Peppinos Pizza

So my guy and I just flew in from Texas and we had to get some New York style pizza! My cousin picked us up from the airport and he suggested this place I’m actually glad I didn’t read the reviews because this place is amazing! We ordered four different types of pizza which was pep and sausage, all white pizza, veggie and chicken! I tried everyone except the veggie (that one was for my cousin)! The crust and cheese on the pizza was amazing! It’s going to be so hard to go back to Texas and have Pizza Hut or cici’s on a broke budget day !

Not what it used to be. Used to be the best best pizza around.
The other day I asked for a well done pie, nice and crispy. It was given to me less than normally cooked

During the late 1980’s through the early 1990’s my friends and I would take a ride from upper Westchester down to the Bronx to have what we considered was not only the best Italian food around but good Italian food with reasonable prices as well as good service. Imagine my surprise when last week we stopped by Peppinos for the first time in many years and the experience was the complete opposite. It seems to me that they are under new ownership, which in itself is not they issue. The Stromboli was extremely greasy, the pizza crust was so doughy I had to ask if the slice had been cooked. The prices are not resonable, the service was filled with attitude, not a smile or thank you. I am extrememly disappointed and can’t fathom how they manage to stay open. Needless to say we will not be returning. At least we have great memories of how they used to be.

The pizza wasn’t that good. Thin crust shouldn’t be soggy. Tried two slices, won’t be a third.

BEST Pizza and Pasta !!! the prices are great and the service & staff are very friendly

Their pizza is nothing like it use to be in the 90’s, its not terrible. just another mediocre pizzeria. Ever since they changed management a few years ago Forget About IT!
Also please forget about tasting any of their dishes/​pasta/​Sandwiches! They use to be so good. Their White Clam Pasta I ordered from them was CLEARLY made with Pre-​made Progresso’s white clam sauce from a can! It tasted just like that mess.

Excellent pizza!

Peppino’s was the bomb… in the 90’s. Last time I was in there it seemed a bit shady.