Papa Saverio’s Pizza

Overpriced. Sauce tastes like it has four cups of sugar in it, when its actually on a piece. Will not order again

The pizza is just okay. I think it’s overpriced. $ 40 for 2 pizzas?! It’s not that I’m opposed to spending $ 40 on a dinner; I’d consider Papa Saverio’s again if the quality was better.
We ordered one thin crust pizza with sausage and a BBQ chicken pizza. I don’t like pools of sauce, but this pizza barely had any sauce. Overall the sausage pizza was bland. The BBQ Chicken was good, but I’ve had better elsewhere.
I will give Papa Saverio’s credit for friendly service. When I lived in Plainfield, all of the pizza places seemed to lack basic social skills, but both on the phone and the delivery driver were pleasant and friendly people.
Papa Saverio’s pizza just didn’t do it for me though. With so many food options nearby, including pizza, I doubt I’ll order from them again.

Great pizza. By the slice and pop special is 4.00… super affordable and we are full. Crust was excellwnt. Not greasy at all!

I give this place a solid 5. For the past 4 months, my family orders from here once every other week. Usually its just pizza but we have ordered most of the other menu items too. The wings are good. Typical standard wings but done right. The burgers are even pretty good as well. I like their sauce and the amount they use on their pizza. Double dough is a favorite of mine too. Haven’t had a bad experience yet.

Since they have reopened after the remodel their food and especially pizza is still delicious without a doubt.
The girls answering the phone tell people that their order will be ready for pick up in 45 minutes, which turns into half warm soggy pizza every time. I began stressing the words «Well Done» and with no luck.
Maybe they should try a slice of their $ 20.00 soggy half warm pizza that they’re serving up! Happy microwaving

Ordered a large thin crust pizza with sausage and an order of wings. The pizza was pretty typical thin crust pizza, except for the sausage. The sausage was ALL OVER the pizza and full of flavor. The wings were very good and the customer service is also good.
They offer coupons with some pretty good deals, so look out for those

I should know better than to order a burger from a pizza place, so I guess it’s my fault I have had bad experiences with this place. Unfortunately the cook doesn’t know how to read. My receipt clearly says no onion, but had massive amounts of onion all over it.

We ordered a large pepperoni pizza with wings and a two liter for delivery. They said it’d take about 45 minutes to deliver, which is fine. We ordered using grub hub, and in the special comments asked that our cell phone be called since the call box to our apartment complex does not work. The delivery boy never called. My boyfriend happened to see his car in the lot and went down. The boy said he didn’t see the comment, and instead just continued to ring a box that obviously doesn’t work.
When we opened the box, the pizza looked burnt. My boyfriend checked the bottom before we tried it, and found that the pizza wasn’t burnt, but it was cold to the touch. We tried a piece, and not only was it cold, there was absolutely no sauce on the pizza. We live a little over a mile away, so there’s no reason our food should have been cold. He called the restaurant back and explained that our pizza was cold and sauceless. The guy on the phone asked if per wanted a discount on our next purchase. We asked if we could just get a new pizza, which he said wasnt a problem. He just asked that we give back the old pizza so he could show his supervisor.
While we were waiting for the new pizza, we decided to try the wings. Those weren’t very warm either, and they didn’t taste fresh. After a half hour, the new pizza was delivered. It looked drastically different from the old pizza, definitely not burnt and hot. But there was still no sauce. The cheesy bread we received (twice) was not worth the $ 30 we paid for it.

waited over an hour and 15 minutes for my pizza. pizza was cold by the time it got to me. i tried to call to ask for a refund but i guess i was one of the last orders, so i was unable to talk to anyone. i will be calling tomorrow to talk to the manager and asking for a full refund. i am beyond livid considering i live two miles from this establishment.

First time trying pizza. Not good at all! Thin crust was very doughy, way to much sauce and sauce not that good. We have tried a lot of different pizzerias and have never had a pizza that none of the family liked… or finished, until now. Sorry Papa… this is the worst pizza we have ever had.

I left the Chicagoland area back in 1999. The one thing I miss the most is good pizza. I am not so into the deep dish pizza that a lot of people love so I stay away from it. Now you want to get some thin crust sausage or pepperoni pizza? You MUST go to Papa Saverios! I only just got hip to them about 4 years ago during my visit from ATL to go see my family in Elgin. I am so hooked. This is the first place I want to go when I get there besides Portillo’s where I get my Maxwell Street polish.
Anyway, their pizza is cut in squares the way I like it and the cheese grease is the perfect ratio… mmm, mmm, good!
Oh, if you are like me and you eat French fries with your pizza, don’t order any from them. They are always hard and too dark with not much potato. I am not tripping too much because they are a pizza joint. What was I expecting.
Only downside is they down ship out of state. :-(They still get 5 start though.

Good pizza but under new management… specials are confusing.

Customer service might be forgotten at most places however it still exists at Papa Saverio’s in Aurora. I had a rather poor experience which resulted in my previous Unilocal comment but the owner went above and beyond. I received an apologetic phone call the next morning (which honestly went quite the distance) and then received a credit towards my next purchase/​dinner.
I was not expecting anything and even mentioned that is not what I am looking for, I was just happy that I received a phone call. The owner apologized once again and insisted I take the credit.
Shows pride in your business when you swallow the pill and call an upset customer not knowing if fuel will just be added to the fire. Well done & I want you to know it is truly appreciated!

Very good Thin Crust Pizza, Great cookies. This is a takeout or delivery only location. Groupon deal is awesome for this place. I took the advice of a previous Unilocaler and asked for the Pizza to be «well done» and it came out perfect with golden brown cheese and crispy crust. Perfect. My family loved it. Surprised it’s a chain considering how good it was. They only have slices at lunch time.

Good pizza. Sometimes they take a while to get to the front desk. Other than that, a good place to go.

Four stars because it’s a chain pizza place with really good thin crust. I was really surprised. This is one of the best thin crust pizzas I have had around here. Went way beyond my expectations. I bought a 15 for 30 Groupon and was sitting on it for a while. I got an 18″ cheese and two more 16″. The toppings are over priced but it was still very good. «I’ll be back»…also, you know it’s good pizza if it passes the cold test. I drapped up the leftovers, put it in the fridge and the next day it was great cold… can’t say that about many pizza places.

Last night, Miss Chrissy W. was supposed to cook me a healthy and delicious meal, consisting of what she already had in the fridge, which I knew to be Brussels sprouts and a «cute pork tenderloin.» I told her I’d bring the pinot.
Well, I got there with the pinot, but apparently, the pork tenderloin was smelling questionable. Enter, a groupon for pizza!
With her $ 30 groupon, we got (and no, we didn’t eat it all!)
A 20″ cheese and mushroom thin crust pizza.
3 (yes 3) cannolis
2 cookies (1 peanut butter, 1 chocolate chip.)
Not bad, considering a 20″ pizza elsewhere is going to run you WAY more.
The flavor? DELICIOUS. This pizza had the perfect crust, perfect sauce/​cheese/​veg ratio, and was not over/​under done. It was baby bear… just right. No wonder the box said «the pizza you’ll fall in love with» Yep.
I don’t eat cannoli, so I can’t attest… but, the peanut butter cookie was to die. Take that sucker, throw it in the microwave for 30 seconds, holy schnikies, I burned my tongue on molten peanut butter, but I didn’t care!
Now, I come to see that Papa S’ doesn’t have a location exactly near my home, but I will freakin’ drive to Rolling Meadows for that deliciousness… we don’t have good thin crust pizza out by me.

First time there. Used a Groupon. Very happy I did. We had spinach, garlic and chicken. Excellent. Girl at the counter was very pleasant

My wife and I used to eat here about every week. They used to have great stuffed and Chicago-​style pizzas. Lately though, they’ve changed the sauce for some reason and it’s not so good. They had some really good sauce before — fresh with chunks of tomatoes. Now, it tastes more out-​of-​the-​jar — to sweet. We noticed the last couple times there’s someone new cooking the pizzas so perhaps that’s part of it, I don’t know.
We also have had a couple bad experiences with the spinach pizzas (bad bathroom experiences if you know what I mean).
Lately they’ve also raised their prices. With all the pizza places in the area, we’re going to be skipping this one in the future.

Their double dough has tons of crust, all favlorless. Imagine a circle of regular breadsticks surrounding a pizza that is effectively one size smaller than ordered. My 14″ pizza was more like 12″ due to the significant amount of crust. Shame on me for ordering double dough.
The pizza itself was ok. Although their menus look the same as Sarpinos’, don’t get it twisted; Sarpino’s is way better for the same price — oddly, they have the same specials as Sarpino’s, too…
It’s a carryout only location with a nice staff, but I can’t substantiate spending my pennies on a bunk pizza.