Wicked Thrift

Tammy, the owner, made an offer to sell certain merchandise to me and when I asked questions about said merchandise, she became offended and withdrew her offer. I have never experienced anything like that … a retailer refusing to sell me something in which I was genuinely interested? Very odd. I do not think I will be back. I prefer to give my business to a store that wants it.

We loved Wicked Thrift! My husband found an amazing Nicole Miller suede coat with the tags still on for $ 35. I found a pebbled leather Dooney and Bourke for 60, an H and M dress for 20 and an Ann Taylor jacket for 15. Everything has a tag with a cute description and the staff are very helpful. A must visit on the cape!

Loved there vast array of clothes & reasonable prices but hated how they stole my clothes and lied about getting back to me.
Called many times, left manyyyyyyy messages, emailed & finally snail mail. After two months (at least!!!), owner finally calls me & says she has been very busy but she will get back to me. She neverrrr did & she never again returned any further correspondences. Why any grown person would ever treat someone like this I do not know; it takes a «special kind of _​_​_​_​«to act this way & someone who has no regard for their word! One is only as good as their word; u r no good obviously !

Love this place. We did some consigning in Yarmouth and you can truly see that fashion is their passion. They love and care for their vintage pieces, have specific clientele that shop for the styles, and are very friendly and sociable. Both locations have excellent selections of regular and vintage clothing and accessories.

This was an awesome find when shopping for something crazy to wear at a wedding reception. Where else can you find 4 purple nighties to find 4 guys?
The vintage clothes were awesome to look through but I don’t think I’d shell out the $$ for the full price items — definitely be on the lookout for savings!

My favorite thrift store on the Cape and a frequent stop of mine. I drive all the way from Eastham to their Dennis AND West Yarmouth locations frequently. They are awesome to trade with and shop with. I love their funky clothes and accessories and they are really affordable! The owner, Tammy, is wonderful and so personable. The rest of her staff is great, too. A must go for everyone!

Best thrift shop I’ve ever been to! Highly recommended — Great organization and prices

I’m not a shopper in general but I love this place. The owner/​staff doesn’t pressure you into purchases but they are there for any assistance you need. The variety of styles of clothes & funky accessories spans multiple decades and changes with every visit. Secondhand doesn’t mean low quality; some things even have tags on them still! Thanks to Wicked Thrift, my wardrobe has something suitable for every occasion I encounter. Anyone that knows me knows that says a lot.

Great store packed with awesome modern and vintage stuff! The owner (was that the infamous Tammy I talked to?) was very nice and the store was very well organized. I was impressed by the handwritten tags commenting on each item… they were really cute!
I had so much fun thrifting here! Will definitely recommend to friends!

Best thrift store I have ever been to. Nicely organized with relevant clothing.

If this thrift store were a band it would be the Beatles. No doubt about it.
Ironically this is my 2^nd visit in 1 year to their store. My first was last july and I got a vintage Ronson lighter (which I still have yet to get filled and repaired, but it is from the late 1940’s and that’s another story for yet another time…)
Since last year was one of those happy accident discoveries made with friends while driving, I knew I had to go back this year.
The store is divided into women’s and mens sections. In fact Tammy (who I assume is the one in charge) even commented to me that they did expand their men’s section compared to last year.
There is a great selection of vintage stuff ranging from about the 1940’s (perhaps even as early as the 1930’s or even 1920’s) all the way to more recent vintage clothing and accessories.
I have always found the staff friendly and very helpful. I even got to chat with Tammy’s father this time around. Really it feels like you are coming back to see old friends.
The prices seem very reasonable compared to what you would pay brand new.
Make no mistake, this ain’t the Gap or J Crew (not that there is anything wrong with those stores.)
This is a unique collection of stuff.
On this visit I found a vintage tweed blazer for $ 25 which seemed at least half of what you would pay in a department store. Being that this is memorial day as I write this (the sound of grills slowly dying out as reality looms…) I will be wearing it to work tomorrow.
When people ask where I got it, I will gladly tell them.
I will happily return when I visit the Cape again. You really can’t get these types of experiences at any run of the mill place.
Also, if people can’t make it to the Cape, they do actually have an online presence. Not sure if I can mention other sites on this one, but just check the site out and you will see.
Finally to anyone from the store reading this, you guys are amazing. Keep up the great work!

Wicked Thrift is a lot of fun. There are two sides to the store — a modern thrift section and a vintage section. Although I haven’t purchased anything from the vintage side yet, I love going in and checking out all of the fun dresses and playing with the jewelry. I have had some good luck in the modern side of the store. Last summer I purchased a super flattering multi-​colored v-​neck shirt that I wear all the time, some cool convertible skirts (double-​sided, can be converted from skirt to dress with creative tying — so fun in the summer), and a hot pair of platform heels that I love. They have men’s clothes too, which is good because I think I made a convert out of my hubby. He is obsessed with cords and scored a couple of pairs last time we were there.
Like any thrift store, it can be hit or miss, but that’s part of the fun. They get new clothes in constantly so the selection is always changing. They also have a big range of sizes — I saw juniors to plus size — so anyone can shop there and find something that will fit them. I also love that they get all of their goods by trading with their own customers; I haven’t traded yet but have a bag waiting for the next time I visit the Cape. Writing this review is reminding me that I am overdue for a visit!