Johnnys Pizzeria

My family has a hard time finding a pizza we all can agree on but we found it with Johnny’s I love it I have had it several times but this was the first for them and they still talk about it definitely order from them again also got a great deal from the local flavor app

I know owners changed recently. Johnny no longer owns. That being said the pizza now is quite good. Usually pick up and always have polite service. The Elk card got me back but the pizza keeps me going !!

Great NY style pizza. Staff normally have a I don’t care attitude but that doesn’t keep me away. You can’t go wrong with an 18″ pepperoni or a stuffed pie!

The pizza is about as true to a NY pizza as you will get here in the Dayton area. The crust is a thin crust with tons of cheese on it. I like the small pizza shop vibe that you get from them. Its really nice. The pizza was so greasy though! Man I thought I was going to lay comatose on the floor after the first bite so I decided to use a napkin to absorption some of it. Now I will say I’m a little health nut and sometimes choose to induldge every so often with something like this. So my reaction to this will be different than someone else I’m sure. That’s the reason I took off one star. So Johnny you get 4 out of 5 from me!

Pizza is generic. Not even the best pizza in town. The local grocery store, Earth Fare has much better pizza.
Has community appeal, decent pizza. Nothing special. Good to grab a quick bite to eat.

This is one of my favorite place for pizza in Dayton. I used to go all the time when i was in high school and still head over when i can. The staff is very friendly and thankful for my business overtime I go here. If you are wanting a nice place to get pizza by the slice like in New York this is a great place to go in Centerville.

new to the area and was looking for some local pizza. really enjoyed the pie, as it was hot and ready to go for pickup when they said it would be ready. thought it was a bit pricey for a two topping pizza but I was very satisfied with the product none the less. will definitely be back to return!

New York style in Ohio? — Fuggedaboudit, they aced it. Nice people, good service, and convenient parking.

I have had Johnny’s in the past and liked it so I called ahead to order the Brooklyn Brawler since I figured it would take extra time. An hour and a half later I arrived to pick up the pizza. I live 30 minutes away so I was hoping it would be hot. As luck would have it the pizza was coming out of the oven as I arrived so I knew the pizza was hot, good right? Well when I got home I began to eat a slice. I like ranch dressing with my pizza so I was dipping the slice in the cold ranch dressing. It took me several bites to realize that the sausage was ice cold in the middle. My son had already scarffed down 2 pieces and hadnt noticed, he’s 15, go figure. I told him not to eat anymore because I was worried that if the sausage wasnt precooked we may be eating raw pork. I called Johnny’s and spoke with a lady who assured me that all the ingredients were made fresh and fully cooked. I explained the situation and my concern with potentially eating raw/​undercooked sausage. She offered to make me a 12″ pizza for free but as i said I live 30 minutes away. I ended up putting my next slice in the microwave. It wasnt a good pizza and after paying $ 27 + a $ 2 tip, I must say I’m less than pleased.

Great New York style pizza! Actually had a seating area too! Crust was soft and delicious. Just the right amount of sauce and cheese… perfectly balanced to yield a flavorful experience. Great little joint in downtown centerville. Get a great pizza here!

The Worst! I threw it away and walked out. How bad does pizza have to be for you to throw it out? The WORST.
I like local non chain restaurants so I wanted to, give this place a shot. It’s pizza. I love pizza. Not their pizza.
They have decent reviews but I was the only person in the whole place. While I waited for them to reheat my pizza I used their bathroom. Woof! That was disgusting too.
Go to Flying Pizza down the street. It’s great pizza and they actually clean.

My one star is because they shut down their Springboro location, didn’t update their website, and now do not offer delivery… not a good way to run a pizza business.

Best breadsticks I’ve had in years, excellent Stromboli and amazing NY style pizza. A must try if your a Dayton local or are passing through from a city known for pizza!

Love Johnny’s! Best pizza in town. The garlic crust is delicious and they are always super friendly when you pick it up. It’s a little pricey, but if you only have pizza every once in a while like us, it’s worth the splurge! We get veggies on ours and they always load ‘em up!

Honestly, I just don’t see how this is any different than an average pizza place. It was okay and that’s about all that can be said. It was a little more pricey than a chain-​place, which I am okay with, as long as they deliver on taste. I would say this pizza was average, so I would eat it again, but I wouldn’t seek it out.

Now this is a very good pizza. I would highly recommend it. Some of the best pizza you can get this from like mom-​and-​pop shops and this is one of those.
Pizzas taste great and the employees are very nice.

Really solid New York style pizza! Sold by the slice or by the whole pie. Toppings are abundant and fresh and the crust is just right for folding, big floppy slices. The breadsticks were pretty fantastic also! Very friendly service to boot! Bonus for being locally owned, you can tell lots of love and pride go into their food. Check them out!

I normally don’t give out 5-​stars, but I love me some Johnny’s Pizzeria! First time here, I was greeted by the kitchen staff and helped to make a selection. The Park Avenue stromboli was awesome. It contained chicken, ranch, italian herbs, and cheese, I’m sure. It came recommended and was well worth the leap of faith. I came for the pizza though, so I ordered a medium supreme in addition to the stromboli. It came out first and is possibly the best supreme pizza I’ve ever had (at least in living memory). I don’t know what made it so good, but it was probably a combination of these things: The toppings (to include the green peppers and olives) were fresh and tasty. They weren’t just there for decoration, but packed a powerful, tasty punch. The cheese was very stretchy and cheesy. It was like «Ninja Turtle» pizza because, upon pulling a slice from the pie, it stretched three inches or so before coming undone. Also the bread was light and foldable. I ate half the pizza before I realized I had eaten the crust of each piece I’d had. Normally I don’t eat the crust, or will make an effort to try it, taste it, and test it, before leaving it by the wayside. At Johnny’s the crust was so good I forgot about it being there. All this in addition to the welcoming atmosphere and great service. I wanted to go back the next day, on Sunday, but realized they were closed. Sometime soon though, sometime soon.

Damn I miss this place! You guys still doing the $ 6 double slice and a soda deal? I need some decent pizza and soon!

If I could choose any place in the Dayton area to eat every night, this would be it, without a doubt. Unfortunately, my thighs declare otherwise.
As a native east-​coaster, I have struggled to find GOOD pizza here in Ohio. Now, if one is in to thin-​crust cardboard pizza, sure… you will have no problem finding that here. But true pizza to me means NY style large enough to fold. Johnny’s is just that.
I normally opt for just pepperoni and cheese and it often only takes them 10 minutes from the time I place the order. You can also order by the slice.
You have the option to carry out or eat inside. They have a nice, but casual sitting area with a TV. They appear to be very involved with the schools in the area as you see sports posters plastered all over the place.
I can not rave about this place enough. If you are craving some New York style pizza and live in the Dayton area… you should definitely check out Johnny’s.