New York’s Best Pizza

If you need a divorce from your average chain pizza restaurant, this place is IT! Excellent food and equally excellent customer service! Support small businesses like this!

That was my first time ever ordering at this place and I was not disappointed. I’m from Chicago and I was looking for some good pizza and it was great. I will be back and I will try other stuff on the menu as well.

Another home run. This place is a family run business and they are great at it. Second time and was more impressed this time. New go to pizza place. Quality products. Nothing seems frozen. Have It your way.

This place was quite disappointing. Customer service was fine, but the food itself, well let’s say I could have done better in my own kitchen. The breadsticks looked like a loaf of bread spread with butter and garlic paste. The «stuffed» pizza was not at all what I was hoping for. #1 it was majority stuffed with sausage. Hardly any cheese or pepperoni as it states it has. And #2 the «marinara» sauce tasted like processed tomatoes with hardly any other spices. The only decent thing was the crust but even that was mediocre. I haven’t tried the other products on the menu, but with what I experienced, I won’t go back to try them.

Pizza is really good I also tried the lasagna and it was great as well the staff is super friendly and aim to please I will try this place again and again if you are on Pioneer street stop by and grab a slice you want regret it.

Now that was a good new york pizza! Got a large 2 item the guy i assume was the owner assured me it wouldn’t be soggy, i cant stand soggy crust pizza. It was spot on I will be back again

Ordered pizza tonight and didn’t feel like getting the usual Domino’s or Pizza Hut. This pizza place wasn’t too far away so I decided to try something new. We ordered an XL pizza for $ 17.95, 8 wings for $ 6.95, and a slice of tiramisu. Our total came to $ 33. Delivery is always expensive to me but what can ya do. I swallowed my pride and temptation to reason about how I could make a meal in the time it would take to deliver and placed the order. Our order arrived in an hour and the woman who delivered was very sweet. Our food was hot although it could have been hotter. But I didn’t mind too much because I do understand that it’s cold outside.
Taste wise I was expecting more from the reviews. I have had New York style pizza before and frequented two excellent pizza places when I lived in Chicago and while the pizza did satisfy us, I wouldn’t say it was the best pizza I have ever had. Portions are good though. The pizza was a good size and the slices were huge. The buffalo wings were decent and on the larger side. Tiramisu was good, true to tiramisu recipes.
Bottom line though, if we are in the mood for something different, we’d order again.

Very seldom do I give 5 stars… But this pizza sent me to heaven. I didn’t want the typical chain pizza and decided to give it a go. I drive past it everyday and I checked out the reviews and I took off. This place was very clean and tidy. I was greeted with awesome customer service. I placed my order and as I was waiting the gentleman had pulled out fresh pizza roles. He said that he wanted me to try 1 while I waited. Omgggg to die for. At that point I knew I didn’t want my pizza to go. I decided to stay and eat it right there. He offered me a plated. I turned the offer down and ate it from the box. The wait time was about 7 – 10 mins for my pizza which wasn’t bad at all. The small pizza I ordered was $ 5.83. It was so delicious & fresh. The menu items are cheap if you ask me. Dont sleep on this place get out and give them a try. I will definitely be a repeat customer and will never order from a chain again. I highly recommend them.

Best steak and (extra cheese) with little mayo ever! Pizza off the chain. Wings good made my husband sweat a bit. Highly recommend, staff very friendly.

Simplest and cleanest tasting pizza ever! This place has such uncomplicated flavors, it’s incredible. Tried the veggie pizza this time around and I could taste the freshest ingredients. For once I thought I was actually building health.
Oh and DONT FORGET their deserts! Tiramisu cake was the bomb! Great texture, lightly sweet and slightly chilled. Perfect!

First time trying New Yorks! We ordered it for a group at work, and had it delivered! It was FANTASTIC! Everything was very fresh and tasty! Everyone raved about how good it was!
They were also very friendly taking out phone order as well sa the delivery! …even offering to deliver to our location, even though technically we were out of the ‘delivery area’.
Thanks Guys!
You will be our ‘Go To’ pizza place!!!

Very good pizza for the price. Their stuffed slices are hearty and filling. The windows are tinted too so the seating area is pleasant to sit and enjoy a meal during lunch. I would recommend this place for a quick slice. No beer though…

Unilocal brought us here off the highway… thanks to all of your other reviews! Our party had the outstanding pizza, delicious calzones, best mozzarella cheese sticks ever, and scrumptious pepperoni rolls!!! Our only regret is that we live 3 hours away! Clearly they are a local favorite since their phone was ringing off the hook with to go orders and about 20 locals came in after we did and it was 1:30 in the afternoon! We will definitely be back next time we find ourselves in the area.

Really good pizza and good prices! Definitely a pick up or delivery type place though. It’s really small and they only offer canned drinks. I still left happy though, just next time I had it delivered! :-)

A nice hole in a wall place, great food great prices what more could I ask for? Also they’re remodeling at the moment so there’s a reason why the interior is lack luster. The food makes up for it.

Pleasantly surprised, best pizza! Crust is light and fresh, right amount of cheese and pepperoni!
Lemon pepper wings piping hot!
Would definitely eat here again!

Despite what others say, who is probably only used to pizza from dominos, Pizza Hut, or papa johns, which these place have ok pizza but definitely is not great pizza. This place is pretty good after I try it.
I’m from New York and it’s pretty close to New York pizza. The layout is like New York pizzeria, small and tight, but New York don’t have a lot of space like we do, so they do give me a New York feel (just like home). As for the chucky cheese comment, I think you can only compare little ceasar to chucky cheese. I order a special made baked ziti pizza and it was great, it’s not exactly the same taste but it have a distinctive taste that is good on its own. I’m definitely coming back for more.

I have had the pizza 3 or 4 time. So far it has always been fresh. The shop front is very clean. I love the pizza and our has been consistent. The staff is friendly too.

Disappointing. I had looked forward to trying this place since I spied it one day in passing. To have a sit down pizza place relatively close would be really nice. Scratch the sit down part, while they have a few tables it is a very tight fit and the tables are too small to really eat comfortably if you order anything more than one medium size pizza to share amongst you and a few friends.
Pizza was just okay. not the worse I’ve had but definitely not the most average either. It was surprising and disappointing when our chicken alfredo pizza was ready to see that the chicken in question was a previously frozen chicken patty cut up into pieces and put on top of the pie. Drinks are all canned with no cups nor ice. No service to speak of as you order at a counter and then pick your pizza up at same counter when it is ready… just an FYI, I consider this a fast food environment and do not tip as I don’t at McDonald’s or any other like eating establishment. Keep that in mind when you have a tip jar up front and center.
While the prices are exceptionally good, I doubt that we will ever return. Shame as it is awfully convenient.

New York Pizza & Ice cream is new to the neighborhood. although the ice cream shop has been around for a while pizza and pastas have been added. Great New York style pizza along with hot subs, calzones, cheesecake, Buffalo wings and all sorts of ice cream. The pizza is crunchy and delicious, the subs are cooked to perfection and the strombolis are stuffed with mozzarella, pepperoni, Canadian bacon and sausage. Great food for a great prize. I encourage everyone in the area to give it a try.