West Newton Pizza House

Well I just never tried this place yet. . YET. . Don’t think that they’d deliver but it sure would be awesome ! Even if it’s just locally !

The West Newton Pizza House, which opened in the 1950’s has kept its quality high since then. The house salad dressing is tasty yet not too overpowering. The cheddar cheese traditional pizza is delicious and doesn’t flop as you eat it. The family owned business workers are fri
endly. The usual 45 minute wait is well worth it.

I am giving this place a five star review because I’ve been going there for years and years and the pizza and other foods haven’t changed. The same person that wasn’t making the pizzas 30 years ago still works there and that’s why it’s so good and the taste is the same. It’s my favorite pizza place and I won’t ever stop coming back!

The Carmella.
That’s all you need to know! This is not your normal chain pizza joint. The sauce is fantastic and the dough is fresh. It’s a bit more expensive than most pizza places in the area but definitely worth it.

This is a West Newton thing. If you are not from West Newton, you may not enjoy, most people from West Newton and not from area still enjoy.
Pizza with a twist, owners are very hard working honest people. Always clean, takes a little long for orders to be completed, but then again its a 3 – 4 person operation on Friday and Saturday nights. Always busy. The home made dressing of Viola is the best and a must have.
Carmella pizza is good and white pizza is excellent.
Definitely a West Newton thing, you either hate it or love it. & being from West Newton and growing up on it, it is absolutely one of my favorites along with Sunset Pizza, and Anthony’s Coal fired pizza in Monroeville.
Also not open Mondays, and opens around 4PM daily.

This has been my favorite pizza since I was a kid! Love it! I haven’t been there in a while, but it’s always been cash only when I’ve gone, so heads up if you’re like me and rarely carry cash. It’s worth the trip to the ATM, though. Best pizza!

Best Pizza in town! Nothing compares! Carmella is a favorite as well as the traditional! Make sure you don’t call before 3:30! It’s family owned and family operated! They are the sweetest people in the world! Also try their own homemade dressing!

Great pizza! My family has been going here for years, and the food and service is consistently excellent.

Disappointing. It’s ok, but I’m not sure why these other reviews are raving about this place. The Carmella was better than the combination cheese.

I grew in this small town and this was our families Friday meal. It’s a hometown feel with 90% of the business as takeout. They have 2 tables in a very small dining area that can be occupied. They serve only soda No Alcohol. Overall a quite little pizza place with great food

Pizza is excellent. Usually takes an hour for pickup in my experience. Very nice lady on the phone helped me with questions. Uploaded a photo of the menu when I was there since I couldn’t find one on line.

Not that many places to eat in West Newton, as far as we could tell, but the West Newton Pizza House suited us just fine. We were staying overnight in West Newton (a cute town) as part of a bicycle trip on the Great Allegheny Passage and C&O Canal. The West Newton Pizza House has been in business since 8÷24÷1957 (they have a newspaper article on the wall). At that time, pizza was a novelty in the U.S., apparently. Basic but good pizza, made to order, plus salads and maybe some sandwiches on the menu. There is a selection of cold soft drinks, water, etc., in the refrigerator. No alcoholic beverages, I’m afraid. Limited seating inside the restaurant — the main part of their business is take-​out. Run by two very nice ladies, on of whom is the daughter of one of the original owners. Clearly a West Newton institution.