Brothers Bagels

Best bagels in the neighborhood! I’m here for breakfast about twice per week. Fresh every day, crunchy on the outside, soft and chewy in the middle, and the garlic herb cream cheese is perfect. Very friendly staff.

The egg sandwiches and bagels are actually very good. But if you want to be in the breakfast sandwich businesses you’ve got to get it here in less than an hour and a half. It seems like these guys needed just one more brother to make this happen.

Just left — I think their boars head turkey is off it smelled bad in my sandwich and they overcharged for bacon in my sandwich which I did not have — should have walked to smith bagels. Will not be back.

Every now and then, I crave a blueberry bagel with butter… and years ago I discovered the deliciousness that is whitefish (on a regular bagel of course!). This is where I order delivery on the weekend — usually taking the blueberry bagel route, and ordering a container whitefish for later. SO GOOD.

I gave this place ²⁄₅ stars because they get my order right ²⁄₅ times. If you are ordering multiple things at once you need to watch them like a hawk to make sure they do it correctly. I go back because when they get it right it is good but this morning may have changed that. I ordered a simple poppy seed bagel toasted with scallion cream cheese and got an everything bagel, not toasted, with scallion cream cheese. If they can’t get a simple order right it’s not worth it anymore.

Idk. Maybe it’s me but I never like their sandwiches. I’ve tried the roast beef and it was just eh. Also tried a panini and I had to peel off the gunk that was mozzarella cheese on it. Their chicken noodle soup is ok. Overall I’m on the fence but leaning towards never going back again.

Great bagels … Best in the the neighborhood but never consistent with their sandwiches.
Couple of months ago my boyfriend ordered one of their signature sandwiches and he loved it … Recently he ordered it and it was horrible.
Sometimes they forget items on the sandwich … How do you forgot bacon on a bacon egg and cheese ?
Definitely needs work but bagels are filled with flavor.

Remember that Seinfeld when Kramer and Jerry drop a Junior Mint into a patient’s body as he’s being operated on? Well, the same thing happened with one of my bagels from this place – except it was a penny, not a mint. That’s right – I bit into a bagel today and there was a penny inside. Gross! Won’t go back there.

Ok, this is going to be MUCH different than my Smith St Bagels review!
Shorter…and sweeter!
Brothers Bagels are doing it right! I give them straight A’s–
A+…Food, drink, & Coffee
A+…Attitude
A+…Atmosphere
A+…Service
A+…Cleanliness
A+…Professionalism
A+…Speedy Service
After my horrific Groundhog Day experience (s) at the ‘other bagel place’, You can read that review here–
, I decided to give Brothers Bagels a try. The second time I went… one of the owners remembered my full order from my prior visit. And BOOM! I was out. I was impressed. And sold. I’m crazy busy. No time to dilly-​dally. I gotta get in… and get out.
PS– I own a gym and with the vast array of choices, I can go in there guilt free! I definitely recommend this place to my staff and clients. Confession… Their white-​chocolate-​macadamia-​cookies are Heaven sent (and have a Heavenly scent!). Hey, I said I’m a gym owner, I didn’t say I was a monk! Allow me a vice or two!

Delivery takes forever, WAY longer than the time quoted. Only worth it if you have a super long time to wait and you’re not starving.

Sadly… The negative reviews on here are 100% accurate. I ordered the Cajun chicken wrap and a salad with grilled chicken– what I got was a Cajun «mystery meat» wrap and salad with same «mystery meat»… When I tried biting into it I had to wash out the Cajun sauce cause I thought maybe it was so rubbery and chewy from being uncooked– but it appeared to be cooked– just completely inedible. No big deal, it happens right? So I call grub hub and let them know and tell them that I’m not gonna be eating it if BBs want to come pick it up that’s cool, I just want a refund. The guy refuses and says he doesn’t feel like sending someone back out and he’s not refunding it there’s nothing wrong with it. The woman at grub hub explain that that was very bizarre– usually as long as you’re willing to give them the food back, places have no issue giving the refund. Well not this place — it took 3 more calls to this rude guy to resolve the issue. Please don’t order from here– unless you want to get sick just look at the pic of the chicken I posted?!!

Have been going back recently — and much improved. Friendly staff and pleasant atmosphere

Easily the best bagels on this side of Brooklyn. Never stepped foot in the place but we order delivery from them multiple times a week. A nice variety of bagels and cream cheeses and even some lunch options. Recommendation: everything bagel with jalapeño cream cheese. Very nice delivery guy too.

Love this place! It is our go to for Saturday morning hangover breakfast.
First time we got the egg, bacon and cheese on a bagel. Eggs could use some salt, but other than that, it was a huge, yummy sandwich. Their iced chai is also super creamy and a great value for the cost.
This weekend we ordered the western omelet platters and substituted egg whites. These were super tasty! The bagel that came as a side was amazing; definitely the best I’ve had since moving to the neighborhood.
Only complaint is that they don’t give you the option of adding cheese to the omelet. I added it in as a request and they honored it. BUT, 24 hours later I received a price adjustment email saying they increased my total because of the cheese. They didn’t even call to ask if that was OK? What if I had been paying with cash??? I’m not a stickler about paying the extra couple bucks, but the fact that I wasn’t informed about it kind of made me a bit PO’d.

I ordered breakfast from this spot when my parents were in town and we were all really happy with what we got. I ordered the pancakes and they were so fluffy they almost tasted like cake. Really happy with that choice. My dad got a bagel and an omelette and the bagel came super fresh so he was really happy with his choice as well. The only comment I would make is be really specific when you are ordering online because the bagel came without being toasted. I know its a minor detail but thought it would be a helpful tip.

Best bagels in the neighborhood by far. Deducting a star as the cream cheese is not to my taste, but if you keep it simple you’ll be in for a treat. Great staff and fair prices. Look no further for a local bagel store

I got The Vermont wrap and the Supa Dupa green juice. They packed the wrap full so you really get your money’s worth. I’ll be back. This place is amazing.

Today was my first time here. Ordered an everything bagel with olive cream cheese and a large ice coffee 3sugars and milk.
— cream cheese was rich. Not cheap.
— Bagels was firm and not gooey.
–Coffee was fine.
I just have to make sure I be specific when I order next time. They put too much ice in my ice coffee. Ice was filled to the top. Also, I have to tell them not to put sugar, and use sugar liquid instead because sugar doesn’t dissolve in ice coffee. Other than that, keep it up yo!

Had the Chicken Thai wrap. Pretty filling wrap of white meat chicken, carrots, carmelized onions roasted pepper and avocado with a Ginger Soy dressing. Held together well which is sometimes an issue when I eat wraps. It was a good wrap, my coworker got the Philly Cheese Steak and was quite enchanted by it so I guess they will be added to our lunch delivery line up.

I’ll admit it: I’m lazier than most at the best of times. Throw in a hangover and a wind-​chill temperature in the single digits, there’s no chance you’re getting me out of my apartment before 10 am. But bacon cravings wait for no man.
Brothers Bagels will, after I push a few buttons on the magical device I keep at my bedside, deliver a bacon, egg and cheese on an everything bagel to my door. And they will do it quickly, and fairly cheaply.
These Brothers also stock many different types of excellent cream cheese (including the vegan tofu spreads) that they will schmear on their decent bagels for you, or deliver in increments of ¼ lbs. I would prefer more everything on the everything bagels, but otherwise my bagel experiences have been good.
What I cannot recommend, however, is their whitefish salad. I ordered some recently, and it was… off. Not rancid. If I was starving, I certainly would’ve eaten it before I would consider killing rats and/​or cannibalism. But it was unfresh enough that I threw it out, rather than risk anything.