Peter Pan Diner

My boyfriend and I found this cute little place, while adventuring around! I really enjoyed the food! As well as the staff! I ordered over easy eggs which were cooked perfectly. not too runny ! I also endured in the craving of a peanut butter chocolate chip pancake! which happened to be the best tasting pancake I have ever eaten! Not to mention my boyfriends salad was huge! portion size for the price is great ! check it out !!!

Favorite diner!!! Nice staff, great food, especially if you are in a hurry. I would suggest Peter Pan to anyone! Relaxed place with a wonderful vibe. Classic diner.

2 poached, corned beef hash and home fries… as good as it gets…

Best diner we have been to in a long time! The food is always on point, the service is great, and their delivery has been extremely convenient with a 15 month old. Will always highly recommend this place!

This used to be our favorite place to go to for lunch but lately it has gone down hill. First of all, the wait staff was very rude and we sat here for at least 10 minutes until someone even took our drink order. The food has been pretty good but last time the spoon cut the inside of my mouth because it was like a razor. The cashier, Irma is very nic

Yikes! I was hoping I would enjoy this place, sadly it turned out to be the complete opposite.
The service was absolutely horrendous. I had the waitress YOLANDA and I was not impressed. She only paid attention to a few family friends that came in after us, and didn’t even come over to the table once to see how everything was or ask if we needed anything. It took myself yelling over to get her attention while she was socializing with her friends to ask for a refill of soda. For 2 sodas it cost almost $ 6…thats crazy!
I had «The New Champ» …a prime rib sandwich with fries. It didn’t taste like prime rib, pretty sure it was some roast beef heated up in the microwave and slapped on an old roll.
My boyfriend had chicken fingers and fries. He enjoyed his meal until he found what looked like an eyelash underneath one of the pieces of chicken.
We did not walk, we ran out after we paid our over $ 30 bill.

Great diner! The Greek salad w chicken is usually my go to and they do it right and generous .
Can’t go wrong w their breakfast either

Had a waitress at the PeterPan Diner that looked as if she had ring worm on her hand. This unfortunately was not the first time, I personally witnessed open wounds and cuts on the wait staffs hands. Pretty disgusting and not a pleasant site. I will NEVER return here to eat again.

I’ve been going here for years and love it. The staff are friendly, wait time is short, and the food is great. Texas Smoke is my favorite sandwich, burgers are well made, and the desserts are fantastic. I switch up what I order because the food never leaves me disappointed!

While the good here is pretty good the customer service leaves much to be desired. I hate to be this person but numerous times when I have gone here I have seen myself and other customers of color being treated differently then other customers (not being greeted when we come in or when the owners walk through to speak to the customers or not being offered to spin the prize wheel when the customers in front of us were offered to despite spending the necessary amount). I have chosen not to speak on this several times when it’s happened but it’s become so glaringly obvious that I felt I had to. This diner is located in a diverse area; this kind of behavior is outrageous. Shame on the owners and staff.

Amazing staff and good! Well sized portions for the price! The owner is awesome! Overall a great place and I will continue to go here a couple times weekly! Highly recommend this diner!

Great place with a friendly staff! Manager is a great guy and good crowd of people. The breakfast was great and the coffee was excellent. Will definitely be coming back.

I came to Peter Pan diner and got their lobster special. We each got two lobster tails, vegetable, mashed potatoes, bread, soup of choice and a Cajun chicken breast for $ 20.00. One of the most incredible deals I’ve ever seen. Love this place, whenever I’m remotely in the area we dine here. Love love love it. The owner is so nice!!!

Just looking for a lunch spot driving east today and let the gps pick a diner. Was a lucky pick. Had the Greek burger and the waitress helped my wife pick out the Mac and cheese sandwich. Both excellent service was fast. Staff friendly.

My husband and I went here for the first time today. I got the Belgium waffle with fresh fruit. It was amazing. My husband had the eggs Benedict with a side of sausage. He also was extremely pleased. The sausage was so fresh, like from a butcher. We will be going back.

I’ve been to this diner a few times over the years and always am pleased with the food. On our most recent visit I got whole wheat pancakes with apples and cinnamon in them. It tasted fresh, as did our friend’s chocolate chip/​peanut butter pancakes.
The staff is always pleasant, the décor is normal Long Island diner fare, but the food is always solid. If you happen to be on that side of the service road you could do far worse =).