Andy’s Frozen Custard

The BEST thing on the menu is the turtle sundae. Worth the occasional splurge as it is $$$ and loaded with calories. Big enough for 3 to split! We go once a year and it is consistently good.

I didn’t think I would like Andy’s since my only other experience with custard has been Culver’s. Andy’s is SO MUCH better. Their malts are amazing– simple, but really tasty. We’ve only been there twice so far, so I haven’t had anything else, but they have an extensive menu with lots of options for all tastes. It’s a little pricier than your usual ice cream place, but I think it’s worth it. Their drive through line always seems long, but they have a good system and they’re quick with taking your order and getting it to you.
Bonus: We had our puppy with us in the car both times and they offered us a sample cone to give to her. So nice!

As good as it gets. we have been sticking to the pecan concrete and the proportion of butter scotch to caramel and pecans is perfect …
The drive thru and the seating setup is very open and well designed

Swung by on a Sunday night at 9p. Busy but line moved extremely fast. $ 32 for six of us. It was good! Wasn’t sure what to order since it was our first time, so we all ordered different things and we all loved it.

I can’t believe this landmark of the Ozarks is in my back yard! I first experienced Andys custard in Springfield Missouri probably around 1998. I was there visiting my sister and she wanted to show me this other custard place. «Other» meaning the direct competition to Ted Drews which she had taken me to in St Louis.
I love custards! It’s SOOO smooth and delicious!
Since that day any visit is not complete without a stop at Andys! I nearly fell out of my chair when I saw this was in Bollingbrook!
It’s the real deal! Same delicious taste they’ve been serving in Missouri for years!
So lucky to have them move into the area!
When we pulled in the line was so long we barely made it in the parking lot but they were FAST! It took less than 2 minutes to get our order at the walk up window and the line we saw was cut in half by the time we walked back to our car which was maybe 5 mins.
So don’t be discouraged if you see a massive line at the drive through! It will move quick and even if it didn’t, it would still be worth the wait!

Andy’s ice cream is the best ice cream in Bolingbrook! They never disappoint!

No doubt the best frozen custard you will get anywhere. A bit pricey but heck treat yourself. Service is always quick and attentive.

Wish I could give a negative star but I can’t! My family and I went there today 4÷24÷16! We had our emails for free comes from the loyalty program! My husband and son got their cones with their emails and I was handed my cone from my email (all card numbers are different) as we were walking away they were chasing us down saying my loyalty card number was not working for my free cone (so I showed the email that just came today at 4:02pm and on the app that showed I had a free cone) they said there was nothing they could do so I needed to pay for the free cone or give it back (mind you I already started eating it) so I said take it back then because I’m not paying for something that is free!!! They were very rude and said if I had an issue to call corporate! NEVER AGAIN WILL WE GO BACK!

Had the Brownie Sundae. Soooo Good!!!

I scream for Ice Cream? Pretty much. Didn’t know what to expect. I found them a little pricey. I had a hot fudge sundae and my better half had a mint concoction and together we were at 12 dollars for relatively small servings.
Was it good? Yes… high butter fat mouth feel. We also got the buy one quart of yogurt get one free for under five bucks.
My impression is Andy’s is good, but not worth the drive. Since we live in Aurora, we can get custard just as good for less drive and money at Banana Split.
Will update after we try the frozen yogurt.

UPDATE: the young man at the window (Sunday, February 6) approx. 4pm was extremely courteous. I ordered the Straw-​Ana and it was delicious.

This place is amazing. The custard is to die for. I always get the jitterbug which is my all time favorite.

Great variety of custard. They have banana splits, shakes, malts, mixers that you can add candy into, and a wide variety of other frozen custard treats. If you’ve never had frozen custard before, it’s similar to ice cream.
They also sell bottles of soda here. Open late and they have a drive thru!

My go to for custard. I love a large vanilla shake with triple oreo or oreo n thin mint. Hesth os always an excellent option. I prefer vanilla over chocolate and their vanilla is amazing.

You know what you’re getting when you drive up to Andy’s: a fun location to hangout and pickup some tasty frozen custard. The staff here is friendly and accommodating, and the line moves quickly to place your order. It’s a clean place, with the décor giving off that homely, old-​timey feel.
Had the James Brownie Funnky Jackhammer, and the consistency and combination of ingredients (peanut butter, brownies, and hot fudge) were perfect. There are so many choices that all looked amazing.
Love the fact that they have seasonal items, will be back again.

Andy’s frozen custard is never a disappointment. It’s delicious and soft with many choices to pick. It does melt quickly but it’s worth it. Worth going.

Good Lord, I had no idea how packed it would be on a Tuesday night at 10pm with an outside temperature of 65 degrees! I waited in the drive thru for a little while, honestly I’ve had longer wait times at McDonald’s. They have a similar ordering system to Portillo’s when it’s busy: a young lady took my order with an iPad and relayed it to the cashier, who handed me my creamy goodness and took my money all in one fell swoop. Definitely helped to move the crowd along.
I got my husband a peach Concrete (which he didn’t even eat, WHAT THE HELL) and I got a Triple Chocolate Concrete with caramel Jackhammer. I don’t suggest this if you’re on a diet or feel that your body is a temple. My only gripe is the custard melts too quickly, but honestly that’s more chemistry than anything. If there’s anything I learned, it’s not to argue with science or else Bill Nye and Neil DeGrasse Tyson will rip me a new black hole.

So I have coming here for a while, like 6 years or so. And I had everything on the menu. I love mint with extra mint topped with more mint. Okay I never order extra mint with my mint but I might be leading to something… It’s pretty cool they bottled cream soda in case you’re getting a split or something small like a single scoop cone.
Now if you order a cone or concrete you have literally have over 30 different toppings and syrups with Carmel and fudge cherries pretzels almonds and etc. I like the more clean eating with shakes or concrete or even maybe their famous Turtle split with hot fudge infested brownie at the bottom. So delicious.

Seriously, I am from Michigan. I try to come here once every couple of times I visit the area. I love this stupid place so much. Specifically, I love the chocolate custard with peanut butter topping.
Creamy, decadent, intense chocolate paired with luscious, warm peanut butter. I eat it as a sundae, I eat it as a concrete. I eat it anyway and I eat it anytime, my friend.
I want to eat it, now.

Andy’s is our «we only bought a few more things than we meant to at Ikea» treat. It’s not super far from us, but far enough away that there are a dozen or so other ice cream places near by. Of course, not custard. Andy’s frozen custard has the best custard in the area in my opinion. They have tons of different mix ins and flavors. I’m never disappointed. It also helps that they have a drive thru.