Keystone Pizza

I have ordered from Keystone on three separate occasions prior to writing this review. One delivery order and two carry out orders. The first time I ordered a pepperoni pizza and a cheese steak for delivery. The delivery took approximately an hour. I wouldn’t have minded the long wait time if the pizza and sandwich would have been hot upon arrival, but unfortunately they were cold. Once the pizza was warmed up in the oven it was pretty good. The cheese steak was great. I haven’t ordered delivery from them since. Most recently, I ordered a stromboli and sandwich. I arrived before my order was finished. When I got home with my food the stromboli was cold in the middle. I live less than a mile from the restaurant. There is no excuse for it to be cold. There is nothing that I hate more than cold food.

Best Italian hoagie’s and square pizza in the area! Large menu that has a little bit of everything. I eat here all the time and have never had anything bad. They also have massive salads if you’re into that. They get pretty busy during lunch, but for the most part they have your food ready fast.

If you are from Philly and have cheesesteaks on the menu you should know and offer a fried hot pepper. I just ordered a cheesesteak with fried hots and got garbage banana peppers it’s a disgrace.

I ordered a few zas from here during a night of revelry, and they really hit the spot. At first I ordered three (sausage, pep, and plain) but since I am overly dedicated to pizza, I decided to call back and get a fourth. They happily obliged my request and even messed with me on the phone asking if I wanted 30 more. I appreciate a little playfulness especially since it was probably hard for them to hear with the party in the background. I could see myself giving this place four stars, but I will leave it at three until I actually visit their restaurant.
The original delivery quote was 45 minutes (keep in mind it was peak time on a Friday night) but it only took the delivery guy about 30 minutes. Slightly pricey, coming in at around 60 bucks, but not terrible for four pizzas, two with toppings, delivery, and a few bucks for a tip.
The pizza itself was good and had a nice, sweet sauce with a good sauce to cheese ratio. I deduct one star from the dough being a little overcooked and harder to chew. But this is still a good pizza to get if you are craving it. The sausage topping was the shredded kind, which I like because it imparts the spicy sausage flavor without dominating the slice and making it too heavy. All in all, I would order from this place again and may up my star rating if it continues to be consistent and if the other menu items are good. I only regret leaving the party and not being able to eat a cold slice of leftover plain for breakfast.

Reliable standby for pick-​up and delivery. The chicken gyro and chicken fingers are two of the stronger items on Keystone’s menu and salads here are better than most other pizza places. Spagetti with meatballs is always a hit with my kids. Pizza is just OK in my opinion. Fries disappoint and don’t travel well in take-​out packaging.
Street parking in this neighborhood can be a challenge. There is an office building parking lot ~1 block away, but you have to dart across a 4 lane road. We have double parked a few times here — blinkers on and they are quick at the register!

The pizza is just ok but the salads & dressings are great! Variety and huge. Good lunch delivery spot.

My favorite place to get pizza, hands down. I would definitely recommend this to my friends, family, and even strangers I find myself talking too. Your kids will love the pizza and will ask for it again next week.

Great little local pizza place. Guys really friendly.
Definitely recommended. The crusts and dough are soo good.

Their Cobb salad is amazing. 5 star salad. I am sitting here literally sick I’m so full from salad. How is that even a thing? I’m not too far away, but every time I’ve ordered it, the chicken still shows up warm on top (glad I’m not too far or I guess there could be a wilting situation), and there is just SO much of it. I like the Greek dressing best but whatever does it for you. Order the pita over the garlic knots though.
The pizza is alright, I haven’t found a place in Conshy worth going nuts over pizza-​wise anyway.
Their paninis aren’t paninis… It’s basically a toasted sandwich on ciabatta. If you know that going in it’s pretty tasty, but it’s a disappointment when you think you’re getting an actual panini :)

Keystone is by far the best pizza/​salad/​sandwich shop in the Conshohocken area. I order from there at least 1 time per week, usually more. It doesn’t matter what I order, the food is always great. The delivery guys are always quick; I’ve never had a problem in over a year of deliveries. I highly recommend the chicken caesar salad and pizza with sausage and onions. Also, the meatball sub and fries are an awesome combination. I will continue to order from Keystone for as long as I am in the area.

Thus is an updated review on the staff at keystone. Before I said that the staff was very unfriendly and possibly secist. Since that review I have noticed a DRAMATIC change in their attitudes. I don’t know if it was because of my review or not but I am happy to say that the staff is a lot more friendly! I get no hint of sexism which has made for a very pleasant experience. Thanks Keystone!

Usually like this place and we order from them all of the time, but today the delivery guy was a total jerk. He knocked on my door twice within 30 seconds and because I didn’t answer fast enough, instead of a hello, he offered a smirk, roll of his eyes and the only thing he said «you know, it’s raining». Just rude. Wear a jacket, a hat and do your job.

This was a very average pizza place with higher than average prices. Not impressed but it filled a void.

We were there Friday night ¹¹⁄₂₂ for dinner at 7pm. The dining room is large and clean. There was only one other family in there. It’s BYOB which is great. We had the taco pizza and meatball Stromboli. The food was really good. The crust was especially good. We will definitely be back. The only negative is that parking is hard in that neighborhood.

Great food! Love their homemade chips!
Order the chicken avocado panini often, so good! Great wings as well!
This was our Sunday afternoon /​football watching /​hangover kill food for a entire season while living in Conshy!

… Great salads and they sell pizza slices which is cool too… :)

Keystone is a solid lunch place serving some good old-​fashioned Italian-​American comfort food (and wraps). There is a surprising amount of seating to the side of the counter where you order, which is totally deceiving, because the place looks miniscule when you first walk in.
While the fries are pretty run of the mill (JUST this side of too moist) they do some really good salads. I especially like the caesar dressing because it’s not too creamy and doesn’t make me feel like I’m clogging my arteries by eating it.
My recommendation is to get delivery, unless you are in walking distance. Parking is only on the street, and it gets full at lunch time.

I’ve never had anything at Keystone that’s bad, but I’ve never had anything that knocked my socks off. The service there is solid, friendly, and reliable. Another plus is that not too many local pizza joints have this large of a seating area.
I’ve been going more often recently because there was a groupon available. That makes a slightly overpriced menu a pretty good deal. They make a standard Neapolitan style pizza that’s good if not a little greasy. Their wings are better than you’d think. They also serve by the slice, and they almost always have slices ready. I just wish they were open a little later. I’m always game for some midnight pizza.

Our go-​to for ordering food.
You can order using their online system which makes it a cinch with a large group of friends and delivery is so fast (even late night!)
Great selection on their menu, they have everything to fit all needs/​tastes.
We’re definetly fans.

Update: I would like to update this in response to some things my grandfather has said;however, they still stand at 3 stars (food-​wise) for me:
1) The owner is a decent guy. It’s the drivers that tend to cause the problems in the neighborhood. (double parking to make the street horrible to navigate; mostly weekend nights/​overly busy nights) I understand people have to make a living whatever way they can, but the streets just become dangerous from a community perspective and the attitude of the drivers’ don’t necessarily help. Plus as «Samantha C.» has kindly pointed out, there is a huge lot in the back to park for free!
2)As a result of my grandfather being a regular customer, the owner does remember him when he comes over. Again, it’s the people that work there (maybe they are new or don’t work very often) that usually cause issues with wrong change/​incomplete order/​etc because he does order items like extra sauce, etc.
3) Pizza is okay, but for strombolis and such they don’t use a lot of sauce. (My grandfather always needs extra because there isn’t a lot). Hoagies are okay as well.
I don’t want to bad mouth the owner because as my grandfather puts it, he’s okay, it’s just some of the drivers and such that cause the issues with the business end of things.