Magoo’s Sports Pub

Went for wings tonight. They were absolutely huge. Flavors were good too. Bar tender was super nice & helpful with suggestions as to which wing flavors to try. I had the «tough guy» and «garlic fire», next time would maybe get hotter ones.
Andddd. the bleu cheese dressing was exceptionally good. thumbs up

These are the best wings in the city of Stallis. Maybe Milwaukee. Maybe. Unfortunately, the décor leaves a little to be desired.
And don’t get too drunk or you might fall down the stairs on your way to the bar from the dining area. Or the stairs leading to the pool table that’s crammed into the lower space. So many stairs…

Best wings ever!!! I have been going to Magoo’s for years with 3 different owners. The wings at Magoo’s are the best in Milwaukee you will find. Plus home made ranch and blue cheese.

Great deals for Wing Night on Wednesdays! Get there early because they fill up! Their fish fry is awesome on Fridays too. Friendly staff and extra screens for watching local sporting events.

Dirty with the smell of spoiled cooking grease, and those are the nice things.
I’ve been to worse Dirty, Nasty Frat House Basements than Magoo’s. I was in complete wonderment as to how anyone could work in such a filthy establishment.
Please don’t misunderstand what I am saying, I love a good dive bar but this is an embarrassment to dive bars.

Best wings in the Milwaukee County area. The tough guy and spicy barbeque never disappoints.

Food was good. Wings are always above average. Prices are excellent. We’ve always enjoyed their bloody Mary’s. The place is a bar so don’t expect ambience. Also, I’ve had a bartender tell me no bloody Mary’s after 6. He grudgingly made me one anyway, but I just can’t forget that awkward moment… Still, their fries rock!

Today was a good wing day. Magoos kills me because they are so dang inconsistent that it’s hard to know what you’re going to get when you order. Today the wings were all a real good size, I’d say about 10 to a pound which to me is just perfect because they are big, meaty, and juicy. We ordered the hot wings, the hot BBQ, and the honey siracha. My favorite have always been the hot BBQ. The honey siracha were pretty good too. The hot wings were ok but nothing great. I really like that they are fried, sauced, then finished on the grill. In the past that last part has led to severe over cooking but again, today was a good wing day. If they could consistently hit this level of excellence all the time they would quickly climb back into #1 for wings in mke imho.

My favorite wings in the Milwaukee area. Their spicy BBQ is great. Also the bartenders are all nice and willing to have a conversation.

What a dump. No air conditioning either so hot as H*** in there. BUT the wings! Just fantastic. Might be the best in town as they claim. Also 16 oz PBR cans for just $ 2.50. 32 ouncers for just $ 4.50. Bartender was a really nice guy too. So enough goodness to offset the badness.

Read good reviews about this bar. Being that we are not from around town we took a chance. The food was delicious. A bit under sizes compared to how it was explained at time of order but then disappointing after we got the bill. I felt like we paid way more for what we were served. I will go back but not on a empty stomach.

The owner should spend more time not partying and giving the bar away to his friends. And worrying about getting laid. And spend more time on paying customers.

Dude bro galore?
I was expecting The place to be filled with DB’s but surprised the place was more diverse. Music was up with many DB songs/​anthems. Warning the décor is in old school sports dive. plenty of beer advertisements and specials and TVs on the wall everywhere.
They have two beer pong tables upstairs pool on the lower levels darts plenty of TVs pool tables welcome to Dirty Stallis’s version of Colonel Harts. Good wings with plenty of regulars that pack it till the early morning. It’s a sports dive bar with a good regular following. Even when busy the bartenders always looking out. For who is next.
The wings are very close to East points pub and Jacksons BRP style, Pre fried sauced and grilled.
F 4
A 3
S 3
L 2
V 3

I went there this past Sunday for the Packer Game. My friends and I stayed there for the entire game and ordered food. I tried their boneless wings with their homemade Hot Sauce called Touch Down. I believe that was the name. I like spicy and it was just the right temperature! They were really good! Service was really good to. Bartenders and Servers were really tentative.
I will be returning!

An update: I have been here almost every Wednesday for wing-​night since my first review. The service is still really friendly and we hardly ever have issues (they get really busy so we forgive a missed bleu cheese or two).
While the sampler platter isn’t the best the burgers are awesome!
Go here, if you like dive bars and American food, you will not be disappointed.

I guess this what you would expect for a West Allis bar.
The décor & set up were okay — it was hard to determine whether or not we should wait for someone to seat us or if we should seat ourselves. Services was so-​so and so was the food.
If you want a bar with a better atmosphere and better food, I would suggest going elsewhere.

Went here for lunch today after having driven by two times a day for the last 16 years. I had 20 wings with their «moron» sauce’, their hottest. The wings were huge, dry rubbed whcih gives the wing meat a great flavor on it’s own and grilled and basted with the sauce. I can eat extremely hot stuff and would have liked something with more zing but these tasted really good. The bartender was the server and he was right on point. A nice, comfortable West Allis sports bar which does an excellent job. AYCE cod loin fish fry for $ 10.99 which looked really good too.

Was there for Cassie D’s Birdy30 party and I agree with her review.
There’s just not much to say. It’s a local bar. Everyone around the bar knew each other and the bartenders. However, they were friendly and talkative and welcoming.
We were in a «side» room that was both to the side and down a couple of stairs. The only problem is that the doorway to the kitchen is down there too and we were pretty constantly asked to move so someone could get through with a tray of food.
But the food! We had teriyaki wings and they were pretty tasty — but didn’t taste anything like teriyaki. The wings are made on the grill and they retain a very strong «grill smoke» flavor on them. It was tasty, but overpowered any flavoring they may have had. My bf and I shared an order of wings, a half order of nachos and an order of the cheese fries and were plenty fool.
The table behind us got the full order of nachos and it literally came on a pizza plate. They were as huge as advertised. Since it was just the two of us, we got the small order, but the bigger one looked more appetizing. The small order is in a paper boat/​basket so the chips are piled on each other. The toppings, including the cheese sauce, sit on the very top layer of chips and once you get through those, you basically have an big basket of naked cheese. The bigger order didn’t have this problem, as the chips were spread over the bigger plate.
Despite being a proud Wisconsinite, I will admit to sometimes really, really loving me some processed cheese sauce and the cheese fries were amazing. The fries were thick and had a seasoning salt on them and the cheese sauce was thick and stood up to the fry. They were fatty and fake and so, so good.
All in all, it wasn’t a bad joint. I’d go back for the cheese fries. It wasn’t spectacular and wasn’t awful. Just a good neighborhood joint.
Plus, Cassie won some big cash :)

Magoo’s was the first stop on my #Birdy30 wing tour. We called ahead to warn them we have anywhere between 6 and 25 people coming… Ended up being more like 40 and the staff were amazingly accommodating! I’m a sucker for good service… and bars that make you feel like they’re happy to have you. The staff is very friendly and just genuine people all around.
It is definitely a bar full of regulars-​Which is always a little intimidating. However, they we’re very friendly… Especially when they found out it was my birthday :) Don’t let that discourage you from a visit. We went on a Friday, was super quite when we got there at 6… By the time we were wrapping up at about midnight the bar was packed solid. And yes… I may have ate chicken wings and had «birthday beverages» for 6 hours.
And the fact that I won $ 300.00 on the «Shake of the Day» is neither here nor there. I won’t let that sway my review… I have integrity people, integrity!
The wings were solid. No real complaints. Nothing too special, just done well.

The wings… the wings… the wings… that’s all people talk about with this place! But i don’t eat deep fried food.
I did sample one wing. it was good.
The service was great, but other than that it was just ok. nothing to write home about (but something to write Unilocal about i guess). There were flies in the dining room, the AC didn’t work that well, but the company i was with made for a fun time.
would i go back? probably not. There are much better places for bar food in the are.