Mylks Cookies

I recently visited from out of town at the recommendation of a friend. Unfortunately, my visit didn’t live up the the recommendation. I felt like my presence was a nuisance to the employee. The red velvet cookie was extremely dry and crumbly; difficult to eat. I had even asked which cookies were moist and the employee couldn’t give me a definitive answer on which ones were freshly baked. I also ordered the Tiger Paw cookie which was ok-​not as dry.

These cookies are no less than delicious! Always freshly baked accompanied with cute embellishment they could bring a smile to your face on tax day. A few I like are snicker doodle, red velvet, and cookie cake. My only reason for not giving all five stars is the service. I’m pretty sure the owner is the one that served me twice and good lord was I uncomfortable. She didn’t smile, barely said two words, and didn’t even thank me for coming in. It was extremely awkward.

These cookies are so delicious! So much variety! My personal favorites are the Red Velvet, Winey Dodger, and Apple Pie. SO GOOD. I can’t say it enough! This is a must visit in Auburn! It is very small and hard to miss, so when driving around, slow down a little! I would give this 5 stars but the staff can be unfriendly at times.

I’m in Auburn for the week and happened upon this place– it is such a gem! The kind of place I would love to own. Great fresh cookie selection that will satisfy anyone’s sweet tooth. The Tiger Paw (similar to a girl scout samoa) was so good. Already planning on going back before I leave town!

I’ve been a Cookie Monster lately, so when I discovered a new cookie shop in Auburn thanks to Unilocal,I absolutely had to evaluate it for myself posthaste.
No one was at the counter when we stepped inside, but then a nice gal came out to wait on us. Took me a while, but I settled on the chocolate chip (can’t argue with a classic) and the peanut butter cookie filled with Nutella. Both varieties were beyond awesome. Moist, sweet but not too too so, and soft. The chocolate chip had to be greater than 50% chocolate, perfect for the chocolate enthusiast like myself. The Nutella added a fun twist to the all-​American PB cookie. There’s a long list of cookies on the menu but it looks like a fresh selection is sold each day. The chocolate chip cookie and other regular cookies are $ 1.99 and the stuffed cookies are $ 2.29. My companion ordered the Heath bar crunch cookie which was highly praised. I had a bite and agreed.
We took our cookies to go. There’s no seating inside but there are a few tables outside. Wish they were open Sundays but maybe that’s a good thing for my wallet and waistline.
There’s a frequent buyer’s card: buy 10 cookies, get one free. I’ve already encouraged someone else to go to this place, and I am planning a return trip back. Mylks does a body good.

I’ve never considered myself a sweets person until I visited Mylks. These are the best cookies I’ve had in my life-​really.