Marcella’s Pizzeria

Very good, interesting selection of specialty pizzas. I’ll be back to try some of the pasta selections.

We were in the area for a wedding and the rehearsal dinner was held at Marcella’s. WOW! I HIGHLY recommend Marcella’s when you are near Wheatfield, Indiana. It is well worth it to divert your travel plans and get off I-​65 to eat there.
The restaurant is located at the far end of a large strip mall, so there is plenty of parking. I half expected to walk into a Little Italy-​themed restaurant, and was pleasantly surprised that the motif was aeronautical, with the waitstaff dressed as Pan Am flight attendants. Excellent!
Just a note about the staff… GREAT! We had a large party of about 30 people, with a full restaurant and they never skipped a beat.
Our dinner options had been preset, so we never looked at a menu, but judging by the size of it, it’s extensive.
We were served hot garlic bread rolls, a variety of hot-​wings and salads. All very good. Then the pizzas same out. They brought out a variety, which was great. My favorite was the margarita pizza, FABULOUS! However, all of the pizzas were terrific, so you can’t go wrong. The sauce and cheese on each pie was incredible, very tasty. Loved the thin crust.
They had a nice offering of wine and beer and the desert we were served was nice.
Highly recommend. We will definitely make this a stop when we come back through.

First deep dish I actually enjoyed! Sweet sauce is the best I’ve had. Service was great prices even better. Great family place.

A local spot I wouldn’t have stopped at if the blueberry farm we were at told us to. Wife enjoyed the mushroom soup, I liked the house garlic dressing. The lasagna was home made and had great flavor but lacked a little presentation as it came out in a bowl. Known for their garlic rolls and yep, they were good. A yeast roll covered in olive oil and fresh minced garlic. Had a good beer & wine list.
Be sure you eat here with someone you love as your both going to have garlic breath.

To start off, the staff was very friendly and décor is fantastic. The lemon peppered wings are delicious. My wife and I had their margarita pizza and we will definitely have it again if my wife accepts a job in the area.

As sand through the hour glass… Lost and lots of sand… So it the speed at which the pizza at Marcellas Pizzeria came out of the kitchen. It seemed like hours. And the staff lacked the normal friendly attitude. It was almost as if we were an inconvenience to the employees.

Pizza is very tasty and good. Garlic rolls are okay but mine were a bit hard, I prefer soft rolls. Service can be slow if its packed on a Saturday, our waiter got our drinks and never came back to take our orders so some other girl took over. Food took awhile to come out but for the pizza it was worth the wait. Overall good place just Dont go when its very busy.

I teach across the street and this is my go-​to spot when I’m stuck working late and need a bite. LOVE their food. Service is great. All in all, a wonderful pizza place.

My friend lives in the.middle.of.nowhere.Indiana. It took us about 20 – 25 minutes through fields to get to this place, but it was definitely worth it!
We got here around 5;30 on a Saturday night. There were 3 adults and 4 kids in our group, and there was a slight wait for the table. Maybe 5 minutes (note, that when we left an hour later, there were a BUNCH of people – very awkwardly – standing around waiting, so get there early or be prepared to wait).
The pizzas I saw on everyone else’s tables looked amazing! My daughter ordered a sausage pizza, but didn’t really care for the actual sausage. She liked the rest of it, though.
I got the «Marcella’s Helper» which was really delicious. It came with caramelized onions, noodles, sauce, and some other things mixed in there that gave it a delicious flavor. Yum! The curly fries we added were great as well!
My meal also came with salad and my choice of garlic bread or the garlic rolls they have (see the picture – they are amazing). These came with huge chunks of garlic sitting in a pool of delicious oil, and baked to perfection. So amazing! I wish they saved better because it would have been nice to have been able to show my husband (a fellow garlic lover!)
For all of that food, our bill was $ 24 + tip, and we had a TON of food. The service was really good as well!
I will definitely go back if we are ever in the area!

Great service.
Fantastic, fresh ingredients.
The best garlic (real not powder) rolls I’ve ever had!
Fun, fresh and clean décor.
Outdoor seating and a fantastic staff.
We dive an hour to eat here, we love it!

Dont miss their… Mama Mia pizza and garlic rolls! It’s the bomb!

Service is attentive, kitchen does not waste anytime getting pizza out, and the pizza is VERY tasty!