Mild Wally’s

I ordered eggplant parmigiana and it was the best Italian food I have ever had. I will only order from here from now on. You are better then an Italian Restaurant in lake George and that is saying something.

7.3
Old school, that aftertaste though…

This is our standard spot for pizza, antipasto salad, and subs. It’s more of a take out place, but there are 3 tables. We’ve tried out a bunch of different pizzas and subs, there’s a ton of options and prices are very reasonable. Their calzones are really good if you like a lot of cheese. Also the calzone was really big! And best of all they have a really friendly staff :)

Average food. Ordered the salad for delivery and agree with other reviews, it was soggy. However it was fresh… just placing hot chicken on lettuce and closing the lid will make it Wilty. They should place the hot chicken in a separate container to remedy this problem. Also the tomatoes and bread don’t add value… take them off and add shaved parm cheese and we’d be in business. For the area, traveling… I was happy to find a salad option honestly.

We were ordering lunch from work and someone suggested this establishment. I ordered a Caesar salad. It was not what I imagined I chose the salad with chicken. The salad was ample– plenty enough for 2. The downside was the salad appeared to have been prepared the previous week. It was very soggy and contained soggy tomatoes. Apparently the dressing– which had little to no taste was added to this mess last week also. This was served topped off with a random buttered, also old roll. The whole thing was very disappointing as this was my only meal for the day.

I always regret placing orders from here, because it always takes so long to arrive. This one was definitely my last time though. Ordered on GrubHub, and after an hour and a half I called to check on the food. He said «the driver is on the road, it should be any minute.» 6 minutes later, the driver calls, asking where on our road we were located, and that he had to keep getting out of the car and looking at the street numbers. ??? Seriously? We live on a well-​known and well-​traveled road, about 5 minutes from the restaurant. Another 5 minutes go by, and he calls again saying where he is and asking if he’s close. How can a delivery person not know how building numbers work? We go out to get the food and he doesn’t understand we already paid online, and rudely says «you gotta pay for that!» Wish I could have taken back some of that tip (that was on top of their delivery charge). Also, for a place that offers ice cream pints for delivery, you should find some way to not let them turn to soup on the short drive over.

I’m very disappointed. I ordered a meatball palm sub three different times in a row requesting it to be extra toasted. When I got this sub it was so soggy I ended up throwing it away each time.

Can’t go wrong with dollar slices thur-​sat after 9 o clock. I’ve been a fan since I came to albany, do yourself a favor and order zeppolies.

Mild Wally’s is my go to ordering spot. The heart attack fries are amazing, as are their subs. The subs are packed with whatever filling you choose and definitely fill you up. They also carry Ben and Jerry’s ;). I usually order from Grubhub and the delivery is always within the estimated time range. Only issue is that the delivery fee on Grubhub is $ 3.00. Otherwise ¹⁰⁄₁₀! Will order many more times to come.

I used to think this place was alright. until I tried ordering out a few times on delivery. Took about 2 hours to arrive, and when it finally did they had forgotten items I ordered and paid for. When I asked to speak to the manager about it, he refused to give me a refund on the food that was missing from the bill after I paid in full. I then asked to speak to the owner had to sit there and dignify to him what I «wanted him to do» about the fact that his poor service restaurant messed up my order and that now I had to sit there and watch everyone eat their meal while I was still waiting for mine.
Best thing this place has going is dollar slices on Thursday, Friday and Saturday. Other than that, skip it. Garbagio.

ordered a specialty pizza on New years eve. I must say hands down best pizza in the capital region.
I suggest chicken bacon ranch or their amazing wings!
I’ve been here a bunch of times. The pizza guy (same guy I usually see behind the counter) is a staple of this place. cheerful and energetic despite the busy night.
Thank you mild wally’s for making a buffalonian feel at home with your delicious pizza & wings

Went because I had a coupon and was very unimpressed. The pizza was mediocre with crust that had cooked unevenly. Unfortunately can’t comment on the other food items but I probably won’t go back.

Good drinking pizza! Not sure how it would be without alcohol, but you can’t beat $ 1 a slice! The only thing they need to change is their hours because they close to early!

This place is fantastic! Never received a bad meal from Mild Wally’s. Everything from their catering to their speedy delivery is on point. The guy Brett behind the counter makes a phenomenal pie and is super friendly. Brian, the owner, is always making sure things are beyond expectation. I have been eating here for years and I am a huge fan… Definitely recommend this place for any meal.

Typical college pizza spot, however, it is way better than the pizza where I went to college. The pizza here is actually surprisingly pretty good. Thin crust, good cheese, doesn’t taste like frozen pizza as I would have expected. They ended up burning my pizza so I had to wait for another, but otherwise, I would recommend.

BBQ Chicken pizza… yum!

Still great!
I’ve been back here several times since my initial review 5 years ago. The place is pretty busy on the weekends including on Saturday nights when I stop in here for pizza.
On my last visit to Mild Wally’s, I ordered a Large 16″ Baked Ziti PIzza for carryout since I had a 50 percent off pizza coupon to use up. The discounted pizza price was only $ 8.00 with tax! It did take a while for my pizza to be all set (approx. 30 minutes) since the place was very busy and they were handling large delivery orders. I read through the latest issue of Metroland while waiting for my order.
I enjoyed a slice of fresh baked ziti pizza in the car before heading home. The pizza was loaded with al dente baked ziti with ricotta, parmesan, melted mozzarella cheese and zesty tomato sauce on a thin firm crust. The pizza was very tasty surprisingly not messy, nor greasy since the melted cheese held the ziti together on top.
I will continue to drop in at Mild Wally’s for late night eats whenever I’m in the area.

Pizza was okay, almost tasted like frozen pizza you get from the grocery store. The wings were pretty good. Fast delivery. Not a bad place but not something I would want to try again.
Wish there was better food in Albany.

The calzones are my favorite from here. They are huge and take up half of a large pizza box. My only problem is with their delivery. They charge $ 1.75 for a delivery fee and most of that goes directly to the business not the driver. There are plenty of places around that offer free delivery. They are usually late too.

I finally made it back to Mild Wally’s after just about 10 years. It pains me to say it but it was a bit disappointing.
1. Something was off with the pizza. It just didn’t taste right. Obviously it’s been a long time so it’s entirely likely that I’ve hyped myself up about it over the years, but I do seem to remember it being better than the pie that I got (which had just come out of the oven, so it wasn’t sitting around for a long time). Granted, it tasted close to what I remember, but it just was somewhat bland and seemed a bit undercooked.
2. Hey guys, that bottle of soda? Yeah it expired months ago. Partly my fault for not looking at it before I left, but still… c’mon man!
It could very well have been an off-​day or a random bad pizza (so I’m not going to change my rating for the place), but I have to close this review with:
Carry on.