Orange Leaf Frozen Yogurt

Delicious frozen yogurt with plenty of different flavor offerings. Cleanly, friendly staff, and plenty of comfortable seating. Nothing to complain about.

I’ve always liked this concept, but it could get expensive… and you didn’t have any idea what the cost would be. However, they’ve made all that better by just charging by the size of cup! I’m happy :)

Would come back again. They get you on the weight! Girl was nice to offer samples on checkin.

A good place for a quick froyo fix. It’s a good location with friendly staff and a clean dining room. There are always lots of flavors to try (even if I still tend to gravitate to the same ones…) and toppings galore (except no Fruity Pebbles… what’s up with that?). It’s the same good stuff you expect and done well.

Self-​serve fro-​yo places were created with me in mind. I love trying new flavors, and LOVE toppings. Orange Leaf is also genius because they’ve invented dividers for the cups so that I can try three entirely dissident flavors all at the same time without the embarrassing situation of realizing that lemon does NOT go with peanut butter or pumpkin spice. My only wish is that you were charged by the cup, and not by weight, because I tend to choose heavy toppings. Still, I’m a fan.

Excellent service, great frozen yogurt, & the bobas (tiny juice filled balls) are very tasty! But I wish they had smaller bowls. Other than that everything was great!

The staff at Orange Leaf (this location specifically) was incredibly rude. This was my first experience at Orange Leaf and I am hesitant to visit again. There were, however, plenty of options available.

This would be more a 4.5÷5 score. I had an amazing experience there. They easily trump Yogi’s in yogurt flavors and in taste. The had a ton of toppings and sauces (including Kiwi). I had a mix between brownie and wedding cake topped with M&M’s and Raspberries and it was delightful. The service was impeccable and the store manager was very accommodating to my family. My only knock about Orange Leaf is the Honeydew flavor which my father did not enjoy, but he settled for French Vanilla. The location in Avon is tricky to get to with no easy access from Rockville Rd. (US 36). You have to turn onto a street and then go behind the Bob Evans and strip mall.

I may be the minority on this one. But I will not be back to Orange Leaf. I am a frozen yogurt LOVER. Like an I sometimes skip dinner all together for this treat kind of girl. I was in Avon and searched on my phone for a nearby spot to grab a quick treat. Orange Leaf popped up so I decided to try it out.
Upon walking in, it had the typical bright minimalist modern feel — a la Pinkberry. There were quite a few flavors to try but I skipped the tastings and jumped right in. I loaded up on the white chocolate covered strawberry, cherry, and of course vanilla (I always make a point to try the vanilla on my first visit as a benchmark … if you can’t get vanilla right, there’s a problem). The toppings selection was not bad, but cut so huge that it made it blatant they were trying to bring the weight of your cup up. Not a huge deal, but common at least try to be a little more creative about it. I grabbed some strawberries, raspberries, and kiwi and called it a day.
I decided to sit outside and took my first bite. In all honestly I probably only took about 4 more. First, the spoon is downright obnoxious. Why are you trying to reinvent the wheel? It’s a spoon people, use your money in a better way, like making better yogurt. Next, all the flavors reeked of artificial flavoring. I tried the plain strawberry yogurt my friend got and it was like eating a spoonful of Nestle Quik. All the flavors I tried were like this; wayyyy too artificially sweet. Lastly, when I leave Huddles, Yogurtland, and even Pnkberry I feel good about what I am eating. The yogurt is fresh tasting and I know that I made a better decision then ordering that chocolate molten cake at dinner. I can not say the same for Orange Leaf.
I am not sure if Avon has other frozen yogurt options, if not, I would opt for the frozen section of your local grocery store.

I went there. I ate the pineapple frozen yogurt with the cheesecake yogurt. It was so good, I died. The end.

What an awesome treat to top off a night. Wish i had thought of it. Only problem is the price, but that may actually come as a benefit, it keeps you from visiting too often!

The best most healthy treat around town. PERFECTION!!!
Thanks Jordan/​Kevin and the entire staff for supporting us in law enforcement!

Best frozen yogurt place I’ve ever been to. Had a long line, but there was a reason… it’s worth the wait

My new favorite froyo place on Indy! Better taste than red mango and more variety than huddles. Go and go often so it stays open, that location in particular is certain death for restaurant!

I have tried to find a phone number to call the store since I was charged a different amount then what is on my receipt, but I cannot fine one. I have enen gone to the corp website and no phone number is listed. I called my bank and there is nothing they can do, I need to call the store directly.
Unless this issue gets settled I cannot return to this store and I urge others who pay with a debit card to beware.

It’s so nice inside. Definitely not the best looking frozen yogurt place I’ve been to. The orange spoons are very unique too! My favorite flavor combination was the pineapple and coconut. Basically a piña colada in virgin form.
Downside is… the taste/​flavor/​value don’t meet my expectations of other frozen yogurt places such as Red Mango.
Pros: Nice décor /​spoons /​friendly staff /​variety of flavors and toppings
Cons: tastes very sweet /​no nutritional value…(so don’t be fooled, do the comparison)