Neshanic Inn

my wife and I stopped here with our 2 year old son and another couple with their 3 year old son and we had a blast. The waitress Priscilla was great and very accomidating to all of our adult beverage needs and our toddler needs. we ordered some apps (pretzel bites and mozzarella sticks) that were homemade and honesty the best mozzarella sticks I have ever had hands down. the pretzel bites came with homemade BBQ sauce that I cannot wait to have on a sandwich next time I come back. the French onion soup (also homemade, apparently everything here is) was awesome. I ordered a sandwich that was a special that the name now slips my mind it was a pork roll, bacon, ham sandwich with siracia ketchup and ghost pepper cheese (caution spicy spicy hot!) cannot wait to come back and try some more of their menu

Stopped in for lunch but not being a local did not get much attention or good service as the bartender was attending to the regulars. I ordered a Cheeseburger (Medium Well) and Fries, and the fries were OK. The burger was well done on the outside and raw on the inside. I only had a few bites and pointed it out to the bartender. She said that was too bad and went back tot he other patrons. I asked about getting a different burger but only got the check handed to me.

Quiet and unassuming. You’ll drive past it if your first adventure over to the inn (no sign outside… thats okay because my husband and I thought may be a township code). It’s cute from the outside; reminds me of an old country feed store. The interior is very retro. It’s worn but cool and clean. Our wait staff was so nice and sweet. She wasn’t pushy at all. She’d check-​in with us from time to time but wasn’t annoying at all. This was our first time at the inn and our family enjoyed our dinner. We each had a burger that was fan-​tast-​ic!!! I had the Jersey burger that was so flavorful, juicy, tender, and cooked to perfection! The meat itself wasn’t overworked (which makes a burger tough); and was lightly shaped. A million times better then the burger joint with 25 choices. The burgers ranging in price from $ 8-​$ 10.

My husband and I enjoyed a fun supper here on a Thursday night. In particular, he liked the wide selection of ales, etc. on tap. Since I was driving, I had an ice tea, which tasted freshly brewed. I started dinner with a nice house salad of Romaine lettuce. Hubbie had the Cuban Poppers. These are ham and Swiss Cheese wrapped around a slice of pickle, breaded, and then fried. They were fun and tasty. He also liked his dinner which was the special BBQ Pulled Pork, Mac n Cheese, and steamed broccoli. I was treated to a delicious burger topped with Swiss cheese and mushrooms. I was impressed with the homemade French fries as they were perfectly cooked, piping hot, and not greasy. The waitress was wonderful and took very good care of us.

I have been a patron at this establishment for nearly 12 years. It was my first job and always my local watering hole. It is a nice dive bar but it has recently went downhill real fast. The building is in disrepair and the employees are new every week. Their famous Wing’s have recently gotten much smaller and the menu has been simplified. It’s still a great place to grab a quick beer on the way home but not an establishment for the family