Pagliai’s Pizza

I generally get a Tuesday special which is a 10 topping large for $ 10 every week for pick up. They have messed up the roping many times and they never give the right time estimate. If the price wasn’t reasonable and the food wasn’t great I wouldn’t go back.

The pizza is a value. 10 bucks buffet and include the salad bar and soups. wish they would add more verity of greens and have blue chesse.
seen a child drop a slice of pizza on the floor and put it back up on the buffet trays. told the parent and they did nothing. gross. the staff jumped on it.

Favorite Pizza!
I have been going to Pagliais for the past 30 years and never had a bad pizza!

This is the best pizza around, all the meats are from local farmers. Fast service. The best breadsticks, buffet is pricey but worth it if you are hungry. I love this place.

A must visit when you’re in BG! Great food. Great staff! Pizza buffet is the way to go! You get your own pick and all the other flavors of BG! :)

My husband and I went here for dinner tonight, we will not be coming back. Our waitress needs to be trained with someone who knows what they are doing. My husband had to correct her on his order when she was taking it 3 times. Then when she came back to the table she still had it wrong so I had to correct her. She didn’t even ask what type of sauce we wanted or what kind of dressing I wanted for my salad.
As for the food, that was the worse imitation Italian I have ever had. My husband agrees. I ordered a sampler which has spaghetti, ravioli, and lasagna on it. When the plate came out you couldn’t even tell what was on the plate because everything was smothered in the same sauce to the point where it looked like it was soup. Once you started trying to figure out what everything was then you saw it really was soup, the bottom of the plate was just water with a hint of the color red. Everything on my plate tasted the same. Nothing had its own flavor. Very very bland and gross. My husband’s spaghetti was no different. The garlic bread actually made me laugh. No joke. I really don’t understand how this place stays in business. When we got back in our car I told my husband never ever ever again. Eat at your own risk!

We used to have weekly business meetings on Tuesday nights in BG. Our go to place was/​is Pagliai’s.
The pizza buffet is great and a value for the money. They include a soup and salad bar to go with it. The beef noodle is my favorite. If you don’t see what you like on the buffet, the crew will make it for you. When it is made, they bring it to your table immediately and offer you first dibs. We like the taco and philly steak pies the best. Sauerkraut pizza? Haven’t seen that but indefinably willing to give that a try. I asked about them making a a coney island hot dog (chili dog to you non-​Detroiters) but they didn’t have the ingredients. No big whoop.
Servers have always treated our big groups, with big appetites, very well. We tip as big as we eat.

Good pizza. Buffet it’s a little eclectic in terms of atmosphere, but the food is quality. They have really good homemade soups. This place is great for lunch. Aldo great for large groups or parties. Also everyone can get what they want since it’s a buffet. Always wanted to order if the menu, but the buffet’s allure always gets the best of me.

Worst delivery service in BG. Always cold and takes twice as long as anyone else. Too bad because the pizza is good

Great buffet (although a little pricey for a family). You are allowed to request a pizza when you order the buffet, so you can get what your picky eater might like. Fresh salad bar, breadsticks are back on the buffet now, and two homemade soups each day.

This is a great place for a fresh salad and a pizza buffet. I usually order a 1 trip to the salad bar with 2 pieces of pizza from the buffet. I think the price is like $ 7 about the cost of a happy meal but better ingredients.

I live in Vegas and am coming «home» next week. I have already requested that this is a must while I am back in Ohio. I can’t wait to have a sauerkraut pizza with extra sauce. I am salivating writing this review. Breadsticks with ranch dressing is a must too!

Even though it’s a longer drive to Bowling Green, I’ve always considered it worth the gas and time. We rarely eat from the pizza buffet, but purchase our own. Since we are creatures of habit, it’s always the pepperoni and sausage with the thin style crust.
For a thin crust, it’s a great slice. The dough tastes like it was made from scratch and is not too sweet. Some people prefer Myles to Pagliai’s, but I find them both wonderful in their own right. I’d eat at both establishments again anytime.

Not as good as Campus Pollyeyes. Especially since they took the breadsticks off the buffet

Pagliai’s is a good place to go if you’re looking for a cheap pizza buffet. You’re allowed to request one pizza for the buffet, so there’s sure to be something up there you like. They also have salad and breadsticks. The pizza itself isn’t too bad — not the best I’ve ever had, but given that you can eat as much as you want for cheap, I’d recommend it.