Three Sisters

I love this little sandwich shop! The food is always fresh and delicious and the warm chocolate chip cookies are worth the long wait out the door. There is no indoor seating– just tables outside, so this is only a place to come to when it’s nice out. Some might find the outdoor décor off– putting because it’s all stuff one might find in a rummage sale or on the side of the road, but somehow it all works. My husband likes to call it «yard sale chic» lol! The only issue is that it’s cash only and the prices are high so it adds up. Bring cash!

A good sandwich at a good «island price.» Fresh, pleasant service, great cookies and a funky vibe to the outdoor only seating areas. Much better than what you’ll find on the harbor. Walk inland a couple of blocks and escape the tourist haunts. You won’t be disappointed.

Great sandwiches, incredible cookies. Had a lovely lunch there today while wandering the island. It was a bit chilly outside but they had decorated the tables in a very seasonally appropriate manner. It was a great place for an easy lunch.

Came home again to R.I. last week. Ordered and waited outside on picnic tables. Picked up sandwich, back to table, opened it to find wrong sandwich. «You got what you ordered», the be-​atch told me. Ah, not really, I don’t eat roast beef and I ordered Turkey. Sandwiches are good, but don’t blame the error on the customer. Most of us are alert, oriented and sick of the Be-​atch sisters. Attitude has NOT changed since my visit last year.

We stopped in on our bikes after riding by the previous day. Sooo glad we decided to give it a try — the sandwiches were unbelievably tasty! We had the roast beef and tuna subs. Both were great but the roast beef was absolutely melt in your mouth good. And the warm cookie was the ultimate finish. The Three Sisters setup is perfect for BI: park your bikes, order inside, go find a table in the shade out back, and wait for your name to be called. Then soak up the sun and the fabulous flavors of this great lunch spot! So simple and easy yet a great way to have an island lunch. We will be back next time we’re on the island.

So good! A smaller version of Something Natural on Nantucket minus the crowds. These women work their butts off producing high quality fresh sandwiches. Of the five we tried, definitely recommend the meatball sub. Also, don’t skip the chocolate chip cookies — a definite way to satisfy your appetite while waiting for your sandwich in the idyllic yard (on a hammock, at a picnic table, perhaps hula hooping).

We loved this place! It’s a perfect location to get lunch and relax. The atmosphere is awesome and welcoming. We had the twisted sisters in a wrap. It was delicious. Though it may take a little not to receive your sandwich, it’s worth it. Everything is made to order

Great & very informal spot that reminded me of Berkeley, CA. Excellent mix of sandwich and salad options, with fresh baked chocolate chip cookies to power our bike tour of the island. Add to that mix super friendly service that welcomes a great mix of kids & adults. Outdoor seating only in a delightfully funky and shaded yard.

This place was super cute but the woman who took are order was RUDE! It was almost time to close for lunch and we asked if it was too late and they said no but then treated us like we were a total hassle. I decided to get a drink after we paid and went in to tell the woman and was completely ignored!!! To pay for a drink!!! The young teenage girl bussing helped me but I was appalled at how RUDE the woman was. The sandwiches were bland and the $ 9 salad was the size of a side salad. Then after the shop closed we were still eating and the RUDE woman came out and sat at a table right behind us waiting for us to leave, we were sitting outside!!! I will never go there again. Do yourself a favor if you don’t want bland food with a BAD ATTITUDE go somewhere else for lunch!!!

We showed up without a reservation and they kindly fitted us in.
The food was simple and a little limited on choices but everything we got was great. We tried everything on the menu and each thing was great in its own way. All the seafood was fantastic. It was very nice with the love music outside.
Would definitely come back.

This little joint has a fun vibe and great food. We stopped in to grab lunch on our way back from town to the beach. They are cooking in a tiny little hut but have the plan well mapped out. You walk up to the front and look at the menu before going inside to order. You then order your sandwich or salad (grab one… or two homemade chocolate chip cookies) and then go out the back door to wait for your food at picnic tables and grab condiments and utensils. The back has tables and umbrellas set up to chow down there or you can opt for takeout (which we did) and head to the beach. My sister and I enjoyed our sandwiches thoroughly and liked that the options were healthy with fresh ingredients.

Consistently delicious. I recommend the meatloaf sandwich and the McSister. Please know what you want before you go inside through the front door to order! It’s a tiny tiny place.

Best sandwiches on the island. Bike here from the ferry, grab a Twisted sister from these hard-​working ladies who make EVERYTHING to order, and go exploring. Don’t forget to grab a homemade cookie as well!

Beautiful outdoor seating and amazing fresh sandwiches. The Meatloaf Sandwich is THE BOMB. Best sandwich i’ve ever eaten in my life — and i’ve got 50 years of sandwich eatin’ experience across three continets.

Really delicious, freshly made to order sandwiches. The twisted sister with turkey, bacon and avocado was super yummy; also the Brigid’s Beach (not positive on the name) with salami, provolone, roasted red peppers.
The service was polite and friendly although the wait was a bit long for «just a sandwich».

Great sandwiches. Personal favorites are the twisted sister and the celeb sister. The mustard on the celeb sister is just out if this world. Sandwiches are always yummy and made to order with fresh ingredients. Also their fresh baked chocolate chip cookies are just to die for.
However, we have had bad service here. The employees can seem rude and do not easily apologize for any mistakes. The wait for sandwiches at time is ridiculous.
We have now taken to ordering over the phone and picking up to avoid the cramped house just to order and then wait.
Great lunch place for a sunny day. No indoor seating so keep that in mind when wanting to check out island dining.

Great sandwiches in a cute little place with funky outdoor seating. Great option for lunch, just on the edge of town. They’re only open from 11:30 am to 2pm. Apparently, they were also getting ready to start an open-​air nighttime seafood grill featuring whatever was caught fresh that day… That gig is in the backyard seating area and its called «Mr. Sister». Although we didn’t get to try it, I can almost guarantee its great, and our in keeper raved about it.

Pretty subpar service. One of the «sisters» was rude and they got the order wrong. Perhaps the sandwich competition is not terribly stiff so they can act the way they do.
All of us were pretty hungry so although we received the wrong order we ate the sandwiches anyway. I guess the silver lining is the sandwich I happened to eat was pretty good (hence the 2 stars).

Delicious sandwiches
Impolite service
Pseudo-​bohemian atmosphere
Minuscule. Busy, with slow service. Tasty food. Outdoor seating to service a quick pass-​through of a kitchen/​service-​counter. The dining room is essentially a back lawn and picnic area behind the tiny structure that houses the operation.
I was one of more than a handful of people who wandered out of the ordering line muttering under their breath «what’s wrong with THEM?» after getting treated curtly for no apparent reason.
I have no need for a return visit after the first impression. Delicious is fine, but with all else in the equation, whatever to this place.

As a native New Yorker, I take my corned beef sandwiches seriously; don’t change it and please don’t try to reinvent it. When I started commuting to Philadelphia, before I was informed about 4^th Street Deli, I was in desperate need of a corned beef sandwich. My co-​workers suggested a few sandwich places that served Reubens. It was served with russian dressing and coleslaw. I am used to sauerkraut on my reubens but hell… I decided to give it a shot. It was one of the worse decisions I ever made.
I was hanging with the family July 3 on Block Island. I read about Three Sisters on Unilocal and decided to give it a try. A nice10−15 minute walk from the beach, we arrived at Three Sisters. It’s a small cottage with picnic tables in the back. With so many options on the menu I decided to go out on a limb and order the McSister. It is a lean corned beef sandwich with Swiss cheese, Russian dressing and coleslaw on a sub roll. Swiss cheese is one of my lease favorites, and like I said earlier, I am very particular with my corned beef sandwiches. I am not sure what they are doing in the city of brotherly love, but they need to have a chat with the ladies of Three Sisters.
There was nothing over the top about it, but that was pretty good sandwich. My wife’s sandwich, the Twisted Sister, was pretty and the other members ordered the Big Sister, which looked pretty appetizing as well. All sandwiches are served with a bag of potato chips. If you are on Block Island during the summer and in search of a light lunch that is going to satisfy your hunger, then Three Sisters is your place.