Orange Leaf Frozen Yogurt

The orange leaf in Brownsburg is definitely one to be remembered! The experience is a pleasant one, with a fun atmosphere and excellent frozen yogurt. There are many different toppings to choose from and the staff keeps things clean and tidy all the time! There is always a staff member dedicated to allowing you to test the flavors before you serve, it’s great. The staff is extremely friendly and willing to help. Also fond of the Green incentives going on there too! Great place to take your family, any day of the week.

Sooo bad here today! A few half empty dirty containers of sauces, hot fudge machine out of order, no cheesecake pieces or really good toppings … very disappointing!

Orange Leaf offers FroYo and big orange couches. It’s a good place to take the fam for a special occasion and a tasty treat. Don’t change, Orange Leaf. It has been clean every time I’ve visited and they always have several different varieties to choose from and then you get up to that fixins bar and go crazy like a fat third grader with a twenty dollar bill and no friends.

Normally I love this place but I think it was sold to new owners.
We went last weekend and the toppings were not good. The fruit was old and looks like they had been sat out over and over again. We are usually big fans but very sad this time. We will try it again for sure.

Enjoyed our yogurt with the make your own concept. A big variety of toppings and frozen yogurt to choose from. If you didn’t like the experience, you have to blame yourself. You make your own here.

Very disappointing to say the least. I go to these frozen yogurt places a lot, but this one was was terrible compared to other branded franchises like red mange, pinkberry, etc. The vanilla and other yogurt flavors tasted like watered down sherbet, they are not using any fresh ingredients, and no ‘greek healthy’ version of these flavors. Besides a terrible product, one staff person hounded me to sample different flavors and the check out person wasn’t the friendlies. They also charge 45 cents per ounce — BUT that inlucdes the cup, which is an ounce itself, so you’re paying for the plastic cup to boot on top of what I find is a fake version of frozen yogurt.

We’ve tried it twice now. A great concept which has been discussed by the other reviewers. You choose the flavors and topping (currently 14 types in this location, i believe. They offered free sample and made recommendations. Of note is almost ALL of flavors are GLUTEN FREE. Also there are only 1 or 2 flavors that may contain peanut or nut ingredients (check their website). So if you, friends or offspring have food allergy problems this is a place to check out. The flavors are great. The help is friendly and informed. They are a bit pricey but also offer coupon discounts on line (coupons4indy). So what is not to like.

Amazing! Fresh, fun, and so YUMMY!
I stopped in when I was visiting my sister during the holidays. They have so many flavors to choose from, offer a variety of toppings, have seasonal flavors that change, and offer a loyalty card that gives you free treats. one of the best thing about this place is, you pay by the ounce, so you don’t worry that you order a large and get less than a large depending on who is dishing it out! YOU dish it out and make your own mixes just the way you want them. A word of caution: You might be heavy handed and wind up with an expensive dessert if you fill your tub with FroYo or toppings. Once you get the knack of how much a serving costs, you’ll be able to adjust for your budget AND your appetite.
Oh, and they are a very GREEN company. The adorable little orange spades you can use instead of a plastic spoon are biodegradable and landfill friendly.

OK, for starters, I’m not a big frozen yogurt fan — that is, until now. Stopped into this little place over Christmas this past year, just to see what it was all about, and left with a serious attitude adjustment about frozen yogurt. This place is great, and I want more!
Pros:
1) You get to make your own! Grab a cup/​bowl, walk up to one (or two or three or…) of the dispensers and yank down that lever. Uncork as many different flavors as you like into your bowl (let go of the inner child in you & have at it). Then walk over to the goodies bar and sprinkle on (or heap on, it’s up to you) all the toppings your tastebuds can bathe in. Then go over to the cash register and have your newly created monstrosity weighed & paid for, then begin chowing down with those cute little orange spoony-​paddle things you get to eat with. It’s as simple and fun as that.
2) Clean place.
3) Retro 60s, 70s-​ish décor works for me.
4) Simple, straightforward process for creating your own personal yogurt dreaminess.
5) Did I mention that you get to make your own?
Cons: None.
As of 2012 the whole frozen yogurt idea has been around a good long time. What sets Orange Leaf apart for me is the ability to make your own (have I mentioned that already?) — not some leprechaun behind a counter snorkeling in a few little daubs of frozen milk biproduct in a similarly tiny recepticle. No, not here. At Orange Leaf it’s all up to you. Go big or small, monochromatic or Joseph’s technicolor coat, your only limit is your own mind. Go big — brain freezes are good from time to time, all the better when you’re crunching through 8 different toppings to boot.
Unfortunately for me, there are none of these places in Washington, DC yet. But I’m watching & waiting for when they arrive. When they do, I’m thinking they may put a good many other frozen yogurt places out of business. Either way, I’ll be a return customer.