Sarah’s Sweets and Cafe

I can’t say enough good things about Sarah’s sweets & café. Originally went in off of my sisters recommendation, didn’t really know what to expect. I was very pleasantly surprised! The customer service was amazing, I felt like I knew everyone behind the counter. The prices are very reasonable, and the food– incredible. My sister and I got the chicken salad sandwich on homemade pretzel Amish bread and my daughter got the homemade Amish chicken and noodles. So good! I was so impressed with the café side of the business I ordered my daughters first birthday cake from Sarah to give the sweets a try. Not only was it delicious, but it was beautifully decorated, and (again) reasonably priced. Such a great gem for Brownsburg to have, among all the chain restaurants it’s nice to have a unique experience. Best of luck to you Sarah!

In the short time I have been coming to this location, I have already become a regular.
Sarah makes such delicious cookies that I keep a standing custom order to take for work. She obviously takes a lot of care and pride in what she does, and her cookies are delicious.
I’m happy to patronize a local shop and the quality is outstanding. Added bonus for accepting credit cards which not a lot of bakeries do.