Suzi Cakes

Absolutely incredible! The cake Suzi designed for my daughter’s NYC-​themed Sweet 16 was AMAZING. It looked gorgeous and tasted even better! It was accompanied by red velvet & chocolate cupcakes! Everyone was happy!
PS — Suzi’s crumb cake is the best I’ve ever had!

I have been here before and had great results with a small cake I ordered so I decided to go back for cupcakes, they weren’t good at all. The icing taste like the fake stuff that ShopRite uses on their cakes. Very disappointing for 18.00.

Looooove the chocolate mousse cupcakes here! I don’t prefer the vanilla icing on the other cupcake flavors — a little too whipped-​creamy, I prefer sweeter — but I don’t even bother with those. I’m going straight for the chocolate mousse, every time!

Suzi Cakes is the best! For every special occasion at our home and at our church, St. John’s, Sue outdoes herself in flavor, design and service. She also made our wedding cake last year and it was so beautiful that I still look at it in the pictures!
Lovely family, outstanding service and the best in cakes!

Suzi saved my bacon this morning… I had a cake disaster in my own kitchen 3 hours before my sons birthday party. I went to see Suzi and she was able to put together a replacement cake for me that was AMAZING. (Lucky me!) Devil’s Food cake with chocolate mousse and white buttercream icing. I also picked up a small oreo cookie cake to make sure we had enough for all the hungry kids and it was also wonderful.
Definitely worth a visit and if you have better planning skills than I do, pre-​order. It’s what I’ll do next time ;-)

The cupcakes were rather dry. The fillings and frosting were ok but the cake itself was not so good. Although the service and variety of cupcakes were good, their cupcakes r overated I’m sorry to say. The cookie dough was very dissapointing.

I have yet to visit Suzi Cakes, but my mom ordered cupcakes from the shop for my baby shower this weekend. She ordered quite a large batch of cupcakes (around 60 I believe) in all different kinds. Everyone LOVED them! My mom said she was so happy with the service she received and was very pleased with the cupcakes. There were a few cupcakes leftover, and even after a day or two, the cupcakes still tasted completely fresh! Definitely recommend this place, especially if you’re hosting an event!

Thank you, thank you, thank you for the beautiful and delicious teapot cake you made for my bridal shower! My bridesmaids (and groom-​to-​be) knew I had been eyeing up your teapot cake ever since I saw a picture posted online about 2 years ago – before I was even engaged! – and I was so excited when I walked into my bridal shower yesterday and saw your teapot cake waiting for me, surrounded by accompanying mini cupcakes. The exterior design was enchanting, the the icing and cake inside were moist and flavorful. I’m so glad you’re also supplying the cupcakes for our wedding in May! Thanks again!

I ordered a small birthday cake, wedding cake (2^nd wedding) and baby shower cupcakes from her recently. She does an impeccable job. Cakes taste amazing! Every raved over her artistic elements on cake/​cupcakes. I’ll definitely be a repeat customer

I stopped in to inquire about a dinosaur cake for my son’s birthday. After discussing what I wanted we came up with a dinosaur cake. OMG. It was fantabulous! She worked within my budget. The cake was so moist and full of flavor! She had definitely won me over as a customer. I return for my daughter’s cake! Can’t wait!

I stopped in for the first time last week. I didn’t even know it was there. I’m glad I know now! I walked in off the street and there were 3 already made cakes in the case. I asked about each of them and the owner recommended the Brownie, peanut butter, chocolate cake. I felt my teeth hurt thinking of all the sugar but I needed a birthday cake that day. She decorated it while I waited and the price was reasonable. But OMG!!! That cake was awesome! It was not too sweet either. I went back the Tuesday after Memorial weekend to buy another one just because it was so good but they didn’t have one available. One of the ladies offered to make one for tomorrow but we wanted something sweet now so we bought four different cupcakes. They were amazing as well! My new favorite place. In case you can’t find it, it’s near Heavenly Temptations, which is also a great store.

Suzi Cakes has made 2 delicious cakes for our family, both of which were the hit of the party. Whether it was a Candy Crush cake or a Physician Assistant cake, every detail was so creative and intricate, we couldn’t be happier with the final product.

I can’t say enough about this place. Suzi Cakes made the most amazing baby shower cake for my best friend… Everyone at the party commented that it was the most beautiful cake they’d ever seen, and the best they’d ever tasted! Their custom specialty cakes really are top-​notch… Check them out!

So as i closed door after having just finished my second helping of Suzi Cakes’ lemon cake (i don’t know the exact complete technical name! :p) it dawns on me that i have never left a review of Suzi Cakes. I don’t even like any lemon anything pastries, but she makes this lemon cake thing that is my exception to the rule! Lemon desserts usually tend to have a abrasive lemon flavor, but this dessert completely dispels the lemon pastry myth. The mini cheesecakes here are delicious too. I’m easily a good 30 minutes from Suzi’s (in light traffic) and the drive is well worth it you want to satisfy your sweet tooth!!! ENJOY!!!

We used suzi cakes for our engagement party in october 2013. I had ordered 5 different fall flavored cupcakes. The owner had a list to choose from but mentioned that if you gave her any special requests that she was able to accomodate. Everyone at the party loved the cupcakes and even the food snob of the family said they were the best cupcakes he ever had! They looked adorable on display as well! Tons of guests asked where we ordered from… I would definitely return to suzi cakes for any small or big party.

I decided to surprise hubs with some sweets to congratulate him on his new job and Suzicakes was close by. I had purchased cupcakes from here once before and was ehh about them but decided to try again. A guy walked in ahead of me and was very chatty cathy with the staff, the woman behind the counter was super friendly, perhaps she was Suzi. Anyway I browsed all the delightful cupcakes available – see my photos. They had a pretty good selection for a hole in the wall bakery. I opted for the cookie dough, a vanilla cupcake stuffed with cookie dough, topped with buttercream (i think), covered in ganache and topped with a cookie dough ball, and a canolli filled, vanilla cake, buttercream, stuffed with canolli cream. Husband was really excited, and then must have forgotten that I got him these treats because now, almost 7 days later I finally said I’m having some of your dang cupcake.
I’m happy to say despite a lot of refrigerator funk from a weekend bbq the cupcakes didn’t pick up any weird flavors. I only tried the cookiedough but omg so good. The cupcake was moist and tender, the cookie dough was obviously delicious. I only ate half and that was plenty, it was pretty heavy but not in a gross diabeetus kind of way. He caught on and ate the rest of that cupcake plus the cannoli filled, he seemed quite happy.
SOOO I will def be back to Suzi Cakes. I’m happy to be able to give my money to a local bakery and support Main Street being awesome. The two cupcakes I got were $ 5 and change, not bad imo for 2 decent sized cupcakes. Go check out Suzi Cakes!

I was walking downtown with a friend looking for something sweet when we stumbled upon Suzi Cakes. The shop is cute with pink décor, but the cupcakes were only okay.
I had a French Toast cupcake. The flavors reminded me of French Toast (with cinnamon and syrup), but the icing tasted artificial like a cupcake you would buy at the grocery store. Also, the cake was very dense almost like a pound cake.
Overall, the cupcakes were nothing special but that shouldn’t stop you from going in and checking it out yourself!

Met the owner shortly before closing time. She was making her own marshmallows. Right away, that starts at a 5 star rating for me. Now, the bad news. I think that because this is a one-​woman, small-​volume bakery, things are baked early and that’s it. Getting there late in the day, the food just didn’t taste fresh. That said, everything is homemade with a LOT of love — it’s obvious from talking to her — and the flavors were good. So my preliminary rating is 5 stars if you stop by first thing in the morning, 2 – 3 stars if you stop by at the end of the day = 4 stars average.

I walked past this place at about 9pm a few weeks ago and it was just closing — to me, that is reason for 2 stars at least — a bakery open late, which is when you really want a sweet.
Last night I was in Boonton again, and checked in around 8:30 — a gentleman behind the counter was quite engaging, and talkative about the cakes and the chocolate, etc. I got two cupcakes and two different cheesecakes… I didn’t get to try the cupcakes so I can’t speak to them (my daughters devoured them) — the cheesecake is creamy and sublime!
Repeat — amazing cheesecake! The decorated cakes are astoundingly beautiful…
Only giving 4 stars as my tastings were limited, and I can’t advise on all products — I wish all small businesses well and encourage a stop by this lovely bakery in Boonton.

A cute little bakery that is easy to miss if you haven’t heard of it. I stopped in based on a recommendation from a friend, and discovered that Suzi Cakes provides a limited variety of cupcakes, cheesecakes, and cookies.
I had the Cannoli Cupcake, which was OK but not great. It might have been the result of the cold refrigeration, but the cupcake didn’t seem super fresh. Still, the flavors were OK and it was a nice little treat that you can’t find elsewhere in the area. I also saw a great decorated cake and was told that they can do customized cakes that are pre-​ordered.
Prices were decent with each cupcake ringing in at about $ 2.75… about a dollar less than a Crumbs Cupcake. I hope that business picks up so Suzi Cakes will start to provide a bigger variety of sugary goodness.