Stevi B’s Pizza Buffet

Appleton, WI is sorely lacking a decent place to get a salad-​bar and this place follows this rule instead of providing exception.
It DOES have the salad bar, but it features a mixed-​greens cornerstone populated with mostly iceberg lettuce and very little else. There is no spinach option, and the carrots, one of the few fixins, are unsliced baby-​carrots.
For nearly $ 7 for just the so-​called salad bar, I would expect more.

After refusing to pay almost $ 60.00 for LUNCH at golden Corral (outrageous !) we crossed the parking Lot to Stevie B’s. FOV half the cost My husband Myself and our TWO Teen Boys ate a nice lunch. We did ask for a couple Of PIZZAS To be Made and it was done quickly. They brought the PIZZA Right to our Table and the 4 of Us took Most Of Each of them. It was not the best pizza
ever had but It was better than many. I really liked the Mahganritta pizza…-yum! thanks for great service and good food.

We arrived on a Tuesday at 11:30am. There were literally two pieces of pizza available on their buffet. When I asked an employee why there were no pizzas on the buffet, she claimed that if they make them too soon they have to throw them out because nobody eats there between 11 and 11:30. As stupid as this will sound, I asked her why don’t they just open at 11:30 instead of 11. She didn’t respond to that but she did offer to make me a pizza. So I had that going for me… which was nice.

I’ve been here twice for lunch and won’t be back. Service is ok. Pizza isn’t very good and that’s when you can get it. It’s a buffet but at noon they only have two slices of pizza per each selection. If you only like one or two of the selection then there’s not much to offer and they don’t refill the empty selections very fast.

We visited the Stevi B’s located in Grand Chute Wi and had to share our experience. We have visited the restaurant several times before and were overall pleased in the past with the food and service.
Today was completely different. I should have know it was not going to be a pleasant visit when the only works the cashier shared with me were «How Many,» «$ 32.xx,» and «here» as she returned my card. Nothing nice or even full sentences.
As I was getting my first round of pizza, the staff could be heard behind the counter discussing their ‘horrible pay’ and how hurt the store would be if they ever left. The conversation on my second trip up was even better. According to their conversation about people named Amanda and Crystal, they can’t stand each other and Amanda doesn’t get here ‘stuff’ together soon, she has it coming to her. Great conversation for a family of diners, including my 7 and 5 year old, to overhear. By the way, the word ‘stuff’ was not the word used but was cleaner than the words actually used.
Being they were preoccupied with their conversation, no attention was being shown to guest, the buffet, or the tables. The buffet was virtually empty and the pizza was cold and old. Something is wrong when I have to coax kids to eat pizza. The salad bar had random food in the wrong bins and had not been wiped done in a while. The only food restocked during our visit was one pepperoni pizza and the lettuce. This was replaced just before the employee made herself a salad and another employee was already making a salad.
Normally, the service is great. People will stop by our table several times to collect plates and make sure everything is going well. No one stopped by any of the tables. At least 6 tables had stacks of plates from the time we arrived to the time they left.
We have attempted to contact their home office twice to no avail.

To start off, the cashier gave us a hard time about using a coupon we had. I enjoyed the pasta and dessert pizzas, but the regular pizzas were just ok. A variety of pizzas were listed on their menu, but they only had four or five of them on the buffet. You could request a certain type of pizza, but then you had to wait for it to be prepared, so we only did that once. The kids seemed to like it, but I don’t plan on returning.

Stevi B’s is the place we go when we’re famished, but we don’t want to break the bank. The pizza buffet is $ 6 per person, which is very reasonable for UNLIMITED pizza. Is the pizza amazing? No, it’s not. In fact, it’s very average. But the fact that you can eat your to your heart’s desire (and then some) for so cheap is pretty darn cool.
The inner pizza snob in me scoffs at this place, but the bohemian in me knows this is a really good deal. I like that you can order any combination of toppings with either wheat or white crust. The best pizza I’ve had there was really simple: just white cheese. I also enjoy the taco pizza and the loaded baked potato pizza (both asked for sans meat because I don’t eat it). When you order a «customer creation,» then you take a seat and someone brings the whole pizza out you, piping hot, and asks how many pieces you want. I always feel guilty when I order a customer creation, but then fill up on lots of other pizza before it’s ready. But the rest of the pizza goes up to the front of the pizza buffet for any other customer, so I know I shouldn’t feel like I’m «wasting» pizza!
When I feel guilty about eating too much pizza, I enjoy loading up on the salad bar, too, which actually has a great selection of toppings. I don’t come here for the salad, but the salad bar offers a lot of options, too.
There is also a little arcade section, which my boyfriend and I have had fun playing. Who says you need to be a little kid to enjoy arcade games? Obviously, the prizes are way overpriced (in tickets) compared to the actual value, but it’s all in the fun of it.
3 stars for the pizza, 5 stars for the price, and 4 stars for the whole experience. Even though I know I’m not getting gourmet pizza, there are times when I’m starving and want nothing more than to eat as much pizza as I want. Stevi B’s is the place to go!

I’m not sure these guys understand the concept of a «buffet». They were strangely devoid of pizza. Plus it was difficult to find a clean plate. That last point seriously put me off. I don’t ever expect to return.

Perfect for quick tasty pizza, cheap, extremely clean, nice staff, Skot was the manager on duty the second night we visited he was great, very friendly. We need one in Green Bay!

Ordered this as carryout for a night of games and few cocktails. We were extremely pleased with the pizza, not to mention the half hour pick up time that was news to our hungry tummys on a Saturday night. We had a coupon for a buy a specialty and get a 1 topping free. Got the cheeseburger pizza and although we asked for no pickles and onions and they came on it, we ate through them and it really resembled a cheeseburger. The pickles were just set on top so we just devoured those first. We also ordered a sausage and a pepperoni pizza as well as breadsticks. I had the sausage pizza that was pretty typical with small pieces of sausage but the breadsticks were amazing. The twist in them helped the garlic, salt and other seasonings stick to them and we all enjoyed the sticks. I didn’t have the pepperoni but it looked like a typical pepperoni. Between the 6 of us, the pizzas were almost all gone so we will definitely be ordering from here again.

I believe I may have passed the coveted 2,000 calorie barrier. But I had to, because you can’t sample all of the specialty pizzas without eating a bunch of pieces. The ones I would recommend are the taco pizza, spinach alfredo, chicken fajita, and for quirkiness, the mac & cheese. Desserts and salad bar with tons of options included, we had buffets for a family of 5 with drinks and tokens for the arcade for under $ 30. Service was very friendly, we were asked if they could make a specialty pizza for us that wasn’t already on the buffet. Food was in the upper quarter of chain style pizzas. All I know is my high school students I teach highly recommended it, and for the quality you get and the price you pay for it, I agree.

Had high hopes for good food, was very disappointed. I will say cheap, $ 5.99 for an adult all you can eat. My 10 year was ok with the food. The also have a arcade for kids. Will not eat here again though.