Orange Leaf Frozen Yogurt

This place has some good fro-​yo! I am especially into the birthday cake flavor, which in my opinion tastes less like cake, and more like frosting! They have a lot of toppings and flavors to choose from. I like that they have dividers for your yogurt so you don’t have to pick between fruity or chocolatey — you can have them both and they don’t have to touch! The only thing I didn’t like about this place was the guy working. I get it, it’s the weekend and you don’t want to be stuck in a room full of 13 year old girls all afternoon — but hey, would a «hello» or «thank you» kill ya?

Delicious, but terribly expensive. We normally go to Rita’s which is right down the street and half the price. I think they’ve recently raised prices again here at OL. My 2 daughters and I each had a bowl half filled with frozen yogurt yogurt and a few toppings, it was over 20 dollars! We won’t ever be back. Avoid.

Orange Leaf is a good place for frozen yogurt, and one of the only ones you will find in ice cream dominated Westerville.
The atmosphere is open and inviting with the ingredients clearly displayed in clear containers and tongs for picking them out. Sadly, beyond being open and inviting, there is nothing to set it apart from any other frozen yogurt mixery you’ve been to.
Bottom line: Tasty frozen treats to make your own way that are good but not mind blowing.
Tip: Try the seasonal flavors.

When you need a froyo fix on the Westerville side, this is your go to, if Polaris is too inconvenient (choose your poison: weather, traffic, hours…). It ain’t bad.
The key is: not overloading. Keep it simple — one or two flavors, a couple toppings. Otherwise, it becomes a gooey crunchy pile of OHMYGODITSSOTASTYnomnomnomnomnom

Who doesn’t love making their own sundae? And who doesn’t love eating their sundae with a mini shovel? Orange Leaf has been a great place to meet up with other friends with kids. They offer fresh fruit toppings, nuts, and lots of candy. There are also dividers so you can do different combos in the same cup

Pricey but a good treat! Lots of choices. If you want a cheaper but quality Italian ice place Rita’s is miles down the way. The have soft serve frozen custard too! Regardless this place has it’s perks because of the location and variety. Don’t go overboard though. Keep it simple. :)

We’ve tried them all, and OL has been our very favorite since last summer. Their yogurt is just better! Cute little place, always super clean, friendly staff, and awesome live music on the weekends!

Wife and kids love it! Nice flavor selection to choose from, just gotta watch the kids with all the topping options — don’t wanna pay $ 8 per pound for pretzels or chocolate chips.
Great rewards program too.

This is *the* self-​server frozen yogurt place in Westerville. They have a good selection of yogurt and they’re always tasty.
The place is almost always busy with TONS of kids. So expect controlled chaos. Also for weight conscious look at the ingredient list. Most of the other local frozen yogurt places use natural sweeteners but Orange Leaf often uses sugar. It higher in calories and the glycemic index then the other local yogurt places, although they not no much higher.
If you want great frozen yogurt give this place a try.

Orange Leaf is kind of tucked into the shopping center at the corner of State and Polaris Parkway. It was a little hard to find amidst all of the strip mall chain haze (I think it was by the UPS store, if that helps.)
Bonus points for the fun décor and ample seating (sparkly orange tile! Mini shovels instead of spoons!) I definitely need a shovel when it comes to places like this because I *will* eat all the yogurt.
There were about 12 yogurt flavors, self-​serve style, and tons of toppings. They didn’t have mini chocolate chips which is big on my list of important yogurt toppings, but they had pretty much everything else fruit and topping wise. The yogurt was good, but pretty sweet — more like soft serve ice cream than tart like yogurt.
Oh yeah, and I agree with the reviewer that complained about the no test cups — factor it into your price, people. It’s already pretty pricey, I feel like there must be a way to offer tasters.
Overall, it’s worth a stop unless you’re really craving true, tart yogurt — in which case you need to head over to Easton for Yagoot.

Love the product, but it’s weird how they won’t give you test cups anymore. Someone must have abused the opportunity to try flavors, as you are now escorted to each flavor that you want to try out. Prices are a bit outrageous, and for some reason, my yogurt is always more expensive at this location compared to the others in the area. Maybe my appetite just increases. Great spot, great flavors, and a big screen tv that is typically showing the Buckeyes game or Sports Center is a big plus.
4 stars for the product, the friendly service, and the brand.

Once again, frozen yogurt has won me over (but with so many amazing flavors and toppings it is not that hard too)
I still LOVE the fact that you can serve yourself at these lovely establishments and no one will judge me on the flavors I mix or that the amount of cookie dough bites I put on top would make cookie monster concerned.
This place is large, with a modern, Cali flair. Large couches and tables are set up with a few seats available outside. The flavors seem richer here and amazing. I know there are other competitors on the market (aka Cuzzins and groovy spoon) but this place may have them beat!
It helps that they are close to my house too… I mean we are talking walking distance!
The only negative part (that only Cuzzins seems to defy) is being able to sample your own. I know that this could lead to a LARGE mess and everything, but I feel bad when my indecisive flavor obsession takes up the employees time.
But yes, this may just beat out all other frozen yogurt places in Columbus (yes, I know I have said this before in my other reviews, but this is the last one and I am sticking to it!!)

Out of all these little self-​serve frozen yogurt places popping up… Orange Leaf is by far, the BEST I’ve tasted! It’s creamy (more like ice cream) and not icy like some frozen «yogurts» you come by.
I ate at Josies the other night (for whatever reason…) and was reminded how much better Orange Leaf is. Bleh, nasty!
Orange Leaf seems to have more flavors, more toppings, and just better quality altogether.
I’ll gladly be back!

Fun environment but always really crowded, not really a bad sign, though.

Awesome! The place itself is super cute. Everything is fun, light, modern and bright and CLEAN!
I want to say there were 16 individual frozen yogurt flavors to choose from. You pull down the handle and soft serve frozen yogurt goes into your cup or bowl. The have two individual flavors next to each other in their line up of flavors with another lever in between to make them into a ‘twist’ if you want. Their ‘toppings bar’ was giant. I want to say there were 42 different toppings (reeses, m&ms, strawberries, pineapple, brownie bites, cookie dough, animal cookies, kiwis, graham cracker crusts, oreos, etc…) and then of course sprinkles, chocolate syrups, caramel, some jelly belly topping, marshmallow topping and so much more! The possibilities are endless!
I have gone twice now and both times were busy but while standing in line (which seems to move along quite efficiently) you can see what flavors are available to you and you can ask the staff for samples before filling up your cup or bowl. The «CUP» serves two people or one REALLY hungry person. The «BOWL» is giant and would serve four people. That is if you choose to fill them up all the way.
**Parents Warning: If you give your child their own bowl they will fill it up ALL the way plus some. I mean they are kids, bigger is better and they tend to go overboard. It is VERY easy for them to do that here. Which means the more they put in the bowl the more it is going to cost you!
I got a CUP both times to share with my daughter. I filled them both up to the top but not overflowing and spend about $ 5.00 each time. At the checkout you put your cup/​bowl on the scale and that’s how they determine price of your frozen yogurt creation. Which I think is about the same price you would except to pay at ColdStone or Graeters except you serve it all yourself.
Loved it! Will be back again and suggest to others gladly!

This orange leaf is awesome! I had gone to Pink Berry in Denver but this is way better! You get to pick several types of yogurt and put your own toppings on. Also your cup is weighed at the end :) I love this cause if I just need a little something sweet for my 2 year old its perfect! No waste, no mess, just a beautiful little yogurt smile from my baby girl.
Another thing I love about this is she loves the fruit from here because it’s so ripe. When you’re a parent it’s important to let your kids make healthy choices. Here she is choosing to put strawberries and kiwi on her yogurt rather than m&ms and marshmallows! I love it!
The chairs in here are made for small children, and adults. There is a patio. Also inside they play the newest kids movies on a flat screen.
BTW this location has a larger selection than Pickeringtons, but the one in Pickerington is much nicer. Both have an extremely friendly staff!

Cool place. If you’ve never heard of these places the basic concept is this you choose your yogurt flavors, toppings and other fixings. Then you just pay for whatever your weight is at the end. When i was there the line was short so i had plenty of time to take in what was available. I think there were about 5 or 6 different stations with 2 flavors on each that went somewhat hand and hand. I went with strawberry and cheesecake. Next we have the toppings. An assortment of fruits that you would normally see (strawberries, blueberries, pineapple etc.) candies (chocolate chips, yogurt bits, m&m’s) and nuts (almonds, walnuts, peanuts). But they also had some weird things like rice crispy treats, cinnamon toast crunch, and graham cracker dust. After you are done selecting what you want you get weighed, cash out and grab your shovel shaped spoon. Seems like plenty of seating but ive seen this place with a line out the door so im sure there isn’t sufficient room when its packed, so i suggest going outside when its like that (weather permitting.) All in all its a good way to treat yourself, but it wasn’t anything substantially significant. Don’t fall for the hype.

One thing I’ve learned this summer is that Columbus loves frozen yogurt. It seems like every week someone is telling me about the latest magical Froyo shop. After all the buzz, I finally gave Orange Leaf a try.
The experience was a bit like standing in line at an amusement park. The line was long with anticipation in the air. An employee explained the process of selecting your ice cream and toppings. You could ask for samples so you could create your perfect masterpiece.
I went for red velvet and vanilla. I was impressed by all of the flavor options, I wasn’t expecting so many. The brownie and peanut butter seemed to be the overall favorite.
If you love toppings, this is the place for you. Crushed candy bars, gummi bears, coconut, the list could go on and on. Your creation is weighed, so before you go all starry eyed and create a mountain of toppings remember those few extra gummi bears will cost you.
I can imagine, much like an amusement park ride this experience doesn’t end well for some. I just don’t see the 4 flavor/​11 toppings/​$ 7 creation as a good choice. But, to each his own.
The frozen yogurt was tasty, but at the end of the day I prefer real ice cream. I did like it better than anything I would have selected at Cold Stone. I’m sure I’ll be back for the ride.

I just love the concept of this place! You can’t be disappointed with your treat because you are the one who made it!
I was so pleased to see how busy this place was. There was a steady flow of happy customers.
For my combo, I tried the pineapple/​mango swirl, and the chocolate/​coffee swirl. I added a few blueberries and some coconut! YUM! It was all so tasty!
The only reason I am not giving this a 5 star is because my coffee yogurt didnt taste strongly of coffee. It was not BAD by any means, I just love coffee flavors to be STRONG! Otherwise this place was such a delight.
The atmosphere is so warm and welcoming, and everyone looks so happy to have a refreshing treat on a HOT summer day!
Please go visit!!!

You can make any combo of flavors and the toppings are endless, even marshmallow fluff.