Culver Lake Nursery & Farm Market

On our way home from hiking, we stopped by because we saw a huge sign PIES. The only pie they had left was strawberry rhubarb and boy was it YUM. Worth ever penny

What a find this one was!!! My favorite pie is apple, hand’s down, my husband’s is peach. For 4 summers, since my daughter has been going to sleep away camp in Honesdale, PA, we have been in search for a great, REAL country homemade pie. Last summer, we thought we found the perfect apple pie when we stopped by an Amish food stand. It was far from perfect. The dough was authentic, but the filling was made with that compote filling. That was a shocker and some disappointment, I’ll tell you that!
Well, fast forward to yesterday. Driving along Route 206 trying to find a place to eat (see Jumboland), I spotted the Culver Lake Nursery and Farm Market along the roadside and the word «Pie» stood right out. This market had everything you could possibly imagine: Perennials and Plants, Homemade Cider, Jams, Fresh Farm Vegetable and Fruit, PIES, and so much more. If we had more time AND I knew I would find it on Unilocal,I would have insisted on staying longer to look around and take more pictures.
There was a table displaying the most beautiful pies I have ever seen. Apple Crumb, Plain Apple, Blueberry, Mixed Berry and Cherry. I was speaking to the owner and she told me she gets all her homemade pies from a bakery that her Brother and Sister-​In-​Law own. My husband lifted the Apple Pie and he said it felt like it weighed 4 lbs! The aroma of fresh baked pie filled our car, we couldn’t wait to get home!
As soon as we cut into the pie, you could hear the crunch of the apples. The dough was the PERFECT consistency — how it held so many apples I have no idea! The pictures speak for itself, this was by far THE best apple pie I have ever had. I found the bakery on Unilocal (
) and called to compliment them and to find out exactly where they were located. The girl told me they put EIGHT cups of apples into every pie. Unfortunately, after my husband spoke to the owner to get directions, he realized this bakery would be too much out of our way coming home, so chances are we will not be going there. But, we have all intentions of stopping by the Culver Lake Nursery every chance we will get! Look for an update the weekend of August 4^th, we shall be returning then!
Note: The large pies (12″) are $ 13.99 and the mini’s (6″) are $ 5.99. Worth every penny!!!