Pesci’s Pizza

This place used to be awesome. Food was great and delivery was fast and friendly. However, After having ordered from this place several times a week I accumulated quite a few «Points».
You have to send an E-​mail to the owner to convert points to a card or whatever else you want from the list of crap you can exchange points for.
Well. I managed to convert some points to a gift card but after trying to redeem a years worth of points before it cleared (Clears yearly) I was ignored and no one seemed to know the points system i was referencing. No response from the manager-​owner via Email even after having held a digital conversation only weeks prior.
It is my impression that the owner was not willing to honor the point system. Like I said, the delivery guy had no clue what I was talking about when I asked him about the points.
If you order just save yourself some time and disregard the «point» system they advertise if you order a lot. I am a student of U. B and did order frequently. I have sense advised anyone I told to try Pescis to disregard and advised them of the shitty business ethics.

Although this is called Pesci’s Pizza, I never get the pizza from here. I don’t care for Pesci’s Pizza, I’m a snob for Pizza Plant and their thin crust pizza. But everything else I’ve gotten from Pesci’s is pretty damn okay in my book. And they deliver to my house! And are FAST!
I’ve gotten take-​out from them probably a dozen time or so in the last 8 months. Last time I got it, it was a Saturday night and I was expecting the worst. They surprised me and I learned they bring the A-​team on Saturday nights. Everything I got that evening was perfect.
They toast the subs, I like that. To be fair I am a carb freak and you feed me bread drenched in oil with some cheese and tomatoes (lettuce and meat too) and I’m putty in your hands. But you toast that sub and get the cheese sorta melted? YUM. I normally eat half a sub but if it’s made right, I’ll eat the whole damn thing.
They make a pretty good chicken fingers and fries. My toddler loves the fries (shocker, a child who likes fries) so I get them almost every time. I’m pretty sure they make a chicken finger sub, my husband usually gets those or cheeseburger subs.
I think my *favorite* thing they do though is the char-​BBQed wings. Good Lord, how did I go so much of my life before I discovered the complete glory and awesomeness that is a char-​BBQ wing?!? I like hot wings, don’t get me wrong… but char-​BBQ is where it is at!
They have other things on the menu I get now and then, like the chicken quesadilla or the poppers. This place is a winner for me.

They have a decnt chicken finger personal pizza — very tasty! Their steak hoagies used to be my go to but have been lack luster over the years — including less and less meat with a price that continues to rise.

The chicken wing dip pizza was really awesome! Even good the next day after cooling off in the fridge! Chicken fingers were great and had a turkey sub and it was to die for!

Buffalo wing and buffalo dip pizza are to die for. I remember they were all the rage at wing fest as well. Too bad I live in the city or this place would be a dangerous staple in my diet

Fairly quick delivery, great food, have tried many things like subs, pizza, fingers, even deep fried Oreos (which weren’t too amazing). Nice that you can order online as well and specify exactly what you want. Whenever I call they sound rushed and have made mistakes.

This is in a small strip mall — mainly a pickup place, there are a few tables outside.
I got the two piece pepperoni with drink special and the pizza was very good. Classic Buffalo style with pepperoni grease cups that drip orange on your shirt if you are not careful. BTW, any suggestions on how to get those grease drops out?
Overall it is a place to come back to.

Joe Pesci finally got dumped by sexy Marisa Tomei who ran off with his sports car which she basically built for him, and he drowned his sorrows by opening this pizza place.
There are some amazing pizza places in Buffalo. Why a lot of people in the Clarence and Williamsville areas rate Pesci’s, I have no idea. I appreciate that they are a family business but that is about it. I’m not big on their (usually dry) wings, or their bland, almost sweet pizza. Bozanna’s and Pauly’s were nearby — I’d stick to those places, except that both places have recently closed down… what cruel gods are ye? However if this review was for actor Joe Pesci (or gorgeous Marisa Tomei), then we’d be talking about a ⁵⁄₅.
Buffalo actually has the best Pizza in the world — check my «best Pizza in the world» list to see all the best Buffalo pizza places, lots of my choices are Buffalo based. But this place definitely doesn’t live up to the standards as far as I am concerned.

I eat here often for lunch. They have a great lunch deal: 2 slices of pizza and one can of pop for $ 5 plus tax. Can’t beat it. If you like pizza with a crunchy flat crust, this is your place.

Delicious food. My family and I have gotten pizza, subs, wings, etc. from here for years. This is a great example of a typical «Buffalo pizzeria.» Delicious pizza with just the right amount of toppings. Great crust. On the right night, they have very fast food turnaround. Take-​out only.
On a side note… the bbq sauce they use on wings and subs is horrendously cheap-​tasting and awful. This is «Open Pit» sauce… the cheapest type of bbq sauce available in the mass restaurant market. It’s sweet, very loose, and comes in large paint buckets. Honestly Pesci’s, this sauce is sh*t, and you know it. Terrible way to save a buck. This is why they lose 1 star.

Felt as though I had stepped into some sort of movie when walking into this pizza place. It was overtaken by teenagers, a large amount of teenagers, with no adults in sight. But the old saying «Don’t judge a book by it’s cover» came into effect, just watching them work they all seemed to share roles, taking turns looking at the pizza, answering phones, and preparing the pizzas. They even brought our pizza out to our car for us where we were waiting, I thought that was nice!
Delicious pizza! Generous toppings, delicious cheese, and great crust! Will definitely go back again!

Sweet tasting sauce on pizza. The amount of sauce is not overdone. Overall, a very good Western New York style pizza.