88th Street Pizza

Called in for delivery at 5pm asking for it to be delivered at 7pm. Came at 5:45. So had it been a normal delivery I would have been happy. When I specify a time it really messes up dinner plans. Delivery guy was unapologetic. Ordered extra large BBQ chicken. It had no chicken what so ever, yet tons of mushrooms. Almost like a vegetarian BBQ chicken pizza. The pizza tasted fine just a little off missing checking. The other pizza was extra large half pepperoni half cheese. It had 5 pepperoni TOTAL! Same thing, the pizza was good but expecting ½ pepperoni not ¹⁄₈ pepperoni.
I think this place has hope but is lacking in attention to detail. For $ 46.90 not counting tip I feel it’s extremely over priced. I can get the same pizza’s, better tasting, properly made. with better customer service from Papa Murphys for $ 28.

Ordered Philly cheesesteak at 8:00, they said I had to order minimum of 15.00, so I asked for double meat, because I was at 14.50 and that was not the minimum, I ordered extra cheese and they said it would be 45 minutes. Almost 1.5 hours later they called to inform me that they were running late. I received the order 1:40 minutes after initial order— no extra meat and no extra cheese. Quite pathetic, it is now 2! hours after order and still no replacement sandwich. DO NOT ever order from here. Straight out of Philly is ONLY option for cheesesteak, what an incredibly bad experience! Also, straight out of Philly subs are several inches bigger than this pathetic offering.

We’ve ordered pizza here at least 8 times. Being from NJ I equate pizza to NY style pizza. 8^th Street makes a great NY pie we crave. They deliver and have taken my credit card over the phone. Never had a bad pie here, in fact it’s our goto pizza place for pizza at home.

Ordered delivery from them for the first time tonight — a gourmet margherita pizza, the 88^th street special pizza and an order of mozzarella bread. Arrived in 45 minutes still hot, and both pizzas were delicious. Not the kind of mozzarella bread like you’d get from a chain but that’s not a bad thing — a halved French bread loaf with cheese, parsley and paprika. Wife raved about her margherita pizza several times. Will definitely try them again.

Tried to order food but guess what… They don’t take credit cards over the phone. It’s 2012 guys.

Great pizza and calzones! The salads are worth a try if you are feeling like a rabbit ready for some veggies!!!