Toppers Pizza

This is great pizza with full flavor and awesome variety of toppings. Hence the name; «Toppers».
They are not bashful in quantity of toppings. In fact it is quite filling and worth the price. Have tried multiple versions of their chef’s creations and never been disappointed.
Late night delivery makes this a slam dunk for March Madness! Drivers are college students so tip them! They need the $$.
Rock on Toppers!

For the price it is much better than most fast-​food chain pizza restaurants unquestionably. This is definitely the go to place when you are cramming for a late night midterm, or partaking in illicit substances on campus (Geez, I feel really weird saying that as I live in California now).
I’m sad that they did not hire me as a driver :(.
Make the most of your student coupon book! They have amazing deals! Don’t forget to tip the driver!

I have a long, sorted love-​hate relationship with Toppers as a former Whitewater student, where the following is like a cult and I will forever have their phone number memorized. We get the Stix and a couple of their specialty pizzas once in awhile, usually attached to a lazy or self-​loathing weekend afternoon. They lose one star due to the shame I felt reheating The Stix in a microwave after passing out on the greasy box the night before.
It’s not super great, but you didn’t call Toppers to get that, now did you?

Single greatest pizza place I’ve been to in a LOOOOOONG time — check out the Buffalo Chicken Pizza and the Chocolate Bacon Topperstix — AMAZING

I am struggling on whether this is a 2 or 3 star pizza place. Having spent almost four years living in Chicago, it is hard for pizza joints to compete with the great deep dish pizzas of Giordano’s, Lou’s and Gino’s to name a few (along with the many other pizza places that don’t do deep dish but have amazing pizzas). As well I have a fondness for local mom and pop joints. I like my pizza to come out of a traditional pizza oven and not off a conveyer belt pizza oven (like the chains). I don’t like a lot of grease and so that is what makes me really struggle here. Toppers is a chain, so it has the conveyer belt ovens and it is greasier than I like.
What I liked about the pizza was that the sauce was good, there was a lot of meat on the pizza. There was a good amount of cheese and overall the taste wasn’t bad.
The cons are that it is, in my opinion greasy. The price is definitely not a deal. It doesn’t have a mom and pop feel.
In the end, because of where the place is located (Whitewater, WI) and the other choices in town, I will say this is a 3 star pizza place. It is better than the chain pizza joint in town. So, if you are looking for a pizza this is an A-​OK place to grab a pie.

We were staying at the local super 8 hotel in town and late at night after making it back from a concert (Zac Brown Band) @ Alpine Valley Amphitheater we were hungry. Well, Nothing open anywhere or so we thought. The desk attendant told us of a local pizza place that stayed open late. We called and ordered our pizza from Toppers!
25 minutes later it arrived and was beautifully covered with molten cheese and a hearty helping of meats and goodies. We were more than happy with this large pizza, easy on the sauce and thinner crust. It was delicious!

Not huge on pizza, but this pizza is far to greasy for my tastes.
I don’t know why everyone loves topper sticks so much, they are pretty lame.
The only occasions I have toppers is when drunken friends insist on ordering, they have a huge following in Whitewater, but it’s safe to say I don’t get the appeal.

Pizza at toppers will be heavy on cheese, medium sauce, be ready for that and yeah… Pizza is a ⁴⁄₅ in my book, near the top of my all time greatest pizza’s although I usually do not favor cheese heavy pizza due to the health factor and grease. I recommend not doing pepperoni for grease sake, but its all great tasting even if you do… The smell of the pizza is intoxicating-​ly good. You get pepperoncini peppers in the box with your order and they have become a staple for me thanks to Toppers. I recommend bite a pepper, bite a pizza slice (even if your against the idea) and that has become a toppers tradition I use today on most of my own pizza dishes.
THE HOLY GRAIL OF TOPPERS: is topperstix (do a triple order, you will regret anything smaller), they are the mecca of the cheese covered bread stick world. If you do not get anything else on the menu, get these with marinara and ranch. You wouldn’t think ranch, but trust an expert the ranch is perfect with these doughy melty cheese treats. These are a must and you will see what everyone else sees who has ever had them.
Subs and sandwiches are high quality, but the price point is scraping the top of the feasible range with subway around down on main, but they have deals from time to time to help out.
Quesadillas are new in the past 2 years, I think they need to be priced better however for their fullness factor.
Wings from toppers are good, little pricey unless you have a coupon deal, but I reco these if you have the taste for them.
This chain is expanding now from the world HQ in whitewater so there may be one around you in WI now, check around. My buddy is a franchiser there and does a very detailed job of openings and listening to customers. They are only recently chaining out, but you need to stop in.
Open late I believe to 2−3am? This is pretty much EVERY location not just Whitewater.

Skip the pizza and get a triple order of Toppersticks with ranch and cheese sauce… yum. Lots of interesting pizza toppings to choose from (hence the name Toppers) if you don’t heed my advice and order a pizza. They have expanded to several other locations but the original Whitewater location still has the best Toppersticks. Topper’s is also open late.

Pizza is weak. Value is good.
Not the best pizza in whitewater, but it is fair.

Best delivery option for Pizza in Whitewater.