Brooklyn Pizza Parlor

So, first time here and probably last. I don’t mind having to go to the counter to order my food, although I find it an inconvenience… especially when they have a large menu that includes dinner entrees. Ordered… tea, soda, sausage Stromboli, fries and baked ziti with eggplant. My main issue is items are made in two different parts of the kitchen and they can’t seem to coordinate with each other. First out, Stromboli… probably pre-​made so it heats in the pizza oven in a matter of minutes. Ten minutes later, you guessed it, out comes fries and Baked Ziti. We complained to the food runners… DEER IN THE HEADLIGHTS! Manager came over and asked how things were, she was told we were upset. I explained about the timing and she explained the two kitchen system. I said it would make sense to cook the ziti and fries and when they were almost ready, fire the Stromboli. She told me the cashiers were supposed to ask if the food should come out together. I explained that I ordered two drinks and two different dinners so it would make sense that I wanted everything to come out together. She did the right thing by apologizing and asked if she could do anything for us. I said no as I didn’t want anything for free. I ordered my wife’s dinner to go and handed the girl my CC, she handed it back and said I was on the house, no charge. I told her thank you and I didn’t come in for free food. She understood and apologized for the mix up. I guess we will be back… next time pizza.

Coming from NJ and having eaten pizza in all 5 boroughs, especially Brooklyn– this is damn good for this area! Pizza is as close to NY/​NJ style as it comes down here and we won’t be going elsewhere for a while. We haven’t tried anything but the pizza to be fair but entrees seemed to be moderately priced and looked piping hot when served.

the place is really awkard when you first come in so i go in order and the cashier is rude, i order drink they didnt give them to me yet, anther person jus slams forks on the table leaves. then finally i ask about the drinks and she says they are at the end of the counter. how am i suppsed to know? the pizza is was not good! i just did not like my whole experience there.

Very overrated and overpriced. Crust taste like it came from a can, vegetables taste stale and old, and meats have no flavor. Ordered a bbq chicken and the bbq sauce tasted like it came from a generic jar. Onions were not warm so I have to assume the cooks forgot before making the pizza and threw them on top afterwards. Chicken had no seasoning and flavor. Obviously not a true bbq chicken because it looked like the cooks cut up some Chicken and threw it on as an after thought. Wasted $ 18. Little Caesars is better.
Oh and don’t expect your food in a timely fashion. Even on a slow night it will take the kitchen 30 mins

My first time going to Brooklyn Pizza. I called ahead and ordered a Sicilian Pizza to go. Pizza was horrible. Dough was like sandwich bread, pizza didn’t have enough sauce as it was really dry. It was a very bad experience. Stay away from the Sicilian Pizza.

One of the few things I miss from my time living in the NYC metropolitan area is good pizza. So, imagine how excited we were to see «Brooklyn» pizza open. I was hopeful we were finally going to get some good pizza out here in union county. Not so much. This place is an overpriced, grease factory. We tried it on multiple occasions thinking the first time we just caught them on a bad night. Not so much. The one thing I will say is they are consistent, and that isn’t a good thing. They get 2 stars cause their service is real good, 4 stars worth. Pizza repeats on you all day, all night and it sits in you like a boulder. This place is nothing like New York pizza. If you go here, make sure you take some Tums or some other antacid.

Food is good, but much too expensive. Lunch specials are a good deal. $ 16 for a large cheese pizza is gouging.

I ordered a calzone and it tasted like it had been setting out all day. It was burnt and hard as a rock. We will not be back. We thought about giving it another try after a few years since our last bad visit: no more.

I come from NY and this was pretty damn close to being just like pizza from home! Staff is friendly, prices are what I’m used to, but a little high for the area! It makes me feel like home so I will definitely be going back!

Lemme just say that this pizza is more pricy than most, however when we got our hands on it, we couldn’t help but notice its weight! This thing was loaded with the toppings we ordered! Not to mention delicious! We’re not super frequent here, but the few times we have ordered its been great.

The food is alright, but the prices are way too high. Today, I ordered the eggplant parm hero and the eggplant was bitter and undercooked. I complained and got another one for free, but it was just as uncooked as the first one. I won’t be getting that sandwich again if I even order from here again.

Greasy pizza. But if you love that NYC pizza then go for it. I think it is a bit expensive for what it is but the alternative is Dominoes– so you will probably go ahead and pay the money for this stuff. Wish it was better.

We decided to order a pizza for take out this weekend while we were out running errands. We just went basic with a plain cheese. The pizza was ready to go pretty quickly.
For me the pizza is a-​ok… but not great. The crust is not the best and it was a bit too greasy for me.
This place is preferred over «fast food pizza» like Farley’s…but definitely not my favorite pizza.

Everytime I come here the cash register people are always in an upset mode. I say thank you and polite but I just get a stared and no smile at all. I feel like because I am Chinese and that’s the type of treatment I get.

The quality of the pizza depends on when the pizza was made. Often it has been sitting in the open shelf drying out waiting to be reheated, if you order by the slice. But, the quality is OK. There are better pizza options in the local area.

I come to Brooklyn Pizza once or twice a month and my usual order is two slices of pizza with mushrooms. The pizza is pretty good and very reasonable in price. The service is always great. I decided to try something different yesterday and went with angel hair and meatballs. When I placed the order, I told them to go light on the sauce.
A few minutes later, my order came. I saw a fairly large plate of pasta with two decently sized meatballs. A good amount of steam was coming off of the pasta. So far, so good. When I looked closer, I saw that there was a ton of sauce on the pasta… not what I wanted. The meatballs looked a bit strange. I may be wrong, but they did not look homemade (they were near perfect replicas of each other on the outside), and the inside of them looked very processed-​looking. Neither the sauce (which was a-​plenty) nor the meatballs had much taste to them and I poured on a ton of grated cheese and crushed pepper to doctor the dish up a bit. Moreover, the meatballs were both cold. I told the server and she brought me over another meatball. You guessed it– it was a clone of the other two and it also was cold.
Next time I go, I will stick with the pizza and avoid the pasta.

Too Expensive!
My husband paid $ 40 for one pizza and a spaghetti entrée, no garlic bread, just a piece of bread thrown in the bag and not even wrapped up!
The pizza was WAY too greasy, but I’m giving 2 stars, because after getting the grease off with a paper towel, the pizza made a nice breakfast and the taste was pretty good. Spaghetti came with one meatball, had very little sauce and was just okay.

Great food. Great staff. Always enjoy going to Brooklyn. Never any mistakes or issues and always have an excellent time. Highly recommend!

Go across the street to Villa Mia!!! Brooklyn Pizza is so so… way over priced and VERY greasy. Garlic knots were burnt. I ordered their Pizza, Ziti, garlic knot special. I was quoted the special price over the phone. I gave my husband the coupon and he went to pick it up. He didn’t know the quoted price. It is our fault he forgot to present coupon. However, they should have asked for it knowing that I ordered «the special.» He came home and mentioned how expensive it was. I called after for the significant difference to be refunded, if I brought the coupon back in. They refused, giving no options. Therefore, I will refuse them my business. Especially when there is an even better pizza place, Villa Mia (in Harris Teeter lot), across the street.

I want to love this place, and sometimes I do. Other times not so much.
I have come here and left feeling like I have found the mecca of NY style pizza, so good it reminded me of home, and other times I have left regretting even ordering anything.
The service is always good, let me start with the positive. The girls that work there always have a smile on their face and are very helpful with any requests.
The food on the other hand is so hit or miss, it totally depends on the day as to whether you are going to enjoy your food or not, and I am talking about when you order the same exact thing on different days. There have been times when the pizza was cooked to perfection, with a nice char on the crust, and perfect toppings, and there have been times where the pizza looked like it was just passed through the oven, with a barely edible crust that is pretty much raw.
Unfortunately I like consistency with my food, and I’m not willing to spend my hard earned money, knowing I could get home with my pizza and feel like I could have gotten a better one from the frozen food section of the grocery store.

Really good food always consistent and arguably the closet thing to real NY style pizza in the area. The entrees are always good and the chicken cutlet dangerous is always a5god choice.
And their sweet tea by Java Jeff is the best on a hot day!

Great food. Good value. A pizza will fill you up! I can’t say anything about eating in the restaurant but I pick up a pizza frequently and my pizza is done when they say it will be done and friendly staff.

Been coming here for over a year. Pizza used to be good but it seems like every month it gets worse and worse. Final straw was the last time I ordered two pies and there was so much oil and slop that the dough was soggy and just fell apart, had to scoop it out of the box with a spatula.

Cheese rice ball was really good, a little on the salty side but nice & big! The plain Sicilian pizza was a little cold but tasty. The staff is very friendly and attentive!

So my mother is a bonafide New Yorker and from Brooklyn so she wanted to check this place out. We loved it! We’ve been twice and the food has been delicious. The pizza is the real deal! Try the cheese garlic knots.

Great friendly staff. Got canzone to go. One cheese and spinach and one with peperoni and mushrooms. There was so little cheese on it I had a hard time finding it. Bread is good but that’s about all we got. Would have sent it back if we were eating in.

When they first opened, I loved their linguini with clam sauce. However, through the years, it has become horrible. It just isn’t what they used to serve when they first opened, the clam sauce is just yucky now.
Their pizza’s still seem pretty good, and their Antipasto salad was, and possibly still is, wonderful — even though I haven’t had it in a while. Guess I’ll go back to that salad, since my days of having their linguini and clam sauce are finished. I gave it numerous chances, but it just never measured up to what it had been when they opened their doors.

Brooklyn and it’s two cousins take #2 for best pizza in Charlotte behind Due Amici in the University Area. Brooklyn South is in Wesley Chapel in a bustling shopping center with CFA, Target, and some various other stores. When you enter, you walk to the counter and place your oder. They have a huge subway map on the floor which is super cool. Last time I was there, I got 2 slices of cheese and a water. They give you your drink right at the counter and you take a street sign back to your table so they know where to bring your food.
I sat down at a booth, but the booth itself still had pizza crumbs on it. Ew. The table was clean but I guess they just missed the booth. The food came out fairly quickly and it was HOT. Unbelievably hot but also so delicious. Crispy crust that could be folded, a nice amount of cheese – not too much – and great tomato sauce. It’s really very good pizza.
Service is friendly and efficient – no complaints here. Brooklyn South could just be the best pizza in south Charlotte!