Sergios Restaurant

My dad used to take me and my brother here once a week when we were little. I remember being so excited to go there. My young mind was sadly mistaken. If you order takeout, they act like you are bothering them when they answer the phone. last time i ordered over the phone the guy hung up on me before i completed my order. we dined in last week and that was the final straw. our food took over 30 minutes to come out. our server was a moron. she was friends with the table next to us, so she made sure their drinks were full, but she checked on us one time after she took our order. and then, she proceeds to tell us the specials of the other restaurant that she works at on her days off. i had to ask her if she was kidding. its a shame. i really enjoy helping local businesses, but if they are not going to put in effort, then i will spend my hard earned money elsewhere. the pizza is really good, but i will go to one the chains from now on.

Great pizza last night, this place is 5 star pizza as far as I’m concerned. Will go here again, often!

I live close and make it a priority to support local businesses, that’s why I’m sorely disappointed in my recent experience. I ordered 2 pies the other day got there and saw the pizzas done, on top of the oven. We then waited between 10 – 15 minutes for the lady to come and take our money. We rang the bell 3 times. Doubly frustrating because the kitchen staff is right there in front of us but apparently could not help.
The pizza is pretty good, too much cheese but good flavor on the sauce and nice chew on the crust. The problem is it’s terribly overpriced for what it is. I’ve ignored that in the past to support small business but combined with bad service, I will choose another restaurant next time.

Calamari was fake processed fish. Chicken Marsala was bland unseasoned chicken with canned mushrooms and a store bought sugary sauce. The calzone was bland with runny cold cheese. All of this for a mere fifty dollars. Avoid this dirty place like the plague.

Do not bother. If you call for a pick up order of pizza, they don’t prepare it until you arrive. They say it will be 15 minutes, and 30 minutes later they give you your pizza. For those reviews that claim «best pizza ever», I say hogwash to that! The sauce is clearly canned, and very acidic. You will be better served going to the Hess gas station for pizza. Authentic Italian? Not so much. I will tell you though, be prepared to pay $ 1.25 (plus tip) for a can of soda and a glass full of ice to be placed on your table. If you like an Italian menu from 1976, this restaurant is for you. That is ironically the last time they cleaned the air conditioning vents on the ceiling. This restaurant has been serving the 55+ croud in zephyrhills for years under the pretense of authentic Italian food, and that is just not the case.

Stopped by here for lunch with friends. The place is pretty run down and Defiantly dirty. We decided to try it since we had driven there. Average food and poor selection of overpriced soda given out of a can. Saw many health code violations including workers directly handling cooked food with bear hands. Wont be back.

Are you kidding me!!! i called in an order for 3 pies and was told to call back in an hour before coming down to get the pizza. so i called them back, they said it would be another ½ hour… AN HOUR and HALF for 3 pizzas!!! the pizza sucked but me and my guests were starving at that point.
just drive to Tampa and save some time

Absolute worst place I think I’ve ever eaten. The staff was not rude, but just very miserable. The furniture and décor was very dated and the food was horrible. The icing on the cake was that my soda was served in a glass that had an obvious red lipstick mark on it. When I asked the waitress for a clean glass, there were no apologies, is this normal? I just recently moved to this area and was trying it out… never again.

Do not come if this place is crowded.
I walked in with my girlfriend expecting a nice, relaxing Italian meal, but I was very disappointed. The place was crowded, so it was a seat yourself situation. It took 15 – 20 minutes for someone to come and give us menus, which was conveniently the time we started looking for other restaurants nearby. The menu has almost no description of any meals, and of course we got the waitress who couldn’t tell the difference between chicken cacciatore and chicken marsala. They were out of the ingredients for marsala and cacciatore, so we ordered the chicken milanese. They were able to bring us our soup and bread, but took a ridiculously long time to bring the milanese, which is just a fried slab of chicken with nothing on it. The chicken was nothing special, the spaghetti that came as a side was overcooked, and the pasta sauce almost certainly came from a can. I would excuse the slow service because of the crowd, except customers who had been seated much later than us were finishing their food before ours even got to the table. Today was not our waitress’s day, as she told us her mind was on vacation.
If you want a good, authentic Italian meal, don’t come here. I would instead recommend Vilaggio’s. While it’s further away in Lutz, and is a bit pricier, they’ve given me better food, better service, and an overall better experience. It’s well worth the drive, and the cost.

I was raised italian so I know good Italian food. Where else can you get authentic gnocchi? Or lobster raviololi?
You aren’t paying for atmosphere so don’t expect it and it seems everyone in Zephyrhills wants to dine between 5 and 7PM. So if you go at that time you may have to wait for a table and service might be strained.
Inexpensive and great quality food. Recommended.

My wife and I visit often due to how close they are to home but it isn’t the absolute best pizza in town. It is good though and the service is reasonable.

It was just OK. I would not go out of my way to go there. I had the pizza and it was not great again just ok. My wife had the shrimp Alfredo and it was soupy too much sauce. We are staying at a campground in almost walking distance and I don’t believe we will be back this trip. Just not a real favorite for me or my wife.

It’s ok. Average at best. Not my favorite pizza or meals. It is just ok. Once and awhile will go there just to change it up. I prefer the chain pizza placed more than this place.

What can I say, The pizza was good, but the staff there are absolutely miserable. Our waitress provided good service but had 0 personality. She was obviously having a bad night. The guy making the pizzas was slamming the dough on the prep table like he wanted to do that to someone’s head…

My absolute favorite Italian restaurant. Always fresh made real Italian pizza. Pastas are to die for. And wait service is fast, friendly and accommodating. If your passing by, you have to try this place. You wont regret it!

The pizza, sandwiches and salads, are really great here! I have been searching for great pizza ever since we moved to Florida 14 years ago, and here it is right around the corner from me! Nice family owned business!

We love Sergio’s! We usually get take-​out from there. maybe once a month. Typically we go with chicken parm and eggplant parm but we occasionally get the pizza which is also good.
I think their prices are fair and they’re always friendly. In the winter, it’s pretty crowded in the early evening so expect to wait or get take-​out. They’re closed on Monday’s.

I love Sergio’s, their sauce is «How grandama used to make» wonderful balance of herbs and tomato, with a hint of sweet. Very friendly service in a casual diner like atmosphere. Prices are fair to portion size, come hungry or bring some home. Would recommend! I’m a regular there.

Been going there for years. Run by lovely family. Their calzones (my favorite) are big enough for two or three people. It’s our family’s go to take out restaurant. Many vegetarian options.

This 4 star rating is for the pizza and service only.
The pizza is great but make sure you ask for it crispy! The medium is more than enough for two to share with leftovers. This is a seat yourself type of place where the service is just what you expect. They aren’t going to go above and beyond but you will not be neglected.