Plumpeez Deli

My bride & I returned a few nights after the online debacle to seriously give the place a try. The space is a former custom framing shop (which I once used to get my professional license matted and framed) in a nondescript metal building.
Upon arriving, we noticed someone come to the door to unlock it. I get it since the parking lot is dark and the building isn’t well lit. Good idea to keep it locked after dark until a customer gets there if you ask me.
Coney Island — it’s a pastrami sandwich, but with american cheese and on a hoagie roll — delicious.
It’s what they didn’t have that I found somewhat disappointing. The deli case seemed nearly bare, and there was no pepperoni for my bride’s 6^th Avenue. We opted for another meat instead. There was also no Gabilla Knish. This got me to wondering if showing up later in the evening is a bad idea due to food running out for the day or we just picked a bad night, or they were waiting on deliveries.
In any event, we enjoyed the food. Plumpeez could very easily compete with Jimmy John’s as far as flavor and freshness of the sandwiches, despite JJ’s seeming to have a little more variety for condiments and sandwich extras. It’s worth not having to drive to JJ’s in Brier Creek, RTP or anywhere 15 – 20 miles away and just go over to Plumpeez for some similar sandwiches.
They will deliver, but only for a $ 40 minimum order, and a 15% gratuity will automatically be added to the delivery order.
Nice addition to Butner.

Talk about, «About Time»! Plumpeez brings New York to Butner NC and I’m loving it. Finally one can get a delicious Boar’s head deli made sub in this small town.
For this visit I had the pleasure of not only meeting the owner, whom by the way is from Brooklyn NY, but I also experienced great customer service. They prepared for me the pastrami sub loaded with meat and graced with Boar’s Head yellow American cheese. The roll purchased from a local bakery was soft and fresh almost as good as the amoroso bread in Philadelphia.
Sadly they do not have fresh fountain drinks as of yet but they do have a decent selection of canned or bottled coke products. While I enjoyed my sub I also learned that they can sell the deli meats by the pound. Good bye Harris teeter your subs have met their match and Plumpeez subs are by far better.
Clearly if one is in the area whether you are hungry or not, just be hungry and give Plumpeez a try.