was pretty average. Servers are very hospitable. Good atmosphere. 15% off if you stay at the canyon motel! They had a guy playing live piano music.

I remember when the place was first opened. It has grown since, but after the new owners took over, portions, taste, and creativity dwindled. They have the word «subs» and «pannini» as their main feature in their lunch/​dinner menu, one type of roll for every sandwhich, build your own burger, and box desserts. The hand tossed pizzas were really amazing, but prices went up (and they were high enough). Timeless was not a «pizza or sub» joint… not with a full bar, wine selections, and beer on tap, but now that’s what it is. It’s tacky and poorly executed.
Great for a beer and a game exerpeince, but not a date nor for business. Just disappointed. It was my favorite go to.

A solid lunch here. I like the bar area, amply configured with large flat screens within easy view. I had a firecracker wrap, not too spicy other than the few jalapeños inside. Hard to find a good place in town, so this was a nice change of pace.

My husband & I just went to Timeless for our 19^th Anniversary. It’s under new owners now & the food was terrific. My husband had a Philly Cheese steak & fries & I had the best salad I’ve ever had. It was the Waldorf salad with grilled chicken on top. I was going to have Balsamic dressing, but the waiter suggested the grape vinaigrette. Glad he did because it was terrific! The waiter was a really nice guy, friendly & great service
(wish I remembered his name). Prices were decent too. We will definitely be going again.

Talk about small salad portions… I got a salad and it was $ 8.50 and was starving. I expected a full and large salad, but what do I get? The smallest salad I have ever seen, on a good day maybe 3 cups total. I was starving by the time I was done… It was a rip off taking the dinner side salad that came with the $ 10 burger was just as big as my dinner.

Decent food, not great but good. Service varies from the worst ever to being treated like royalty. The wings are good.

This restaurant has the potential to be good it just fails to execute. The menu looks good but the food really lacks flavor. They seem to try to hide their bland flavor by drowning things in batter and sauce. The service is ok but the prices are way too high for diner quality food. People say it’s an Italian restaurant but this is by no means an Italian restaurant, not even a poor imitation of one.

After a day of bicycling and getting our bearings of the area, we stopped for a late dinner. Had a drink at the bar which was full. The bartender was very attentive and helpful. We decided to have dinner in the dining room which is quaint but could have the lights dimmed. The menu had various items but both my husband and I decided to try the speak, potatoes salad. The dressing was vinegery, the meat cooked perfect, the greens crisp. This is something I would have never considered. What an excellent choice. The service was excellent. When we come back to Wellsboro, we will come back for dinner!

Almost 4 stars. We liked it just fine, it’s just not special enough to say «Yay, I’m a fan».
The tossed salad was a step above typical. It had more ingredients than you usually see, and was very nicely arranged. Then we shared a small pizza, the «original» style, which we found very tasty. (This pizza does not have tomato sauce — it’s a «white» pizza.)
The décor is interesting and friendly. There are two distinct areas, one with bar and tables, and the other having only tables. The latter one is more suitable for family or group dining. Service was good. Bathrooms were clean if a little worn.
2 house salads, 2 iced teas, 1 small pizza, and one coffee came to about $ 30 before tip.

Great Wings — everything else is pretty good not great — Go for the wings.
We eat here from time to time– last weekend we popped in after a local wedding service. It’s not fine-​dining folks, but it is a decent place to eat in Wellsboro, PA, and it’s popular with the locals.
The main reason I wanted to write a review — they are doing the best chicken wings I’ve had in the area. Had ‘em twice now — both times were perfectly crackling crisp on the outside but tender and juicy on the inside. Buffalo sauce done to «Anchor Bar» specs — hot but not too hot. Not sticky, not runny — just right. And not so much sauce that you’re left with a giant mess.
PS — I have no idea where people are coming up with «best Italian Restaurant» for this place — it is not. They do have a couple of Italian things on the menu, but overall it’s bar food and good old American fare. Nothing fancy. Probably not much healthy either. Go for the wings and you’ll be happy.

Food was Amazing and prices are reasonable. However, it was their service that most impressed me. Staff was very helpful, efficient and pleasant. Ask for Alyssa! Highly recommended!

Good wings… That’s about it, rest of the food is meh

Not happy at all! Both the service and food were unacceptable. We were seated promptly in the front dining area and was asked if we would like something to drink. My wife ordered a glass of merlot and I ordered a beer. Ok so far.
When the merlot came it was ice cold and my beer came in a bottle with no glass offered. When the appetizer came I noticed that there was no silverware on the table and I figured I would ask here for some utensils when she came back, well she didn’t come back and my wife had to get up and ask another waitress. Then my wife’s salad came with the dressing on the salad (my wife had asked specifically to have the dressing on the side). It took 17 minutes to get a glass of water and when I saw here BS’ing with people from another table, I got up, put the money down for what we ate and drank and walked out!!!
I have never experienced this level of customer service anywhere in the world where I have travelled and I travel frequently. Never again will I go back or recommend this place. I’m a little surprised because of the good reviews previously. Maybe there is a new owner or the manager was not on duty that night.

We eat at Timeless any time we’re in Wellsboro. We always receive great service and great food! I appreciate the smart shaped bar «corner» that allows groups of 4 – 6 to eat together and converse at the bar.
PROS:
*Great service (the vast majority of the time)
*Excellent pizza (buffalo chicken pizza is awesome)
*Varied menu
*Calamari dipping sauces are out of this world
CONS:
*Service can be a bit slow
*Prices are too high for what it is. Keep in mind as you read this, I’m totally down w/​paying for great food. This IS great food, but the actual food/​products don’t warrant quite the prices being charged. I feel more like the prices are set w/​the intention of BEING HIGH more so than anything else.
*Lackluster beer selection. While there are two rows of bottle beers and 5 taps, there are limited local/​craft beer selections.
All in all, if you’re in Wellsboro, this is a great place to eat and we will continue to eat here again and again and again…