Geppetto’s Pizza & Ribs

What happened top the days when pizza had a nice crunch to the crust??? I live close by (walking distance)… So I decided to get pizza and wings. Ill start with the good! The rings are awesome perfectly cooked and good sauces… I had the garlic Parmesan and barb q. The pizza I had to put back in the oven and cook some more, it was very doughy. Outside of that, it was good!!!

Not the best, nor the worst.
Ordered through BeyondMenu app after reading other reviews about how poor the website/​phone order has been.
Pizza is ok. Decades ago it was much better, or my memory was. Baked chicken is seasoned nicely. Ribs are just ok, being a bit on the tough side. BBQ sauce is quite good though. Prices are completely random. Some appetizers are in the $ 8 range, which is more expensive than their $ 5 medium pizza special.
Delivery time is atrocious, averaging over an hour at non-​peak hours.

wow… I do not understand how Geppetto’s is in Business… We Ordered a Hamburger medium rare with cheese and Mushrooms. the Burger was so bad that when i gave it to my Dog. he sniffed it and LITERALLY Unilocaled as she ran away. mind you, this dog feels cat turds are gourmet tootsie rolls… the Burger was so well done and they made sure to get ALL the juices out of it… seriously i feel it was harder to make such a tasteless burger then one with taste. it came with a side of pre cut frozen «fries»…you could taste the freezer burn… well, we also shared a small order of cheesy bread. well, it was ok. nothing special… there web site you can order from… plus a place to put your visa in. well, you STILL had to call as they could not process it… The Owner has a thick accent and gets frustrated when you ask him to repeat the order… The Delivery gal was very nice and on time promised … plus, they charge a 3 dollar delivery charge the driver does not get so you still must tip… I will never order from here again. the wonderful hamburger. the awesome fries… bread sticks
(sarcasm folks. lol) all together cost 18 bucks. way over priced… Frozen burgers from SPEEDWAY are Gourmet next to these folks…

Everything is awesome! From food to workers! If you haven’t tried this place then you’re missing out!!!

If it’s between little ceasars and geppettos, I would choose geppettos hands down. Their five dollar pizza is way better than little ceasars with only an extra ten minutes of wait. If your looking for a quick cheap pizza they are the best place to go in Brooklyn.

We ordered from this location twice, and will never order from them again. First time, food came as ordered, hot and in a shorter time frame than quoted. Today (May 4, 2015) I placed an order for a 10-​slice pizza with pepperoni, sausage, green peppers, and pineapple, as well as 15 boneless bar-​b-​que wings. I had to repeat my pizza order at least twice, correcting him several times (because he confused the size of the wing order with the size pizza order, did not get all four of the toppings as given to him) and I gave him my address of 4364 (four-​three-​six-​four). I was quoted 45 minutes for delivery. About 50 minutes later, the driver calls and says she is at 3364 because that is what her boss wrote down. Needless to say, the food arrived warm (not hot), and when I called to complain, I was put on the phone with the same call-​taker who wanted to argue with me about the address, stating he was give 3364. I said, «No, I spoke with you and I know I gave you 4364, because I had to make sure you got all four toppings on my pizza.» He replied, «Did you get all four toppings?» «Yes, but the food is not hot.» «But you got all four toppings?» By this time, I just said, «I will never order from you again.» I do NOT recommend this location, as they do not care about their customers. If you are going to hire someone to speak to the public, make sure they speak and understand English correctly.

The worst place to deal with. We ordered the special and they told us that it would be ready in a hour. Not true we didn’t get our pizza For almost 2 hrs! They proceeded to forget the ribs and I showed it to the driver and he said he would go get it! I get a call from the manager asking me if I got them as if I lied to the driver even thought the driver seen what he gave me as I didn’t leave his sight! He ended up bringing the ribs a hour and a half later and a phone call he got here told me not to worry about it and left. They ended up charging me after he said don’t worry about it. This place is the worst! I will never order from there and I will let anyone in my circle not too also.

Mediocre pizza. They refused to sell a side of anchovies. I won’t order from them again. The manager said that it was state law that would not allow them to sell anchovies unless they’re cooked onto the pizza.

The pizza really was not too enjoyable. Digiorno’s may be better on some occassions. However, they have a special that they run all the time for $ 3.99 for a one topping medium! This is recession food! I brought a couple pizzas for my friends on Friday night and was the hero of the day.

This place not only gave me a dry, burnt pizza, but then they lied to me and put me through hell in order to get my money back.
What a joke. I pick up a pizza, get home and tried to eat even though the crust on the top was burnt, thinking it’s only the top of the crust, so no big deal; well the pizza was burnt on the bottom as well, and the cheese was all dried up. So I call the business and ask to speak to the owner, well the guy on the phone tells me SHE is busy so I’ll have to wait. After sitting on hold for a few minutes I hand up and call back, thinking they were busy. I get a woman on the phone and when I ask to speak to the owner, she informs me that she is the owner; so I go into what happened with my pizza and that I would like a new pizza delivered to me or my money back, at which points she asks me to hold, which I do for another couple of minutes until yet another woman gets on the phone and tells me shes the owner and asks me if I could help her. I’m a little upset now since the last lady lied to me and tell the owner about whom simply blows it off as well that was my daughter, so how can I help you. Well I tell her I don’t know if she can since the last two people I’ve talked to haven’t been much help and one even lied to me, again, she wants to get me off the phone and tells me if I’m not happy with the pizza to come back up to the store and get my money back.
Then when I show up to the store some guy acting as the manager looks at my pizza and tells me there’s nothing wrong with it and that I can’t have my money back. At this point I feel like getting into an argument with them but really aren’t in the mood, so I ask to speak with the owner, and when she comes over to me, she looks at the pizza and tells me she’ll give me my money back, but there was nothing wrong with it.
So, my conclusion to this is that Geppetto’s idea of a pizza is one that is dried out, and burnt both around the upper crust and the bottom of the pizza; so if you’re looking for dried up burnt pizza, I would suggestion you go to Geppetto’s at this location, AND if you’re looking for attitude from the owner as well as everyone else who works there, this definitely is the place for you to go. AND of yea, if you want someone to lie to you about being the owner, and it’s acceptable behavior on the actual owners behalf, then go here as well.