Cake Crazy Bakery

Good location and easy to find. Bakery is always running specials. Went on $ 1 cookie day. They were perfect. Everything is case looked amazing. Prices were excellent. We will be going back. Feel like it maybe my new job to try every delicious looking thing in the cases. Glad to have a new bakery to go to.

Had her cupcakes at a couple food festivals in Buffalo and they were AMAZING. Usually, I’m indifferent about cupcakes. I could honestly never have a cupcake again in my life and be OK with that… except that I truly love hers. The one that stood out a lot in my mind is the pink lemonade cupcake. Wow!!! All the flavors we had were amazing, but that one is my favorite.
Appearance is cute, not too airy, and taste of both frosting and cupcake (what should truly matter n all food and lately is lost by most bakeries) is the best, easily. No competition. Nothing is too sugary, and for once I didn’t wipe off gobs of frosting from it because it’s too sweet. Yum!!!

Delicious! The best cupcakes ever. Red Velvet, Chocolate & Strawberry crunch. We all tried each others and it was hard to pick a favorite! We will be back!

Needed a same day special cupcake order for a baby gender reveal. They went out of their way to accommodate and the best part is the cupcakes were fantastic. Moist rich and tasty.
I called four other bakeries first and was actually laughed at for asking for a custom order with less than a week of lead time. I knew it was a tough request and was perfectly fine with hearing NO, but I didn’t appreciate the attitude. This bakery was polite and had my order ready in a few hours.

Went to this place a few times & have only purchased their cookies. I heart the PB’s. They get you where they need 2 be ;). Can’t wait to try one of their specialty cupcakes/​cakes next.

I visited this bakery today with my father after recently hearing about it… and the whole experience was fantastic. When we arrived Shetice, the owner, was already closed down for the day. However, she seen us outside the window and happily let us in despite being closed. She welcomed us and told us about the bakery menu items and what they consist of. I could really tell that she is a sweet person and enjoys what she does! We tried a slice of the Strawberry Crunch Cake and a few different cupcakes. Not only did everything look delicious, but everything TASTED delicious! Needless to say, I’ll be back to visit Cake Crazy in the near future.

This review is for customer service and not actual product.
I reached out to get a quote for customized cake order and was met with one word or one short sentence responses via email. Even though the price was higher than other bakery’s quote, and because of good reviews — I still decided to move forward with the order and called in to make a deposit payment. I was met with answering message after multiple calls and left a voicemail regarding my attempt to make a deposit.
I did not hear back and decided to pursue another bakery in town with better customer service.

What a great place! Friendly owner who makes everything from scratch and it shows. Highlight was the chocolate chip cupcake and got lucky and stopped in on Gumbo day — she worked for Emeril Lagasse in New Orleans. The gumbo was fantastic.
Not far from the Galleria Mall and worth the trip. She caters as well! I will be back

Such a gem in our little neighborhood. Cake Crazy has cupcakes to die for! The prices are good and they do amazing specialty cakes to order. The service is wonderful and helpful. The owner is truly talented and it’s a great place to stop and grab some sugary goodness!

This bakery is amazing, and is definitely worth a try! The prices are extremely low, especially since everything is homemade. Their pies are to die for. Especially the sweet potato pie. Their cupcakes are tasty. My favorite is the red velvet. This place is definitely addicting.

Love this little bakery! They have homemade soup too! It’s a must try you won’t be disappointed!

I felt so welcomed when I walked into the bakery! It’s a very cute little place and there are adorable cakes in the window. The girl (possibly the owner?) came right up to me and made sure she asked if it was my first time in and then personally thanked me for stopping in and welcomed me to the bakery. From start to finish was the best experience I’ve had with customer service in a place like this.
I mentioned I had a Groupon I purchased to try them out, and she treated me like every other customer and gave me A++ service. She took the time to explain each cupcake to me when I was trying to make decisions. Unlike other cupcake Groupon offers, she let me choose any flavors I wanted to try instead of giving me a premade box of flavors I don’t like (which has happened at a few other cupcakeries I’ve gone to with a Groupon).
I’m not a sweets fan for the most part, unless it’s cupcakes. I have tried out several cupcakes throughout Buffalo and even across the states. Cake Crazy has to be one of the top around the area. (You should try out for Cupcake Wars! … Big fan of my Food Network shows lol)
All the cupcakes were moist and delicious, the buttercream was perfect, and everything about them was just the right amount of sweetness.
I tried a variety of flavors and stuck to some of the traditional as well. My favorite by far was the chocolate chip cookie dough cupcake. I could eat those all day! And possibly get a dozen of just that flavor itself … (Wouldn’t even make it to the car)
I look forward to trying more of the cupcakes and other products offered here in the near future!

I’ve worked for the owner Shetice but I’ve also been a customer which is why I’ll still submit a review. Shetice is a chef turned baker who basically can’t fail in a kitchen. The creations her and assistant Sabrea make are nothing short of amazing. It’s one thing to make something that looks good but when the taste is just as good you feel as though you hit the lotto lol.
I’ve probably tried everything the sell by now and have never been disappointed. In the winter various types of soup are also sold. (The chicken noodle is a must try!)
Stop in and give the place a try. You will not be disappointed.
Note: Gourmet Catering is also available

Service was A+, and the cake and cupcakes that we ordered could not have been more perfect. The cake was a chocolate peanut butter one and the balance of sweetness was spot on. I was a little hesitant when I looked at it as it could have easily been nothing but a sugar bomb but as I tasted the first bite I was do impressed with the balance. Rich, soft, chocolate cake dancing beautifully with soft, creamy peanut buttery loveliness and then that soft hint of chocolate ganache. Perfection. The decorations on the cupcakes were individually made and each and everyone was formed perfectly. Even the shop is lovely. Do not hesitate to have confidence in this place. We chose it with zero knowledge of how it would be and I’m so glad we did !

Bakeries and Diners. 2 of my favorite things. And 2 things I travel for.
This review is for a bakery. On William Street in Cheektowaga, which is far from my usual path. But I saw a Groupon. And I bought that Groupon. And here I came.
Open since Oct 2014 the storefront is in a house/​apartment space. It’s a small storefront but each item in the display case looks very inviting. We picked up a sweet potato pie, cupcake, piece of cake and a lemon bar.
The lemon bar has a touch of almond I think and it’s spectacular. A touch of something anyway. Those will be in high demand here.
The cupcake was also very good. Her flavors are typical of what you see in other bakeries in town. So you may have an expectation. I encourage you to ignore those expectations and taste it as if it’s the first time. I think you will like it. We did.
The sweet potato pie we warmed up. I gather usually people use a microwave for that, but being a household without a microwave (I know, but you don’t miss what you never got used to), the toaster oven worked fine. Lower heat for 10 min should do it. We liked this pie. First time I had had one but others in the house who have been exposed to more than I, really liked it.
The cake was a little dry and I probably would not pick that up again. But the frosting (not a huge amount) was very tasty.
This a real sole proprietor. She knows how to bake. Worth a visit to the area. I think you will be pleased.
Street parking.