Andaloro’s Taste of Sicily Pizzeria

This is by far my favorite place to get Italian. I’ve tried half of what’s on the menu. Normally at any restaurant I find something safe and order it every time. But everything I’ve ordered here has been SO amazing. Huge portions, you’ll definitely bring leftovers home. Which is awesome when you’re on a budget. Not to mention, the prices are amazing. The bread they serve with their meals is always fresh. The service is always fantastic. I can’t say enough good things about this restaurant.

My husband and I stopped here for dinner as it was a place we had never been before. They made us feel like we were their only customer… Wait, we were. Th restaurant was empty. I suspect the do more carryout than anything. The food was nothing special, in my opinion. It wasn’t awful but it wasn’t anything special either. While we were sitting there an older man with a Cain came in and stood by the door for about five minutes and after he waited for someone to come to the front to acknowledge him, he left. They definitely lack on customer service. When other customers came in, there was no greeting or welcome, just «do you have a pick up order» which was yelled from across the restaurant. The lady at the bar leaned over the bar with her coat on playing with her phone as well pretty much the whole time we were there. I wasn’t a fan of the vinyl sticky table cloths either.

My boyfriend and I love coming to Andaloro’s! From the drinks, the food and most importantly the wonderful service from what feels like my very own family, this is a sure place to indulge in good food and company.
Every time we visit, we get our classes of wine and share a pizza — we want to try them all! We always have enough to take home for the next day (or late night snack!).
I love their Portobello Pasta, and I always add broccoli. Perfect amount of spice and always leftovers (but you got to stop me!)
Thanks for the hospitality, wonderful food and great company!

My husband and I very much enjoyed our dinner here tonight! Excellent service and tasty dinner; have already recommend this restaurant to a friend!

We needed a nice place to have our family Christmas party at and we chose Andaloro’s Taste of Sicily Pizzaria. My husband and I have eaten here on two other occasions and the food was always delicious. I was a bit apprehensive to bring 20 people to a restaurant and allow them to order straight off the menu but I should not have been worried at all. Everything was perfect! The front staff were charming and kind and efficient! The back staff sent all the different dishes out together and they were all perfectly cooked. Our family raved about the food and service! We will be back soon and the family has already requested Xmas dinner party at Andaloro’s next year!

The food is very good, the service is timely and the prices are very reasonable. We have tried the pizza, veal piccata and spaghetti. Desert ranges from a very nice tiramisu to stromboli and more. Full bar with decent wine selection. I wish they would finish the paintings on the walls.

I won’t even bother to try this place. I called to find out what their web address was, and the RUDE woman who answered the phone gave me a «Pshh! We don’t have one.» remark. I called back a few minutes later figuring that just ordering a plain pie would be safe, but the boy who answered informed me that «We ain’t got no delivery guy working today.» Thanks, nevermind. Business must be booming there to be able to deter customers the way they do…

Four of us had dinner here last week. Three dinners and the aps were good but the fourth was a chicken dish and it was raw ! Inexcusable. But even worse the waitress took it back and instead of a new plate the chicken was microwaved and returned. The restaurant is also in need of an update and cleaning. We will not be back.

Italian cusine doesn’t get much better than this! When you step through the doors you get the feeling that you’re in for an authentic experience… well you are! Southern Italian cuisne is known for its simpicity, and Andalaros offers just that at very reasonable prices. Not to mention, the portion sizes are quite generous, and all entrees come with bread and a house salad, so you won’t have to worry about not being satisfied. Lastly the staff are very warm and welcoming, know the menu, and treat you well! There are no negative points to list, so if you want the true, unadulterated Italian experience, try Andalaros — it is the best in né Ohio as far as I’m concerned!

The food is divine! But, let me tell you about the interior! I hasn’t been changed since, oh…1970? …in a good way! I don’t have a drop Italian blood in my family, but I still felt like I was at home in an Italian Grandma’s home.
Portions are huge and FRESH! The House Italian dressing has a wonderful zip to it and the spicy pesto is phenomenal. Very worth a visit!

I love this restaurant. Best spaghetti and meatballs on the planet! And best Italian wedding soup. We go here every 2 weeks, service is excellent.

We tried it for the first time this past Sat night. We were very surprised. The food was excellent. The bread came out with a roasted pepper and calamata olive spread (excellent), the salad had a nice homemade balsamic dressing, the pasta and chicken were excellent. The prices were great and the service was quick enough and very personable. I felt the food was better then the majority of restaurants in Little Italy. This is a great gem of a restaurant.

Didn’t even know this place was there until I saw the Unilocal reviews. It’s a gem.
Instead of a regular olive oil for dipping, the bread came with a rich tomato mash. My wife couldn’t get enough of it.
Caprese was ok; beefy tomatoes (romas, I’d guess).
I had the veal parm; it was lean and tender. You get your choice of pasta; the fettucini was done exactly right and the spicy tomato sauces was a treat.
My wife had the gnocchi in a creamy tomato sauce. A little bland for my taste, but she liked it a lot.
We got tempted by desserts. Her coconut sorbet was, she said, one of the best she’d ever had, and was topped with a mound of shaved coconut. I got the cannoli and could only finish one — rich, but not too sweet, drizzled and dunked in chocolate.
We’ll definitely be going back.

This could be the most belated Unilocal review ever.
Our visit tp Taste of sicily in September of 2008 was, perhaps, the most memorable restaurant visit in my 62 years. My wife and I were traveling the Lake Erie shoreline on motorcycle with friends in 2008. It was a mid-​afternoon, and we were looking for a quick stop for food. Our first choice was a restaurant across the street from A Taste of Sicily, but it was closed. So, out of desperation, we walked across the street to this unremarkable little pizza place. And then, a miracle happened.
This little pizza place also had a pasta menu. And it was DELICIOUS. I will never forget the Pasta DiPortabella. We dined alfresco, and all dishes we served on china. The owners were having coffee nearby and engaged us in conversation. After dinner, they went home to fetch cups and saucers for espresso and treated us to complimentary cannoli. Excellent food, combined with unforgettable hospitality, made this visit one to remember always. Almost five years after, I still have the menu. And great memories.

Good food and good value. Chicken Marsala was so-​so. Portions are very generous. My wife had the eggplant and veal parmesean. She said it was very good.
The service was top-​notch. Our 2-​year old daughter fell backward in her chair and was immediately helped by the staff, including the manager (or owner?). Of course she was crying – more scared than hurt. They came to make sure she was ok and offered her ice cream to «make it better». Hats off to a great experience at andolaros!

Food was ok, prices ok. Service not so much. Each time we’ve been, they’ve been under-​staffed. Yesterday, my party arrived before I did (about 10 mins before me) and had still not had their drink orders taken. It was another 10 mins after I arrived that our waitress came to get us beverages. Shortly after getting our drinks, we had a spill at the table, which the waitress watched happened. She rushed away. We thought she was getting something/​someone to clean it up. NOPE! We watched her bring out entrees to another table. When I got up to approach the bar to get help, she seemed annoyed, saying she was getting something. She rushed into the kitchen and came out with… bread for the other table she was serving! What? Finally, a busboy came out to clean the mess. When the waitress came back to the table she barely acknowledged the spill, and certainly didn’t comment on the fact that she had literally left me holding the table cloth to keep the mess from going all over the place! Not cool, dude.
It was our second trip there. There won’t be a third.

Food is FRESH and great tasting. Staff makes you feel welcome.

We went one Sunday, the food was amazing, my daughter finished her soup. Fetuccini and lasagna were great… but the best was the service…
Price was OK and once before we ordered pizza that was really, really good… So, we recommend this place,

Excellent. Real veal not patties. Good service. Very nice atmosphere. I am hooked.

«Saturday night and I ain’t got nobody»… so I wanted pizza.
I called Andoloro’s since I had never tried them before and they are super close to the ranch.
I sent huzzband dude out to grab a menu (he is still my slave) since they have nothing on a website. He procured a menu. I chose. I called to place an order.
The woman on the phone was silly. A very silly woman, indeed. She clearly didn’t understand how to use a credit card reader because she called me back to tell me that my card was «declined». I was a bit shocked and immediately thought, «hmm, someone must have stolen my awesome identity!» I mean, really, who the hell wouldn’t want to be me? Seriously. So she said she’d try again after I gave her the number a second time.
She called back. Again. Still «declined». I knew something was fishy. So. I did what any self respecting woman would do. Sent huzzband dude out to pay for the pizza in person. I wasn’t leaving the house!
The card reader worked in person. How mysterious!
If you’re still reading… I realize most of this review is my boring story about TRYING to pay for a freakin’ pizza. I apologize. It was a huge part of the experience though.
They had a section of specialty pizzas. They were all Sicilian style — all white. I chose one with artichoke hearts, portobellas, tomatoes. It was alright. Not the best though. I also ordered a side of calamari that was extremely disappointing. It was the frozen stuff. And there were no tentacles. I love tentacles.
They were really nice and gave me a large pizza (for all of the credit card trouble) instead of a medium. I only ate 2 slices. If you would like some pizza, stop over. There are still 10 slices left.
I will try them again — because they were so nice to give me a bigger pizza without my even asking or making a stink about anything. I would order a different pizza next time though.