Benito’s Pizza

Iv worked at benitos a few years back. And I still love the pizza today. Always down for a 1 $ slices!
**order light sause, btw there is ALOT of cheese and oil. So if your looking for thin crust idk I’m a deep dish guy lol^^
** add black and red pepper
Benitos over dominos, little C, jets, papa john, papa romans, tomatoes, dollys„

Since Benito’s is a small local joint I feel bad by rating them 2 stars but I’d be lying to my fellow Unilocalers if I gave them more based on my experience. The good news is that I’ll still give them another shot at some point because I only had their pizza by the slice and haven’t yet tried their «gourmet» pizzas.
My plan on this day was actually to stop by Costco for a cheap lunch and get a couple slices of pizza from their food court. If you’ve eaten Costco pizza before then you know that it’s not great but not bad either. However, I remembered that Benito’s, which is just around the corner from where I live, has a sign out front advertising pizza by the slice Monday through Saturday 11 AM-​3 PM and 8 PM-​10 PM. So with the baseline of my expectation level being Costco pizza, I figured that I was walking into Benito’s as an easy to please guy.
Unfortunately, I wasn’t pleased. Upon walking in I was expecting to see some pizza that was ready to go but they keep the premade pizzas back behind the counter somewhere out ot sight. I asked what toppings do they have for by-​the-​slice and the girl at the counter lets me know they have pepperoni and cheese. Pretty much what I expected so I order 2 slices. She then goes behind the counter and grabs 2 slices of the squared deep dish pizza and puts it in the oven for warming. I guess I was surprised that it was deep dish pizza rather than regular round but I was ok with it. After a couple minutes I’m out of there with my 2 slices in a small box and a bottle of diet pepsi (they don’t have fountain drinks).
My first disappointment was the 3 measly slices of pepperoni they put on each slice of pizza. If you see the picture that I posted, this isn’t a case where I just happened to get a slice from a part of the pizza where toppings were scarce by chance. You can tell that they deliberately place 3 slices of pepperoni per slice of pizza. With this being thick deep dish slices of pizza I was disappointed but it’s only .99 a slice so I was accepting of it. The pepperoni and cheese were average tasting and I kind of enjoyed the sauce. It had a sweet flavor and a nice texture. The problem here was the crust which was thick and doughy on the inside… maybe even a tiny bit undercooked? I’m not sure but what I do know is that halfway through the first slice I was tired of chewing through all that dough. If the toppings were more plentiful then maybe I could have overlooked the doughy center but I couldn’t. Flat out, I didn’t enjoy this pizza. I ended up just scraping the toppings off the second slice and just eating it with the other half of the first and tossing the crust out. Again, the barometer here for me was Costco pizza and Benito’s fell well short.
This place is pretty close to where I live so I’ll probably give them another shot, but I’m staying away from the pizza by the slice. If their whole pizzas are better, I’ll update my review.

Their pizza is ok. But their customer service is terrible. I think it is just this location because we have been to other locations without problems. The manager is just not good and the staff is not well trained. We eat pizza at least once a week and will be taking our business elsewhere.

Benitos is the shiiiiizzzzz. My go to pizza place in the area. Much cheaper than Tomatoes and much better.

I ordered online, big plus! Small cheese and breadsticks for the kids and they devoured it. Then I ordered a small deep dish for adults, bacon, chicken, hp… It was good, a bit under cooked, but I liked it. In a pinch I would order again, especially for the kids and babysitter!

Best calzone I’ve ever had! Benito’s was recommended by a friend and now we get calzones delivered All the time. They stuff it with toppings and most importantly lots of sauce. Normally if ask for extra sauce in the side but here I don’t have to.

While they have a decently average pie, their customer service is flat out terrible. As a restaurant owner who stands by my product and especially our service, it pains me to know that places like Benito’s will go through great lengths to screw their customers when an opportunity presents itself. It’s to bad as it was nice to have another option in an area with few DESCENT and no real good pizza delivery options.
Order if you must but be sure to check you receipt and your order BEFORE you pay for it and DONT pay if it’s not what you ordered or if it’s not to your satisfaction. They will make a promise to «make it up to you» but they won’t and will argue with you.
This place must be barely hanging on to screw a customer that orders delivery no less then once a week and sometimes as much as 3 times, out of a few bucks. It’s not the $, it’s the principles… Principles Benito’s doesn’t seem to have.
If you diliver the wrong food and promise that your actual and regula order (which was a pepperoni pizza with mushrooms on half) would be free or «comped» then suck it up and one the promise and do it. Instead we were offered a $ 3 discount on the $ 15 pizza. Not the $ 15 comp for the $ 15 f-​up that we had to through away.
Out of principle you have lost a huge customer with large circle of influence over a few bucks.
I promise to open a pizza joint neer by that will smoke out this «worst practices» biz and restore the basic buisiness ethics and principles to the area along with a better then average pizza. All in a company that will stand by there work.
Until then. Order Jets, Tomatoes, Bronx Deli go to Little Caesers or any other pizza joint other then this place or Dominos (yuck)

So far they have not let me down. Pizza always turns out great. They have round and square pizzas. I like it with butter and Parmesan cheese. Crust nice and chewy never doughy. Quality toppings never had a problem yet. And it’s cooked just right never rushed or over cooked. Guys behind the counter are pleasant too.

My husband wanted to order pizza that we haven’t tried before one night. We ordered from Benito’s and now order only Benito’s. The pizza tastes homemade and has so much flavor. The pizza was delivered hot and fast, which is always a plus. We like extra sauce on our pizza and forgot to ask for it, but it was perfectly sauced. Most other places skimp on the sauce, making the pizza taste dry and gross. Definitely worth getting — delicious pizza and great service!

Whenever I heading home late, I stop in to pick up dinner. The menu is huge and I never get board of the options. The salads are really good and always fresh. I also love the pizza sub and usually substitute chicken for the pepperoni. The employees are always friendly and attentive. I’m really glad that they are in my neighborhood.

Awesome pizza go deep dish cajan crust it will blow your mind