Anthony’s Pizza and Pasta

No complaints! I like to go for the two slices and a drink lunch deal. I have never had a problem with service and they have always been professional and efficient in my experiences. Pizza has always been delicious. I have almost become slightly addicted to it.

$ 37 pizza. Called in for an order 5 mins before they were supposedly closing orders. Would not take it. They said they could sell what they have forslices at $ 37. When i askedwhy couldn’t we get a pizza price for the numberof slices we needed (same as a full pizza) The answer was «Thats all i can offer, take it or leave it.(That was june 5)

The pizza here is amazing, but it does take quite a while for them to bring the food out. It is worth it though. I definitely recommend this pizza place.

Amazing NY style pizza (coming from a true New Yorkah) Delivery is always pretty quick and service has been great. Especially like the primo bread and marinara sauce. I’ll miss you guys when I move back to NY in a month.

Pretty good ny style pizza in an open relaxed casual atmosphere. Cheap and delicious and they have the spices and cheese at your table if you want those. Also offer beer and maybe liquor as well as fountain drinks and pasta.

The pizza is great. The cannollis are delicious. I definitely recommend the farmers salad with ranch. Staff was very polite.

Always good and fast! Best calzone and pizza in Aurora so far! Toppings under the cheese is not my favorite. gets a little soggy and wet but still pretty good.

What can I say I love this place especially after they remodeled. I’ve never had New York pizza but I bet this come really close. You can’t go wrong with pizza unless it’s a copy frozen one. So check this place out its good!

I hate to be this person… BUT it’s been a reoccurring problem at this location & after my attempt to first solve the problem with management failed I figured I’d leave this review.
First off-​the pizza is awesome! I moved to CO from the Midwest & have had a hell of a time finding some decent pizza & Anthony’s solved that for me!
The problem: pick up orders take over 40 minutes. No matter the day no matter the time and the managers response to a complaint is «there’s nothing I can do for ya». This is a general manager at that. When I explained I didn’t have this issue at their other locations his only response was that he was a general manager and couldn’t help me. I worked at pizza places for 4+ years throughout high school & my undergrad years in college & never once told a customer I couldn’t help them.
Overall A+ pizza & D– customer service.

Thankful someone delivers to Murphy Creek! Good pizza! Not as greasy as I remembered, which is a plus. Good size. I would recommend the Neapolitan as the crust wasn’t too thin but not thick either. Delivery driver was very friendly. We will order here again.

It has to be 5 stars. I dont really care about the service etc, but that was fine. Great Neopolitan slice, or what we call a slice in NY. Thin almost cracker-​like crust, full sized pizzas, oily (a sign of good cheese), balanced pizza sauce (not too much oregano or anything, not raw) perfectly made pizza (proportions and cook).
And all the NY Pizzeria basics for your pizza… For me just a couple chili flakes.
Good prices IMO.

I love the lunch special!!! Such an awesome lunch spot. Great value, friendly staff, generous portions. Their garlic bread is delicious. Pasta dishes are pretty good as well. If you are looking for a great new York slice, look no further.

Asked as soon as I came in which pizza just came out bc I wanted fresh slices
Then the guy says they all just came out while I’m looking at a rack of 12 pizzas
Then I wait 15 mins for it to come out
And it’s deff not fresh like he said
Only reason for 2 stars is bc other whole pizzas looked awesome
And cashiers as was nice to look at lol

I ordered a pizza to go from here last night. I love pizza and consider myself somewhat a connoisseur having lived in Chicago and visited many places known for pizza. This pizza has surprised me. I really love everything about it.
It has tons of pepperoni the sauce is spicy. The crust is delicious and thick at the ends. I can’t say enough good things about it and it upsets me because I don’t live in Colorado anymore so I can’t have this whenever I want.

I love ordering pizza from this location.
My visit tonight was wonderfully uneventful, which is exactly how I like it.
Ordering a pizza on Friday night, I expected it to take a bit longer than usual. When I called in my meal the girl who answered told me it would be about an hour before my meal was ready. I showed up 45 minutes later expecting to wait for fifteen minutes, I waited 15 minutes and my meal was ready.
The pizza was hot, the cheese was perfectly melted, the wings were spicy, and my family loved it. Thank you all for a wonderful meal.

Just like a Good east coast should taste. Nice fast service. I have been going here for years. Puts everyone else to Shane.

For now, it’s a 3. I’ll have to give it another shot before changing my rating. I got a slice of the huge slice, but that was a mistake. The flavor and texture was great, just not entirely enjoyable since I had to throw out half of the bread. I plan to try the thin slice next time.

Maybe it was an off night but my son and I ate here tonight since we were in the area and it was not good. My slice of pizza was sopping with grease and toppings looked like they just got dumped on top and heated up. My son had pesto pasta and it came as a bowl of spaghetti with bland oily pesto sauce and hard garlic bread. No one asked how we liked it and the vibe in there was awful– the place had no music and the workers seemed grumpy. Won’t be returning.
…month later …
I am changing my review from 1 to 3 stars. After the last experience here Peter contacted me and gave us two free pizza coupons to give them another chance. We went to the location off 8^th and CO this time. It was nice inside– very up to date and clean. We ordered the same pizza as last time with a salad to go. I only had to pay for the toppings and salad, so thank you Peter for that coupon. It was definitely better than the last time. We got meatball, black olive and green pepper again. Unfortunately I don’t think they used meatballs though– it was more like crumbled sausage. But it was cooked better and we appreciate the offer to try again.

I was teetering on 3 – 4 stars for this this place. The pizza is very good by the slice, but lacks a bit of oomph if you buy a whole pie. I don’t know what they do different, but whether you buy pizza by the slice, or by the pie matters. They taste completely different, so if you are looking for a well-​oiled NY style slice, this is a great spot. You want the whole pie? It’s alright.
The service in house is very good. The manager is great and the staff is personable. Delivery can take a while (a long while). I suggest you go pick up your order. It’s worth it.

Very good New York style pizza. The price is a little high but worth it. Great place for kids and they also serve beer, which is a plus.
The guys that work the counter and the kitchen are great. They are always friendly and seem like they are having a great time.