Toppers Pizza

Use to be the best pizza place around. About a year ago it went downhill quickly. Horrible food every time in the last year so stopped getting food from there

Still waiting for my pizza… is it ever gonna come… guess not thanks for taking all my credit card info and then not bringing me anything. Better not be a charge on my account!

Waited far too late, needed to run the delivery driver down because he can’t find my apartment and this is what I get a smashed pizza, never again!

Are you guys serious? You accepted my order online and then closed for the evening without delivering. I didn’t even receive a call to let me know you wouldn’t be delivering. I used to like you, but this is ridiculous.

Ordered for delivery and was told 45 minute wait. After an hour and fifteen minutes I called to see where my food was and they said it will be there shortly. I never received my order that night. VERY UNPROFESSIONAL! This is the second time this has happened by the way.

Before moving to Milwaukee I was told about this pizza place. After living here for 3 years I have had many in counters with this delicious, ingenious pizza place! Late night, drunken meals delivered in a hurry. To the ‘I don’t care to cook anything’ night. Toppers never fails. They always offer a coupon or some sort of deal over the phone and online. It is addictive! Reasonable priced. Even on a broke mans budget (trust me!)! My only complaint is it is a bit greasy. But it’s pizza right?! :)

I love Toppers Pizza but this location is incredibly terrible when it comes to making pizzas the way they are ordered, and delivering them in a timely manner isn’t a speciality according to my experiences. I have had multiple experiences where my order wasn’t made as ordered. In fact, one time, it even took them three attempts to send me the correct pizza. To me that is complete carelessness. We also had another experience where we ordered for delivery and after an hour and half of waiting I called to ask where my pizza was and the guy told me it just walked out the door. When the pizza arrived it wasn’t even hot. It was like it had been sitting under the heating lamp for a very long time. As much as I love Toppers I am going to have to stop ordering as long as I live in West Allis. This Toppers seems to be poorly run and I have paid for it for the last time.

This was my go-​to pizza place if I wanted something delivered. They have a wide array of different pizzas and toppings. There was not one that I didn’t thoroughly enjoy, and I had quite a few. They also were never late, if not early. Now that I have moved to aother neighborhood, I will miss this location as there is no one that can quite compare in my current part of town.

Better than expected. We had the Ultimate Pepperoni and well worth it.

[NOTE: comments based on PIZZA CARRYOUT experiences.] Based on a sample of two (2) different pizzas, and 4 or more visits, consistently NOT HO-​HUM pizza, with some real flavor, I’ll be a repeat customer when I’m visiting my parents «up north». If you’re looking for authentic Italian, well, this ain’t. If you’re looking for California pizza — minus wood-​burning oven — this is more like it. Medium-​thin crust, with crunch and soft combo texture. Speaking of which I can reccomend the California pizza, a white one, with arties, spinach, feta and ranch sauce. And the Gyro pizza, skip the mozzerella, add easy feta, is a hearty helping of goodliness. Skip the dine-​in — no ambiance, too bright.

Walkouts til 1AM and delivery til 3, all seven days. Toppers raises the bar on modern day thinking of pizza. With fancy pizzas and epic sides it easy to see why Toppers is hip — and they even tweet.