Scotti’s Pizza

Unfortunately ordered from here through Seamless, where this place unfathomably has 5 stars, before checking Unilocal and boy was the order a huge regret. They delivered it relatively quickly, although I suppose it shouldn’t take too long to microwave frozen pizza, which is what this amounts to. Mozzarella sticks were a pittance too. Seriously, save yourself the hassle and go to any of the other better pizza options around. Sure, it might be cheap and, like some of the other reviews mention, you get what you pay for. That being said, you’re better off paying a few extra dollars to get food that won’t go down rough and come out hot.

Excellent food great service. It’s a small shop with personal service. You could see how they can get overwhelmed but always produce quality food.

Waited almost two hours for cold, uninspired food to be delivered by a cold, uninspired delivery person. Yonkers food delivery at its absolute typical.

This pizza is horrible it gave me the «runs» for my money my wife always told me never ever to eat there but my curiosity to find a nice pizza place got me I ate their chicken pizza. I’ll never do that again

Very good pizza. The sauce is some of the best I’ve tasted. The mushrooms were fresh. Very nice. Very nice indeed. The crust was a little soggy, but I’m still very happy with my pepperoni and mushroom pie. Fast delivery across the Bronx/​Mount Vernon Border!

Ever since Scottie sold this place a year or 2 ago, the pizza has been disgusting. I ordered 2 or 3 times from here since it has been sold to a younger guy and what i got was a reheated pie that has been sitting around for a day or 2. the cheese was rubberized, and incredibly salty. I’ve never been back since.

I have two things to say
1. All the food is absolute heaven. all the food I’ve tried is SOOO amazing. pizza, pasta, salad, burgers AMAZING. HIGHLY RECOMMEND THE FOOD
but…
the owner scotti is the rudest most self absorbed person I have EVER met. I have been there a total of 3 times. the first time I went there he was in the front making a pizza and he never once greeted me or asked if i needed help I had to ask him. the second time the exact same thing happened. the third time which was today it was horrible. I order a chicken ceasar salad which was delicious but he was so rude and disrespectful. I went there with my mother and we went in to get a plain slice. we went in and we were the only ones there, he never once greeted us, so then my mom asked for a plain slice after that was ready she asked to see if the salad was ready which I had ordered ahead of time online. when she asked him this he gave me the nastiest look I have ever received. he then proceeded to tell us that it wasn’t ready yet with the worst tone. then he continued on working on the pizza he was making, which he was throwing around and then when he went to put it in the oven it wouldn’t come off the wooden board, I guess because he didn’t add enough flour so he got even more mad and then threw the pizza back on the counter. then a customer called to place an order. so he went to pick up the phone and as soon as he did he yelled please hold and threw the phone on the counter and when I mean throw I mean THROW almost to the point where it could have broken. then another customer came in to pick up a pizza has ordered, so the man asked Scotti for his pizza (the man had a spanish accent) he looked at the man and proceeded to tell him that it wasn’t ready but mocking him by trying to fake an accent and speaking very slowly as if he couldn’t understand, which he could perfectly. a couple more things happened today but I would be here forever going on about the horrible things scotti did. I love the food but the HORRENDOUS customer service just makes me not want to purchase food from there. that is why I will be giving scottis pizza only two stars

I ordered about 10 pies from Scotti’s Pizza for a birthday bash for my son in September. We could not be more pleased with the food and presentation. Delicious, fun (tons of variety), on time — the pizza pies were a hit!

I see a lot of old reviews and I’m glad this place is under new management. We have ordered from scotties 3 times to date and I’m waiting on our 4^th pie to be delivered. Outstanding pizza for good prices! Our favorite is the Pizzazz pizza and I highly recommend it, pep bacon sausage onion and garlic. Delivery time is never an issue, and they haven’t messed up any orders yet. Nothing bad to say at all.

New owners have been running this place for several months and the food they have been putting out is fantastic.

Never been to this place I order for delivery because a friend recommended, my first time ordering we had a chicken parmigiana with penne pasta and the sauce was really good like homemade you could taste the tomatoes the chicken was real breast a lot too all stacked up and nice sauce lots of cheese lightly breaded great experience. But second time order the chicken was really beated very thin pieces more flour than actual meet barely any of the previous meaty tomato sauce, also order a fettuccine alfredo and what a waste so blend not even salt and pepper. Pizza is ok nothing special tasteless too. I guess you only get good stuff at your first order any other time they can care less. Rude on the phone too you can hear people screaming in the background.

Very quick delivery. I ordered a Cesar salad and buffalo wings. Must say the wings were very good and came with a good amount of blue cheese.

Definitely a very big NO GO! Customer Service is non-​existent. They make you feel awkward as all hell from the second you walk in the door instead of warm and invited. They don’t have any available menus to look at. The place is a wreck and filthy along with dusty tacky pictures on the wall. I feel as though at one point a very very long time ago a family member opened it up, probably had it ran correctly made some money retired and left the business to be run by the rest of his unqualified completely lazy incompetent family who instead of running with it, ran it to the ground. Theres only one cook in the back, a little old lady who shouldnt be doing it alone and cant adequately do so alone. And three lazy guys upfront doing nothing while shes swamped in the kitchen. This is a place that I feel has potential but needs to be put on a reality «save this restaurant» tv show to do so.

Fa god sake common guys pizza is pizza! Scottie’s has ultimately the cheapest pie around $ 7.99! Face the facts, it its good enough to feed the little critters who just eat the sauce and cheese only and finger the dough. Its hot and ready when you call in advance. The pizza essentially has no taste and u need to doctor it up with parmesan cheese, salt, hot pepper garlic or all of the above. The ingredients are used sparingly. Look — you get what you pay or in life!

whole pie, $ 8, yummy.

Worst pizza in yonkers.
Cheap as hell but bland and tasteless
You are better off buying frozen pizza and making it at home.

What’s the deal with this place? The pizza blows. The pictures of the owner with his horses at Yonkers Raceway in the 70’s are awesome. Maybe instead of investing in trotting dog food he should have sunk a few dollars into Scotti’s. There’s this mean lady who hangs out there. If she’s Scotti’s wife I can see why he spends so much time at the track.

I have to say that Scotti, hands down, makes the absolute worst pizza in Yonkers. He cuts corners and uses the cheapest ingredients possible and puts a heavy amount of salt in the sauce and dough to try to compensate for the incredibly bland taste. Seriously, even when loaded down with tons of toppings this pizza has NO flavor to it. His prices are very cheap but in my opinion it’s just not worth it. Last time I was there they got my order wrong, and his big-​mouthed wife yelled at me as I was leaving the place after I had asked them to correct it.
* Just the other night, I was walking my dog past his pizzeria and noticed Scotti walking around behind the counter with his shirt off. I’m sure it must be pretty hot in there by the oven, but yuck, who wants the possibility of getting chest hair in his food?