Abby’s Legendary Pizza

Love that they still have a salad bar. In a world where 95% of the population is obese. And it’s always fresh and well maintained.

Horrible. Rude. Useless. No utensils. Greasy. Takes forever. Doesn’t look clean. Not good customer service. Pizza not cooked all the way. Tasted strange. I told them it tasted strange and they just shrugged there shoulders and walked away.

We love Abby’s pizza. It is a little pricey but for us it is so much better than dominos or a papa johns pizza that we are willing to pay the price. Their Sicilian white pizza is delicious!!!

Worst pizza ever, I ordered two pizza’s one lg Hawaiian, one Greek. Both. We’re tasteless and expensive! Blew 60.00 on that dinner! Won’t go back!

I ordered bread sticks with extra cheese, marinara and white sauce and 2 spinach salads for delivery online. Shortly after placing the order online, I called Abby’s and advised I had provided the wrong phone number on accident, and gave the correct number for the order.
After 45 minutes, I received the order, and there was no white or marinara sauce for the breadsticks. When I called to speak with the manager to inquire about getting the sauces delivered, she advised that they are very busy for a fundraiser tonight for a child with cancer. She also advised that they were not sure what I meant by «white sauce» but nobody called to verify, as the person I spoke with earlier did not update the number. In all, the spinach salad was good, but the restaurant failed on making it right with the bread sticks. Not sure I will order from this place again due to poor customer service and response to address concern.

A lot of their menu can be made Gluten free & I didn’t get glutenized by cross-​contamination!
We ordered very off rush hour so they would have time to do GF properly. My 7″ GF lone star chicken bbq was very good. Staff seemed very friendly when we went in to pick it up. The website for ordering is awesome because it shows how much adding each ingredient is to each size pizza.
I hope they expand to my area (Kent) soon!

Found them online through Unilocal.Looked good, they had online ordering. Went through the whole process, submitted my address (5.5 miles away by Google Maps), chose my\ pizza, entered my credit info, and at 4“15 or so I placed my order to be delivered at 6:15. At 6:10 I got a call from them telling me I was «out of their jurisdiction» (jurisdiction, for Chrissake) and they did not deliver to my address.
Why did it take them nearly 2 hours to realize this and call me? Why does their online ordering system allow you to place an order from an address to which they will not deliver? Why didn’t they make a one-​time exception to get my goodwill? Now I either have to make my own dinner and change all my plans, or call some other place and eat an hour later than I had figured on.
These folks will never get my business. They could have won my goodwill and some great word of mouth by literally going an extra mile or giving me something free because their mistake and poor screening screwed up my meal and my evening. They
just didn’t seem to give a damn. Now I’ll be telling everyone what jerks they are. Nice move, Abby.

I reserved the party room at Abbys for my daughter’s birthday. I said that the party started at 3pm and they assured me that I would have time to setup decorations and such, but on the party day, I showed up 30 minutes prior to the party and the room was fully occupied still. I asked the employees to please clear the room so I could put up decorations and was rudely told that I was only allowed 15 minutes to prep and that the room would be cleared by 2:45pm. That left me 15 minutes to blow up balloons, unwrap all the party favors, plates, napkins, setup the tables and presents and cake. I tried to start setting up at 2:40 while the rude employee girl was vacuuming, and she told me to step out of the room until she was done.
Needless to say, my daughter showed up and only half the party was setup. She was upset that the room didn’t have hardly any decorations, and I was furious at the horrible customer service.
The pizza was good as usual but expensive. The salad bar was out of most of the items and the lady restocking it was overwhelmed by how busy they were and it was obvious that they did not have enough staff working.
Overall I like the place and the food but find it difficult to return after the poor experience.

Good place to eat pizza. Toppings are piled high so be sure to grab a fork. Free refills on soda and they serve a few different beers. They will reserve for parties.

This is best pizza we’ve had in the Yakima Valley. We ordered a ‘Hometown Hero’ on thin crust with the white garlic sauce. The salad bar was very clean, well stocked and fresh. Yum!

Expensive, but you get what you pay for. I thoroughly enjoyed my first time at Abby’s and will be returning. The staff was great, the food was fresh and delicious. We got tons of toppings, like I said, I got my money’s worth for sure.

There’s 3 kinds of pizza I know of:
* Za’ (artsy-​pizza) with fruit & nuts …
* Peatsa, which is the common pizza you feed to a kid’s birthday party …
* and HONEST pizza, which is what you really crave. Abby’s may have the first 2, but I come here for the BEST pizza in the Pacific Northwest time & time again. :-)

The pizza is not as good as Pizza Hut, I have always love deep dis but they are not good in here, not enough butter? Don’t know what’s missing, the hot wings are amazing that’s I have to give it a 5 stars for it. Will I be returning again, maybe for the hot wings only but not the pizza

Good pizza, and for those concerned they have a gluten free crust option on their 7″ and 10″ pizzas

Great food and awesome staff. They love giving back to their community. Not alot business like to do that now and days.
Great salad bar and good beer selection.

I love their chicken and spuds!

What can I say that is good about this so-​called custom made pizzeria??? We ordered a meat special with extra red sauce… and what did we get? A cold pizza, without any noticeable sauce!!! Each slice must have had 500 – 700 mg of sodium in it… extremely salty!!! Being from Buffalo-​Rochester, N. Y…I know what pizza is supposed to taste like. And this «stuff» at Abby’s in NOT pizza! If you want extremely sality bread with no sauce and mediocre service, then this is the place for you. Otherwise, make your own pizza. It’s not that difficult! In short, there is no pizzeria in this town called Yakima, WA. Get a grip!

First, I have to address that I hear this place is best for the lunch buffet. I did not go to the buffet. Sorry can’t comment on that.
But what I can comment on is the pizza and service.
I know I’m far from PA. NY. NJ. and MD. So I already know not to get my hopes up about pizza in WA. Especially Yakima, WA.
With all that said, what do I have to say about Abby’s Legendary Pizza?
The staff and service where really nice and quick. The pizza I ordered had two major problems. To feed my family a pizza with veggies I had to pay $ 31.
No that’s not the price of two pizza’s, that’s the price for one pizza at Abby’s. Granted it was their biggest cut which is I think a 16 or 18 inch pizza with mushrooms, onions, peppers, and olives. That is not a huge pizza, but still, $ 31!
THIRTY-​ONE DOLLARS!
COME ON MAN!
But I paid for it, because my mind was on pizza and I wasn’t about to have a hunger strike.
The crust was fine, not too thick, not too thin, very crisp. The cheese was good too, veggies where freshly cooked not all withered and old and dry like a farmers toenail. They tasted good and still had a little juice left in them when you chewed them.
The second problem I had, was the sauce, or lack thereof. With no significant amount of sauce or pretty much no sauce period, that pizza was a salad with cheese on a thick cracker. If I have to go home and pure my own sauce on a pizza that cost $ 31 something ain’t right. A $ 31 dollar pizza should come with a 15 minute massage or a box of chocolates, not some Easter bunny chocolate either, some good Ferrero Rocher gold foil wrapped chocolates with the crunchies in the middle.
Whats the deal with local pizza in Yakima they are so weak on sauce. Its like they roll out the dough and distribute sauce with a quick couple squirts from a spray bottle? SMH

What can you say about this place, good food good price good service it is good to take in lunch One Trip Salad, Personal Pan Pizza and Drink for a very reasonable cost.
I tired the Pizza Hut on Kern, Salad Bar really sucks