Plus One Pizza

Order pizza from here fairly regularly. To me it tastes a bit like a sweet type sauce, large portions for your money, and all around friendly. Never had a bad experience here!

We got take out from this pizzeria. It was absolutely terrible.
We ordered online. The online didn’t show Alfredo sauce, but my father in law assured me there was. So I ordered no sauce with the intent to call and have the put it on. (Which if Alfredo sauce is an option, it should be listed as such.) Well I forgot. I remembered when we got there. Our order wasn’t all the way ready, so I asked some Alfredo be put on it. The waitress (very rude) said no. I insisted, so she rolled her eyes and went to the back. (I ended up getting my sauce, though not much.)
I asked for it to have chicken added. They gave me a container of nasty, rubbery, COLD chicken. No lie. I had to heat it in the microwave. (Their plastic wear is not microwaveable btw.)
Got a salad-​croutons were stale. No takeout silver wear like I had asked.
The only thing that was decent– and even it was average at best– was the cheese pizza my fiancé got.
I never want to go back to this place. Rude service, cold food, stale food, the restaurant itself looked tired and worn.

My boyfriend and I were here doing a obstacle course race. Being all tired we just wanted some good pizza and wings delivered to the hotel. Simple order: pepperoni pizza and garlic wings (extra crispy)
The pizza was sub par– it seemed as though it sat for awhile before they delivered it. The cheese was good, but the rest wasn’t great.
The wings were super soggy– not extra crispy.
Feeling disappointed as this was recommended as the best pizza around.

food is great. has been a local place many years. décor is a little tired but clean for most part and friendly staff. worth visiting and is one of better pizzas in area

We were driving from VA to IN and decided to stop off to eat and avoid Columbus rush hour. Stopping here was by accident as we thought we had sent to GPS to another place but we decided we were here and we were hungry, so we stayed.
It was early for dinner on a Thursday afternoon so there were few people there, something to appreciate when escaping a major metropolis. I was just saying how the place reminded me of going out for pizza back home (MI) where they bring you pepsi in a red plastic cup with crushed ice, and guess what was delivered right after I said that?!
We had the cheesy bread and had them make the pizza half supreme and half Hawaiian. On both it was just like I like it. Bubbly and gooey but not yet turned brown (I do not like cheese that is crunchy). The waitress was very nice and the air conditioning felt nice on the 90 degree day. As we left we noticed they have a drive through, similar to several other places in this tiny town. They must be in a rush here:)