Blasdell Pizza & Subs

Some of the most average unflavorful pizza in the area. Live within a mile so I’ve had about 10 times. Never great, never terrible. Just average.

Worst experience ever… called for delivery was told to call Hamburg location even though they are further from me… called Hamburg told me they don’t deliver here, so I called Blasdell again, took my order, delivery driver literally called from my parking lot and she told me to call Hamburg next time??? Saw her in my parking lot… told her to go back and I would call someone else… love their pizza but will NEVER give them my business again

This location food is horrible. BBQ wings not charbroiled & they lie about it. I asked if they were like other location in Hamburg where I had best BBQ wings ever. They lied and said yes. BBQ sauce not the same either. All wings overdone. I think they were recooked too. Pizza’s pepperoni small, and tasteless, cheese taste like old socks smell, crust is like worst grocery store freezer aisle pizza.

Best pizza ever ! I don’t like the Southwestern location… but this one is awesome !!! Pizza subs are the absolute best. French fries are great. Pizza is fantastic– lots of places skimp on sauce and cheese — but not here !!(see pictures). Chicken fingers are HUGE. They usually have 3 – 4 different types of pizza by the slice — like chicken finger pizza, steak pizza, and hot pepper pizza. Love this place. Plus, they have a self serve soda machine and self seating so no tips. Cheap and great food.

Average pizza and decent wings. The delivery always seems to be quoted at 30 – 45 but doesn’t get there until at least an hour after I call. The last time I ordered the delivery guy had his girlfriend in the car and it took an hour and 15 minutes when I was quoted 45 minutes. The food isn’t nearly good enough to wait for that long. Probably never order from there again.

First time at this location and I really like the southwestern location so I decided to give it a try. First impression was out dated. The dining room looks outdated and the floor was dirty with crumbs. After seeing a few of the menu screens not turned on I picked up a menu. Got a steak hoagie and that was very good! Also the menu said they had wheat wraps but we found out from employee that was not the case. The bill was rather cheap compared to other places in the neighborhood. After taking a seat it was quick to realize the heat was either off or not working. It was freezing! Food came quickly and was hot and fresh, thankfully. That was an easy way to warm up. Sub and wrap came with fries so that was a plus and tasted good and came just how I ordered it. Would order again but next time I think I’ll save the time and get it to go. Maybe they will turn the heat on and clean up the dining room next time!

Food was good, other than one food-​related issue we had. The bigger problem was that the manager (at least we think he was the manager) was horribly rude; he even went so far as to threaten my wife that if we left a bad review it would «create legal issues» for her. So, guess I’m taking a huge risk by leaving this review…
The food-​related issue we had was that the mild wings we ordered came with essentially no sauce on them. When my wife called to ask if they forgot the sauce (this was a pick-​up order), the manager guy told her that the wings had come exactly as the store had intended them. Now, that would have been just fine had that been all he said (we understand that every wing place does things differently), but instead, he chose to lecture her in a condescending fashion about how she doesn’t know how buffalo wings are supposed to be made, blah, blah, blah.
Anyway, like I said, the food was good and if it were just the food I was reviewing, I’d have given this place more stars. But, there are a lot of great places in the city to get wings, and as far as I’m concerned, I don’t need to go someplace that doesn’t appreciate our business.

One of the top pizzerias in the Buffalo region. I’ve been going here since I was in high school even though I don’t live in Blasdell anymore. I often go out of my way to get a pizza here.
You can eat this pizza all the way to the crust. Don’t you hate those pizzas where the cheese stops 2 inches before the end of the crust? None of that here! The dough is not too thick, not too thin. Perfect amount of cheese. Sauce is zesty, not sweet. I am not a fan of the sweet sauce trend. Tastes like spaghetti sauce. Again, not a problem here.
And they are consistent. The pizza will always be as good as the last one. If you are in the Southtowns, you must get this pizza.

Came here on a recommendation from a local I met on the flight here. Had previously tried Duffs famous wings and I hated it, feel free to read about them in one of my other reviews. We ordered a simple order of BBQ wings and terriyaki wings. The wings in general were decent and better than most places. It is still somewhat dry for me. I am a firm believer than wings should stand alone without the sauce and these passed for good but not great.
The terriyaki wings were drenched in sauce. Way too much for me especially considering how their sauce has a large sugar base and it was more like eating sugar. Wings themselves were a bit drier than their BBQ counterparts. I have had much better wings at university cafeteria.
At this point I would give them 3 stars.
Their blue cheese sauce is their saving grace. Best blue cheese I had. I don’t remember ever having a better one. Words can’t describe it. It went so well with their wings that it made up for a lot of the downsides of what they were lacking.
I would come here again. Something I can’t say for Duffs.

Very good hot subs. especially the Steak and Chicken breast. Also try their wings!.. very meaty and always cooked to perfection!

Whenever I’m in the Hamburg area, I ALWAYS make a couple stops to Blasdell Pizza. Some of the best pizza and wings in Western New York.

Best Buffalo Wings in Blasdell/​Hamburg. Extra Crispy is the way to go, and best Blue Cheese ever.
minus 1 star for the girl eyeing up my Ken Doll — keep your filthy eyes to yourself hickgirl!

Great sandwiches and wings. I especially like the teriyaki wings. They have a big selection of sandwiches including a chicken finger sandwich that I found really tasty.
I haven’t tried their pizza but since that is in the name I would assume it is good. The dining area is split into two sides on either side if the counter and both sides have TVs and soda dispensers.
I did find it interesting that on one trip they had a Jim Kelly jersey in the wall and then more recently that was replaced by a TO jersey. Really?!?

Oh man. Hot sauce drenched chicken finger sub with lettuce blue cheese and olives. Try it and you’ll never go back.
I do hate that I always have to explain to the 15 year old behind the counter that no, I only want blue cheese. No other kinds of cheese. What does she think I am? A pig?
«As a matter of fact I will take the foot long…»

My hometown pizza place. I have been eating this pizza since I was old enough to eat pizza. When I lived there, I had their phone number memorized. The pizza is always good and the Chicken Finger Subs are my reason for living.
This is always our first stop straight from the airport when we go home, and out last stop before the airport on our way out.