Daddio’s Pizza

BEST PIZZA IN BUFFALO!!! It has a wonderful sweet sauce with Buffalo thick crust. The cheese tastes real and not processed. The pepperoni and sausage are both the right amount of kick. They also threw in free soda and ranch dipping saucea when we brought a family member from out of town in to try their pizza. It truly is the best pizza in Buffalo.

This was the most terrible experience. I called because my order never came and re-​gave them my information again. The lady on the phone was very disrespectful, she called my bf a dick and then said we wasted her time. She then told me «get your skinny ass downstairs and wait for the driver, nigga». Instead of speaking calmly she asked why I gave the wrong number when I repeated my number many times. She repeated a number that was no where near my number. The fault was all her’s, she mixed up the numbers and instead of apologizing, she attacked us with her words.

Ordered a medium taco pizza came to $ 22 somehow it was loaded but unfortunately I forgot to ask for no olives so my fault spent more time removing them than eating the pizza that I think would have been delicious if no olives

Sad lately because I have had two incidence in the last few months. I am not sure if they are short staffed or the owners are working long hours. In February I ordered a meatball sub. Sub roll was black. Burnt to a crisp. Recently I placed a order and told 30 minutes. When I went to pick it up, they forgot to make it. And given a slice of pizza from the warmer. Unfortunately it was burned underneath. I hope they improve. They have good food.

I recently tried their veggie pizza and I have to say it was out of this world! I could taste the freshness of all the veggies. So delicious. My son’s favorite is the grilled cheese pizza. I think he would eat there every night if he could. The owner Jim is so nice. Very welcoming environment. Highly recommend everyone try their pizza!

Used to be a big supporter of this business. Previously had a 5 star review because the food was great and the owner seemed very appreciative of his customers. Unfortunately tonight my delivery order was over 45 minutes late. I gave them the benefit of the doubt because i have eaten there so many times. Called once to check on my order after it was 20 minutes late and they told me it would be there soon. After another 20 minutes i called again and asked them to cancel the order. They told me to answer the drivers phone call when he arrived and hung up. I called back immediately and they told me i was being unreasonable and hung up on me again. Finally when the driver called me i answered and he wasn’t on my street so i told him not to bother bringing the food since it was so late and the people were so rude on the phone. Sadly will never order food from here again. The owner seemed like a nice guy but unfortunately his staff ruined it for him.

If I could leave 0 stars I would. Ordered my food at 1030, was told it would be 40 min wait for delivery. I wait an hour and a half, still no food or phone call telling me my order would be longer than anticipated. When I finally get someone on the line at 1155 they tell me my order is out for delivery. I wait for another 30 minutes. I live 10 minutes down the road. It’s 1220 now. I call again and am put on hold. I’m on hold for 10 minutes. I use my friends phone to call from another line and get an answer immediately. They forgot I was on hold. When I speak to this new guy he tells me it is out for delivery and that the first guy I spoke to lied to me and it was not out for delivery when I called at 1150 and I’m on the phone for 10 minutes with him and it is still not here. I ask for anything a refund a discount anything. He refunds my order and has the delivery person not bring me my food. So after two and a half hours at 1 in the morning I am tired hungry and without pizza. Literally the worst food and customer service experience. In summation I was mislead lied to forgotten about and my order after 2 hrs and 40 min was never delivered.
*** update: I was never actually refunded my order. I looked on my bank statement and was still charged 33+ dollars for a service I never received. And when I called to address this issue. The woman on the phone who claimed to be management but never gave me a name, gave me an attitude. Told me someone would call me back. Which no one ever did, and slammed the phone on me.
I feel so helpless. Like there is nothing I can do. I was robbed and treated like scum. This is the worst company I have ever encountered. Definitely not the end of this issue.
*****update: when I did go in and asked to speak with the owner or manager no one was there so an employee told me he would «sit in as manager» so I began to tell him my issue. He told me to write down my information and he will pass it on. He then takes it upon himself to tell me what is wrong with people my age. I explained to him it Has nothing to do with me and everything to do with how this issue has been handled. This turns into a huge screaming match with 3 employees at one point yelling in my face telling me I am a rude a snarky and don’t have as much money as them. At one point a pizza flipper was screaming at me and cursing and threatening to have me arrested. It was humiliating. Not once did I raise my voice insult their character or attack them as people and I was not given the same respect. It was humiliating. A couple hours later a manager calls me apologizing up and down and says I can come down and pick up my money. He then calls me an hour later and says someone will deliver it. When I asked the driver why he told me they did not want me coming in because they all knew how bad of a situation they were in. Honestly if you are reading this and got this far please do not give this company and business. There are a million other pizza places in the area. Bob and johns is wonderful and I have always had great service partners pizzas hell even dominos. These people are terrible and have no business working with the public

Wasn’t a fan of the pizza or the wings. Not my style of pizza.

Had been craving breakfast pizza for about a week, and now I feel Daddios has ruined me. I don’t think ill be able to order it from anywhere else. I got it mine with steak, sweet peppers and mushrooms. The man I placed the order with was extremely friendly over the phone, and threw in a complimentary 2 liter because he didn’t recognize my phone number. Delivery took slightly longer than what I was told, but it was well worth the wait. One slice filled me up, I will definitely order again soon.

If you love Buffalo style pizza, extra sweet sauce, insanely sized and generously topped pizzas Daddio’s is the place for you. Honestly I find Daddio’s sauce a little too sweet for my taste, but I can’t give them anything but 5 stars for their service, quality and quantity. Their pizzas and calzones are huge, they apply toppings almost to excess, and the owner is a really great guy.
I live nearby and I’ve had the owner deliver my pizza to me himself several times, usually with a complimentary 2 liter and a refusal to accept a tip. You always have a good experience with Daddio’s.
If you don’t like Buffalo style pizza or sweet sauce, you might want to stay away, but otherwise a very good choice on Hertel for a local pizza.

I moved to Buffalo almost a year ago and had not been able to find good pizza that delivers to Allentown… until now. I got the Sicilian with red sauce and sesame-​garlic crust. Their red sauce was flavorful and on the sweeter side, which I like, and Parmesan was sprinkled atop an already generous and delicious amount of cheese and toppings. The complex flavors (especially given the sesame-​garlic contribution) made for a more sophisticated pizza than typical delivery. A+ for food quality! As far as the service, they were very friendly and personable on the phone and in person upon delivery. They did take a half hour longer than the 45 minute projection, but they compensated me for the wait without my even remarking about it with a free 2L and mozzarella sticks. So relieved to have a pizza place I can call (from) home, finally!

Cheese is the best part. Not the classic New York style pizza crust, a bit doughy and thick. The sauce is sweeter than traditional Italian sauce. Delivery took an hour and 15 minutes at 10:30pm.

I just picked up a pie this evening and am eating it as I type this. I called with my carry out order for a medium pepperoni (cheese and pepperoni if Buffalonian). They told me it would be ready in 45 minutes I arrived almost exactly 45 min. later. They told me that it would be about 5 more minutes on my pie, so they offered me a free slice while I waited, which I accepted. While I was waiting, they came out to let me know that my pie was almost ready. About a minute later, the guy came back and asked me if I wanted it cut into slices or squares. That caught me off guard because I have never been offered a choice before. It was always one or the other. I was impressed. I chose slices. Shortly after they brought my pie out and informed me that they charged me for a medium, but upgraded me to a large for no additional charge! The customer service they displayed was really impressive.
As far as the pizza, the dough was not my favorite, but it was still pretty good. The pepperoni was typical for pizzerias in the Buffalo area. The cheese was delicious and seemed very fresh. The sauce was delicious, tasted like they used quality ingredients, had a little bit of spice and a little bit of sweet, but not too much of either, and they used a good amount of sauce (I like extra sauce), but not so much that it was drenched.
Overall the pizza was very tasty! I regret not having tried this place sooner because I would most certainly would go back if I weren’t moving out of the area in a few weeks, and I might actually try and hit this place one more time before I go!

Do fresh toppings, homemade dough, homemade sauce, whole milk Galbani moz cheese sound appealing to you?! If so you need to order some pizza from my favorite spot Daddios Pizza located on Hertel Ave., Buffalo.
I know many Buffalonians like to dip their pizza in a little blue cheese at times, well Daddios makes their own homemade Blue cheese. Trust me I call this «crack» and it’s the best freshest blue cheese I’ve ever tasted! I’ve told the owner many times to sell it in the stores in a container because it’s that good!
I can’t stand canned or frozen toppings for pizza. eckkk! Who likes a canned mushroom?! Not me! Daddios uses not only fresh NOT frozen or canned toppings they load up your pizza with them. So you can have your veggies right on your pizza instead of eating a side salad :0)
The sauce is homemade and has the right amount of sweetness to it. The dough is also homemade and it’s not too thick nor too thin! When we ordered pizza last night we asked for their garlic sesame crust. Out of this world!
Daddios also offers specialty pizzas like: delicious breakfast pizza, buffalo chicken pizza, hot diggity dog pizza, etc. You can also order wings, huge chicken fingers «bear claws», subs, and list goes on!
Daddios website is:
Phone # 716−877−7747
Located on 1247 Hertel Ave., Buffalo NY
Open everyday until at least 2am!
Specials: «Daddios Deal» Large cheese and pep pizza + 20 wings $ 29.49
Large Pizza cheese + one topping $ 16.99
This is higher/​better quality pizza remember not cheap junk
The owner Jim is the friendliest guy and he will treat you like family! Daddios is my «go to» for that pizza craving and I hope you enjoy as well. I’m looking forward to my pizza I have left over for lunch… Mmmmm ;0)

Every time we come here we are greeted with impeccable service. Last night the owner gave me a slice of taco pizza to try along with my order of pizza and wings and a free two liter. He also asked if I was parked nearby and if I needed someone to help me bring the food out to my car. That kind of customer service is so important and is the reason why Daddio’s is our go to pizza place!

Yum… I asked a few people in the North Buffalo region where to get the best pizza, more often than not Daddios was mentioned. I went with the recommendation and ordered a white pizza and on my return (because my first experience was so good) I ordered a spinach and ricotta pizza. Now when I say good I normally judge my pizza on a few criteria; sauce, crust, toppings, and the amount for your buck. The sauce was delicious. It has a sweetness to it but you can tell it’s made fresh with good ingredients. The crust was exactly how I like it, not too doughy and cooked so that it’s slightly crispy. The toppings, like the sauce were fresh and abundant. Now I ordered a large and a medium pizza, both reasonably priced and lots of leftovers! Now this is with 2 – 3 hungry people eating and enjoying.
Tip: Get a side of their blue cheese. It’s the best I’ve ever tasted. I want to know what brand they use or if they add anything. It’s the

My new favorite place in Buffalo to get pizza. The sauce is slightly sweet and the cheese to bread ratio is perfect. I ordered a medium cheese & pep for pickup and the time given was accurate. The owner was super friendly and didn’t charge us for our pops. We ended up dining in because we were hungry and the za smelt
so darn good. Excellent pizza, friendly staff, will be coming back again and again.

The Dessert pizza was AWESOME ‼‼(we had apple) wings (honey mustard mediums) are addicting ‼I couldn’t stop eating & that was after the yummy Hawaiian& a sausage calzone (I ate the leftovers today

I absolutely love Daddio’s! The food is delicious but more importantly the owner is so friendly. He is one of the kindest people you will ever meet! He truly loves and cares about his business.
While ordering delivery, the owner apologized for the wait on the phone, which was not long at all! He then engaged in small talk about our neighborhood and how much he loves living here! He then offered a free 2 liter bottle, of our choice! Truly the nicest man.
The pizza is so tasty! The sauce is sweet and they load it with cheese. The pepperoni is perfectly burnt around the edges. Now the most important part, the homemade blue cheese! Guys! It’s AMAZING! Order extra and then order even more! You will not regret it.
Daddio’s encompasses everything a neighborhood pizzeria should!

I’ve ordered delivery from this place a lot since moving to North Buffalo. The owner and his delivery guys are all very nice, chatty, super friendly! The owner has delivered to my house on multiple occasions and he always brings a two liter of Pepsi with him to give to us for free and when I try to tip him, he rejects the tip. I give the tip anyway because I tip for great service regardless.
I’ve tried the pizza, a few subs, fried dough and tacos. The fried dough is served in a pizza box and about the same size as a medium pizza. It’s smothered in butter and white powdered sugar, sinfully delicious. The meat they stuff into the subs and tacos is serious, they’re ridiculously huge and they toast the sub rolls in the oven. I ordered a small taco thinking it would be nice an small and it was large and heavy.
Their steak hoagy is no joke, you’ll never finish it. The only thing I didn’t like was that when I opened it, some of the bread was soggy from the oil/​sauce they put on it. If I ever ate a steak hoagy from there again, I would have to go inside the resturant to eat it so that the bread is still dry and fresh. Nothing worse than soggy bread.
Their pizza sauce is sweet, love it, they load the pizza with lots of cheese and the pepperoni have perfect, burnt rims, nice and crispy cups filled with grease inside! The way pepperoni should be on a pizza! I’m rating this place four stars though because their dough is second rate. Maybe it’s not the dough, maybe it’s the oven, I don’t know but the crust is dry, cracks, reminds me of stale pizza crust and I personally like my pizza dough thick, fluffy towards the end and I always eat the crust. I like the crust to taste like La Nova’s on West Ferry.
Anyhow, compared to top notch pizzerias in Buffalo this pizza is till second rate but one of the best in North Buffalo for sure! If you want the best pizza in Buffalo try Bocce’s Pizza Club on Bailey or Bella’s Pizza or Imperial’s in South Buffalo!
I’ve only had one bad experience with this place while calling, they apologized and called me back. I was understanding because as I mentioned earlier, I’ve order from them multiple times and they’ve been really good to us. However, when I got my pizza, it was over cooked. I just ate it and didn’t call back to complain, figured their day was stressful enough. No biggie.
Hertel Avenue is not a sketchy area (saw someone write that in their review — smh), some of the restaurants aren’t in situated in the greatest of facilities but if you’re in the area don’t be afraid to stop, the neighborhood is safe and the food on the strip is delicious!