Baked of Bloomington

What’s not to like? Custom baked fresh cookies you can get delivered and they are still warm.
Some kind of dream I think. I love the oatmeal recipe. I want nuts in mine, not chocolate. More nuts, any nuts. Does not matter what you prefer, you can custom load them for yourself which is a dream come true for afternoon coffee or late night. Sensible hours for what they do, 12 to 12.
This is another treat we use at work for birthdays like we did last week. Hellloooo Mr. Popular!

While visiting Bloomington, I wanted to buy my husband a chocolate chip GLUTEN-​FREE cookie cake (a cookie that is the size of a medium pizza). They were able to turn around the order in 24 hours but I was extremely disappointed in the cookie, especially for $ 28. Not only was it very thin, the taste was just okay. I asked for it to be covered in frosting like a cake and it only had a very thin piping of frosting along the perimeter of the cake. Upon serving it to 13ish people, they all thought it was just okay. It was definitely not what I expected. I was thinking it would be more like a Mrs Fields cookie cake which is much thicker, much more tastier and has a good amount of frosting on it. I would not recommend anyone buy a cookie cake from this place and the price for what you get, pretty much makes it ridiculous.

I loved Baked! It takes a while for them to be delivered, but totally worth it. My favorite thing is to ask for chefs choice and see what they come up with. Recently they gave me pumpkin dough with cheesecake bites and white chocolate chips — amazing!

We’ve ordered cookies from here multiple times. While the delivery can take awhile, the cookies are pretty darn good! Good value too; when you work it out you get a lot for your money.

!!!
Why don’t we have one in Houston!!!
I love the idea. LOVE LOVE LOVE. OK. So, I normally don’t buy sweets because I bake and I do it whenever I run out of baked goods so I have a constant supply of baked goodies at home. Also because I think most baked goods outside are too sweet. I was a little iffy about these cookies, but like I said — awesome idea. I had to try it.
First of all, this is like a cookie pizzeria, as someone said in another review. They even come in pizza boxes! You pick a cookie dough and you throw in (or on) whatever you want. It’s sort of like Amy’s Ice Cream where you pick an ice cream and you add in any mix-​ins and toppings and the Ice Cream Master mixes it all together expertly right before your eyes… You get the point. …Well, you tell the person taking your order what you want. You don’t actually touch any of it until you’re eating it. Never mind the technicalities. All I know was that I looked at what they offered, and I had absolutely no clue what to get myself. What I did know was that you had to buy in multiples of 3 and that I was going to wing it.
I went out for lunch and decided to find this place to bring back to the hotel room. It turns out it was right around the corner. Yay for small college towns where most everything is concentrated in one main area. :)
I walked in… and it was quiet. No one was there. At least the door was unlocked? I called out. Nothing. I looked around. Nothing. It was only when I began to venture past the cashier’s counter to peer into the kitchen that a guy walked out. O_​o He told me he’d be right with me. Hm.
Lack of prompt service aside, he was pretty friendly.
I looked up at the menu… then I saw a sign for orphan cookies in the display case. :(And they were only $ 2.50 for three (otherwise, it would be around $ 1.50 each)! AND it meant that someone else already did all the hard thinking for me and all I had to do was take them home and devour them! I immediately scrapped my plan for wondering what to order (it didn’t help that I just ate lunch so all the blood had rushed to my stomach and I was in no state to think hard) and asked who the orphans consisted of. They were all safe except for the S’more cookies (they sadly didn’t use vegan marshmallows in them… do they even have vegan marshmallows there?) so I took one of each: chocolate chip, triple chocolate graham cracker, and peanut butter with white chocolate and Oreo’s. They came in a personal-​sized pizza box. I loved it already and I couldn’t wait to have them later that day.
When I did, I had a bottle of water ready (no milk, sadly), just in case they were too sweet. First, they are sweet, but not THAT sweet. I still needed some water to wash them down, but you’re supposed to drink water (or something) after you eat anyway to help prevent build up in your throat to prevent halitosis the older you get. Second, they were still soft and chewy. All of the flavors were there. I WANT MORE.
You know what? I’m going to try to go again and see what other orphans I can pick up!

This has to be one of the most unique and coolest concepts! From Chicago on business and a local told me about the place. Checked them out online and the options can be a little intimidating and/​or confusing. INCREDIBLE COOKIES, much more than I was expecting to be honest with you. I’m in the parking lot now, two days later waiting for another 26 cookies that I’ll be bringing home with me. Not sure I can resist eating a few on the way home though.
Favorite cookie for me:
Sugar
–Reese’s PB Cups
–Butterscotch chips
–Oreos
Topped with vanilla frosting. 5 Star Cookie!

Not that great, takes forever for delivery which is expected, but they don’t taste all that amazing. But when your craving cookies and you’re so stoned you can’t move, This would be the place to get them from. Just don’t expect them to be great. Kroger cookies taste better.

Baked is going to give me diabetes one day I swear it. Yeah as the others reviewers have posted the cookies themselves are not that great but where else are you going to go for fresh baked cookies at 1 in the morning. Yeah that’s right the answer is my kitchen but I’m too lazy! Also the play on weed is a little overbearing. We get it, you smoke pot!

Slow delivery; inconsistent and overpriced cookies. I’d like to see Baked step up its game and deliver a higher quality product. I really like the idea of Baked (I have such a sweet tooth), but the execution is just sloppy. Employees are always friendly on the phone and in person.

By far the most delicious cookies I have ever eaten! This is the first place I take all my friends when visiting from out of town. They have a huge assortment of different options to cater to your taste buds. I usually order sugar dough with toffee, white chocolate chips, pretzels, and vanilla frosting on top.
If I had one con, it would be that the delivery times are often very slow. That is however, the only problem I have encountered.

Nearly all of my friends swear by Baked, and I have tried more than once to see what the fuss is about. I personally have found Baked cookies to be much too sweet for my liking.
Sometimes the vegan cookie dough runs out, which leaves you out of luck if you are vegan. One time my order was completely burnt at the bottom. The service is usually hit or miss.
I appreciate what Baked is all about, but if you are good at baking by yourself, I think you may be better off doing that. Nothing I tried was really remarkable or made me want to go back for more.

Yummy!!! Awesome cookies! We ordered a baker’s dozen of random recommended favorites to bring to a party, and they did not disappoint! Even 4 hrs later, the cookies maintained their gooey goodness.
They place has a chill vibe with hanging artwork and random board games to play while we waited for our cookies to be baked. Staff is friendly. Will definitely return!

After my first time getting baked, I must say that this place is awesome! The whole vibe is sweet, and the cookies are top notch. The cookies are made to order and the drink selection is full of drinks that compliment your cookie: like milk.

Standing outside Baked at 1:04am. Sign says open until 2am. Workers inside. Door is locked. Not going back again. Disappointed as we drove 90 minutes after checking their website and Unilocal for their hours.

I absolutely love Baked and will visit Bloomington just for their cookies. If you love chocolate and mint, you have to try their chocolate dough with mint chips & walnut cookies. They are mind-​blowing, top of the world. whatever you want call it :) Soft, warm, perfectly baked with mint flavor just melting in your mouth. I am almost tempted to have one as I am writing this review :)
And they come in cute pizza boxes. You can order min 6 cookies — make your own kind (3 of one kind which is great as you get to try different ones). And don’t forget to have it with milk. I have never had anything close to these tempting cookies before and even now.
Baked is open till 4 am on weekends and they have few sofas where you can hang out with friends.
Sometimes, you will get some extra baked cookies for just $ 1. That’s a steal. Or if you are lucky like me, you will find a box of free ones around. Love, love, love this place!

OK so hear me out… Cookie delivery… the words themselves illicit a feeling of pure ectasy the idea of something so genius literally makes my head want to explode. YES the cookies themselves are delicious yes but when you wait for 2 hours to get your delivery one tends to get upset now add to that the fact I called and was told by a very rude woman that she was sorry but that’s just how it was. Now if the cookies were cheaper maybe then I could give 2 maybe 3 stars but the service I received tonight was absurd. I mean it’s a Tuesday night so come on baked get it together already the people of Bloomington need you. We need to be able to order fresh baked beautiful little round disc’s of heaven from our sofa while watching Netflix but can we just get them a tad quicker? Thanks.
The delivery chick however was kick ass I even tipped her despite the mishap

This place is better than oreos. Recommended at a late time. Because its such a nice place with your choice of dough, toppings, and amount. It’s in my book for my next visit.

I get cookies here more then I should… Like multiple times a week. Lately however I have been greatly disappointed by the service. Last time I got cookies there it was a relatively quiet night (Tuesday) and they forgot my cookies in the oven so they burned and they had to remake them. They did not realize this until I asked them about it after waiting half an hour, they gave me extra cookies which was a kind gesture but the order was wrong. I would rather have the number I ordered and them be what I ordered but after waiting an hour in the shop I was really over it .
Tonight I ordered cookies for delivery and the order was wrong again but did not realize it until the delivery guy left. The girl on the phone also told me the wrong delivery price and failed to add in tax when she told me the price. This is a minor inconvince but all of this adds up to bad service to me, and I will not be going back as frequently until the service has improved to what it was.
The cookies are good but expensive if I’m going to pay nearly a dollar fifty a cookie they had better be the right ones.

Awesome dessert! Fantastic cookies, intriguing atmosphere, cool mix-​ins; loved it! Wish they had something near where I live like this! Unlimited number of mix-​ins, delicious dough bases, yummy!!!

PARENTS (yes mine included) — LISTEN UP. This could possibly be the greatest gift you could give your child who is having a rough week, just took a major exam, finals week, little five week… Every week? Buy your student baked and have it delivered to their place. Just ask for a box with however many cookies and to get a mixture. There’s literally endless toppings. It takes a while for them to bake and be delivered, but getting it as a surprise is one of the best things a college kid could ask for.